Man Accused of Mailing Peanut Butter Card to Ex-Wife’s Allergic Friend

Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr. (Broward County Jail). A Florida man allegedly mailed a greeting card smeared with peanut butter to his ex-wife’s best friend, who...
HomeCrimeParents Arrested After Boy Shoots Himself With Gun, Police Say

Parents Arrested After Boy Shoots Himself With Gun, Police Say

William David Howard Jr. and Jennifer McGrath Butler (Wake County Detention Center via WRAL).

North Carolina parents are accused of leaving loaded firearms within reach of their children, resulting in the accidental shooting death of their 14-year-old son just days before his 15th birthday.

William David Howard Jr., 52, and Jennifer McGrath Butler, 49, face charges of negligent child abuse resulting in serious bodily injury in connection with the death of William Oscar Howard.

According to arrest warrants, Howard allegedly “provided the child and his 13-year-old brother with multiple firearms,” while Butler allegedly left the boys alone in the home with the weapons. The warrants describe the conduct as a “willful act and grossly negligent omission” and allege that both parents showed a “reckless disregard for human life.”

The warrants offered few additional details, but a temporary restraining order seeking permanent custody that Howard filed against Butler provides more information about the circumstances surrounding the boy’s death.

The order states that Butler was responsible for the children on Aug. 18 at her home in Angier under the couple’s shared custody arrangement. Howard alleged, however, that Butler left the boys alone overnight and traveled to a beach about two hours away with her boyfriend.

“Upon information and belief, in the last few months Defendant has regularly left the minor children alone overnight to spend time with her boyfriend,” the order stated.

At approximately 8 p.m., William allegedly discovered a loaded firearm on the kitchen table. The order says an “accidental shooting occurred,” killing the teenager. His 13-year-old brother was reportedly in his bedroom at the time.

Police responded to the home and pronounced William dead at the scene.

The residence was allegedly in “deplorable” condition, with empty alcohol bottles and spoiled food found in multiple rooms. Authorities recovered seven firearms from the home, according to the order.

Howard claimed Butler was “not fit to care” for the surviving child and asked the court to award him custody. He later dismissed the complaint without providing an explanation.

William’s obituary confirms his identity and notes that he would have turned 15 three days after his death.

“Oscar had a remarkable number of interests and talents. He loved planes and flying games, Dungeons & Dragons, video games, history, and intricate model kits,” the obituary states. “He could lose himself in the details of almost anything that captured his imagination.”

Both parents have been released from jail after posting bond. Howard is scheduled to appear before a judge on Dec. 15, while Butler’s next court hearing is set for Jan. 19.