Sarah Michelle Gellar and Freddie Prinze Jr. have discovered that their families were connected long before they ever met.
During a conversation with E! News on Friday, November 21, Gellar, 49, shared that the couple recently uncovered an unexpected link through Ancestry—one that has made their already remarkable love story feel even more intertwined.
“We always joke that the closest connection I had to my husband’s side of the family was that, for a short time, I went to the same high school that his dad attended,” the Buffy the Vampire Slayer star said. “That was sort of our one connection.”
But their genealogy research revealed something far more surprising. “Through Ancestry, we found out that our grandparents lived less than two miles from each other in the Bronx at one point,” Gellar explained. “They could have potentially known each other. That’s kind of crazy.”
Gellar grew up in New York, while Prinze Jr., 49, was born in Los Angeles and raised in New Mexico. His late father, comedian Freddie Prinze, hailed from New York, making the discovery about their grandparents all the more remarkable.
The couple first crossed paths on the set of the 1997 horror film I Know What You Did Last Summer. Their relationship did not begin as a romance, however. A series of road trips helped them form a close friendship before anything more developed.
“She didn’t have a driver’s license. She didn’t know how to drive,” Prinze Jr. told Us exclusively in April 2020, remembering the early days of their connection.

Freddie Prinze Jr. and Sarah Michelle Gellar. (Photo by Claire Greenway/Getty Images)
“We were filming in Southport, North Carolina, about an hour from Wilmington, the nearest major city,” he recalled. “So I started driving her, and that’s when we became friends.”
The She’s All That actor said their conversations covered “life” and the “completely different philosophies” they held on nearly everything.
“By the end of the movie, I just wanted to be friends with her because I thought she was too skinny and wanted to cook for her,” Prinze Jr. said. “That’s what my family does.”
“So we started this weekly barbecue at her house. My cousins and I would come over, cook for her and her friends, and make sure everyone ate,” he continued. “That was really how our friendship began.”
The friendship eventually blossomed into love. Gellar and Prinze Jr. married in 2002 and later welcomed daughter Charlotte in 2009 and son Rocky in 2012.
The longtime couple have also shared the screen several times. They starred together in Scooby-Doo in 2002 and returned for Scooby-Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed in 2004. Gellar additionally made a brief appearance in Prinze Jr.’s 1999 romantic comedy She’s All That, and both actors had separate cameo appearances in Clerks III in 2022.
Relive the year’s most memorable moments in Us magazine’s 2026 Year in Review, a special edition celebrating the biggest stories in music, television and film that captivated audiences worldwide. Click here to buy a copy—whether it’s for a pop culture-loving friend or for yourself!

