Few foods are as closely associated with unhealthy eating as the humble McDonald’s chicken nugget.
Greasy, salty and highly processed, nuggets are often assumed to be made from the less desirable parts of a chicken. For years, they have represented the very definition of junk food.
But nutrition experts say that reputation may be harsher than the facts justify.
Six McNuggets contain 261 calories, 1.5g of saturated fat and a notable 15g of protein, making them a surprisingly reasonable choice when compared with some chicken products that appear healthier.
They are also made with chicken breast meat, rather than the skin, bones and miscellaneous scraps many people imagine are used.
So would you be better off choosing chicken goujons, tenders or grilled chicken slices instead?
And how do the increasingly popular plant-based alternatives measure up?
Here, dietitians assess some of the best-selling chicken products on the High Street to identify the healthiest options and compare them with the original McDonald’s Chicken McNugget.
So how do they compare with alternative nuggets and chicken products?
Sainsbury’s Breaded Chicken Goujons
Per four goujons: 365 calories, 23.3g protein, 3.1g saturated fat, 3.1g sugar, less than 0.5g fibre and 0.7g salt.
Chicken goujons are slim strips of breast meat coated in breadcrumbs and pre-fried. They may be less processed than some nuggets, but they can also contain more fat and calories.
A serving of these goujons has 104 more calories and more than double the saturated fat found in six McDonald’s nuggets.
They also contain considerably more sugar and much less fibre, which is important for digestive health.
Their main nutritional advantage is protein: the portion provides more than 50 per cent extra compared with six nuggets, which could help you feel full for longer.
Dietitian Sophie Medlin, of CityDietitians, recommends checking the packaging to see how the chicken has been prepared.
‘Many products are pre-fried before you cook them in the oven or air fryer,’ she says.
As a result, the coating may already contain a considerable amount of fat, even if no additional oil is used during cooking at home.
And although goujons are commonly made from whole strips of chicken breast, that alone does not make them healthier than nuggets.
Tesco’s Southern Fried Chicken Tenders
Per fillet: 348 calories, 27.1g protein, 1.2g saturated fat, 0.3g sugar, 1.7g fibre and 1.1g salt.
Chicken tenders are generally made from the tenderloin, the narrow strip of meat located beneath the breast.
Tesco’s version contains 71 per cent chicken, making it one of the most protein-rich choices in this comparison.
One serving offers almost twice as much protein as six McDonald’s nuggets, along with slightly less saturated fat.
It does, however, contain 87 more calories.
Salt is the more significant drawback.
With 1.1g per serving, the tender contains more than twice the salt found in six McNuggets. That is almost one-fifth of the 6g daily maximum recommended for adults.
Tenders may therefore suit anyone prioritising protein, but they are not the strongest choice for people trying to cut down on salt.
McDonald’s Chicken Selects
Per three strips: 336 calories, 23g protein, 1.6g saturated fat, 1.4g fibre and 1.6g salt.
Chicken Selects are McDonald’s take on the chicken tender and are made from strips of breast meat.
A three-strip serving contains 75 more calories than six McNuggets, but delivers about 50 per cent more protein.
The saturated fat levels are also very similar.
For anyone seeking a more filling, protein-rich option, Chicken Selects might appear to be the clear winner.
The salt content, however, changes the picture.
Three Selects contain 1.6g of salt, more than three times the amount in six nuggets and over a quarter of an adult’s recommended daily maximum.
So although Selects provide more protein, McNuggets may be the better option for anyone monitoring their salt intake.
Wasabi Chicken Katsu Fillets
Per fillet: 435 calories, 26.2g protein, 1.8g saturated fat, 1.3g sugar, 0g fibre and 1.4g salt.
Traditional chicken katsu is made by flattening chicken breast, coating it in panko breadcrumbs and frying it until crisp.
Panko has a lighter, flakier texture than standard breadcrumbs, although the amount of oil absorbed varies according to how the chicken is prepared and cooked.
At 435 calories, the Wasabi chicken katsu fillet is the highest-calorie product in this comparison.
It contains 174 more calories than six McNuggets, while also providing substantially more protein.
Sophie Medlin says the foods served alongside the chicken should also be considered when assessing the nutritional value of the meal.
‘Serving it with rice, vegetables and broth creates a more nutritionally complete meal than chicken goujons, which might be served with chips.’
The fillet itself contains no fibre, however, and its 1.4g of salt is almost three times the amount found in six McNuggets.
La Vie Tofu Nuggets
Per five nuggets: 264 calories, 13g protein, 1.7g saturated fat, 3.1g fibre, 0.5g sugar and 1g salt.
For people looking to reduce their meat consumption, tofu nuggets may seem like an obvious healthier substitute.
They do offer some nutritional benefits.
Five La Vie tofu nuggets contain about the same number of calories and a similar amount of saturated fat as six McNuggets, but provide more than twice the fibre—roughly the amount found in a banana.
They contain slightly less protein, though, and twice as much salt.
Ms Medlin says tofu itself is a nutritious food.
‘It provides plant protein and minerals, but once tofu is turned into a nugget, its healthiness depends heavily on the recipe, just as it does with chicken.
‘If it is heavily battered and fried, it can still be high in fat, salt and calories.’
In short, replacing chicken with tofu does not automatically make a nugget-based meal healthier.