New research into two of Christianity’s most closely examined relics is reigniting debate over whether they could be linked to the burial and resurrection accounts of Jesus.
The Shroud of Turin, which carries the faint image of a crucified man, and the smaller, bloodstained Sudarium of Oviedo have both been associated with the body wrappings and head covering mentioned in the Gospel story of the empty tomb.
Researchers detected unusually high concentrations of calcium, a principal component of limestone, near the area believed to correspond to the Sudarium’s nose. Similar deposits had previously been reported on the Shroud.
The ratio of strontium to calcium in those deposits more closely matched limestone from Calvary in Jerusalem—the traditional site of Jesus’ crucifixion—than material from the Spanish cathedral where the Sudarium has been preserved. The researchers said the result may indicate that at least some of the dust came from Jerusalem, supporting the possibility that the two cloths once covered the same body.
Separate experiments indicated that bandages could have held the Sudarium against a head and directed bodily fluids across the fabric, potentially accounting for the patterns of staining.
Researchers are also conducting preliminary comparisons to determine whether the stains correspond to wounds visible on the Shroud. Their reconstruction places the Sudarium over the man’s head before the body was wrapped in the Shroud.
Pedro Peinado, whose doctoral work at the University of Oviedo examines the relationship between the fabrics, said the apparent injuries, consistency with first-century Jewish burial practices and parallels with the Gospels make Jesus the leading candidate.
“That this body was that of Jesus of Nazareth is a conclusion science cannot sign off on by itself,” he told the Daily Mail.
The smaller, bloodstained Sudarium has long been linked to the separate body wrappings and head covering described in the Gospel account of Jesus’ empty tomb
The Shroud of Turin is traditionally believed to have covered Jesus’ dead body, with Christians associating its image with the resurrection
Biblical scholar Jeremiah Johnston argues that the evidence raises a second question—not only whose body the cloths covered, but how the body could have left them behind.
Johnston, who was not part of the research team, bases his resurrection argument on broader claims about the Shroud’s condition, including the apparent lack of decomposition marks and what he describes as undisturbed blood clots.
He said those features suggest the body remained wrapped for only a short time and that the linen was not forcibly removed from the wounds.
“This is where it gets hard for the skeptic,” Johnston said. “Pull a cloth off a wounded body and you tear and smear them. That did not happen here.”
In Johnston’s view, those observations, combined with the proposed relationship between the fabrics, are consistent with the Gospel account of an empty tomb and what he called “a body that did not stay dead.”
“But he left something behind in that tomb,” Johnston said. “Two cloths, and no body.”
The Shroud contains front and rear images of a man. The Sudarium, kept at Oviedo Cathedral in Spain, is marked by stains but does not display a recognizable face.
“I often say that the Shroud is an image without an explanation, and the Sudarium is an explanation without an image,” Peinado said.
The proposed reconstruction places the Sudarium over the man’s head before his body was wrapped in the Shroud. Experiments indicated that pressure from bandages could have directed bodily fluids across the covering, helping explain the formation of its stains
The mineral analysis was described in a 2015 study published in SHS Web of Conferences by researchers including specialists from the Spanish Center of Sindonology and the University of Oviedo.
The researchers set out to determine whether deposits on the Sudarium could reveal where it had been used and provide another basis for comparison with the Shroud.
On March 9 and 10, 2012, co-author Rodrigo Álvarez conducted 57 X-ray fluorescence readings across the Sudarium. The technique identifies chemical elements by measuring how they respond to X-rays.
The instrument was calibrated with modern and historic linen, including fabric dusted with calcium carbonate. The tests showed that heavier dusting produced stronger calcium readings.
The team then compared calcium concentrations at 38 bloodstained locations with readings from 16 relatively clean areas of the cloth.
Bloodstained sections averaged 20,423 parts per million of calcium, compared with 15,348 parts per million in the cleaner areas—roughly one-third more. The difference was statistically significant at the 95 percent confidence level.
One measurement reached 50,393 parts per million, about 2.7 times the overall average. Two nearby readings were also exceptionally high.
Images from the 2015 study show calcium deposits detected on both the Sudarium and the Shroud
When the Sudarium’s stains were aligned with the Shroud’s facial image, the high readings appeared near the tip of the nose—an area the authors regarded as an unusual place for concentrated dirt to collect.
Earlier research on the Shroud, including X-ray measurements published in 1980, had also identified calcium and dirt around the nose area.
The authors suggested that wet bodily fluids may have trapped mineral particles, accounting for the higher calcium levels in stained regions.
“Dust that lands on a wet cloth sticks where the cloth is wet. So the pattern points back to the day the stains were made,” Johnston said.
The researchers next compared strontium-to-calcium ratios with limestone samples taken from Calvary in Jerusalem and Oviedo Cathedral.
The Sudarium’s measurements more closely resembled the Calvary samples, especially in areas bearing stains.
Using that two-source comparison, the researchers estimated that more than 75 percent of the limestone dust could have come from Calvary. However, the chemical evidence did not establish a unique geographic origin.
“This cloth has sat in Oviedo for a thousand years. It has been handled, displayed and stored in that building for centuries. If the dust on it were simply cathedral dust, it would look like the cathedral,” Johnston said.
“It doesn’t. It looks far more like Jerusalem.”
“Dirt on the same nose. Dust that resembles Jerusalem. Stains that fit the same wounds. Each one makes it harder to say these are two unrelated cloths.”
Pedro Peinado, whose doctoral research at the University of Oviedo mathematically compares the fabrics, says the apparent injuries, first-century burial customs and Gospel parallels together make Jesus the strongest candidate
The 2015 paper also revisited earlier research suggesting that the Sudarium had been secured around blood-covered hair, possibly explaining the apparent ponytail seen on the Shroud image.
Volunteer tests reproduced the stiffening effect that occurs as blood dries in hair. Two parallel rows of holes in the Sudarium were interpreted as possible evidence of stitching.
MORE ON THIS: DNI Clayton Warns Putin Is No Friend to America in Ukraine
Researchers also identified two small marks as possible scourge wounds based on their size and spacing. Taken together, the authors said, the findings supported the longstanding tradition that both cloths had covered Jesus.
Discussing the possibility that the fabrics share an origin, Peinado said independently created relics would pose another challenge: “They would have to explain how two pieces, kept more than a thousand kilometers apart and with different documentary histories, share the same ‘map’ of wounds without one having been copied from the other.”
“The Sudarium has no image—it has only stains.”
While the mineral work investigated a possible link between the fabrics, a separate study examined how the Sudarium might have been fastened around a head and how its stains could have developed.
That study, led by Peinado and colleagues, was published online on August 25, 2026, in the Journal of Cultural Heritage.
The researchers combined detailed image analysis with experiments involving a head model covered in linen, bandages and a blood substitute heated to body temperature.
By changing the position of the model’s head, they produced patterns comparable to marks on the Sudarium, suggesting pressure could direct fluid toward specific points.
The 2015 paper proposed that wrapping the Sudarium around blood-soaked hair could explain the apparent ponytail shown on the Shroud
The results indicated that bandaging was a plausible explanation, but they did not prove it was responsible for the original stains.
The authors also noted important limitations: the model did not include hair, and the experimental linen differed from the historic cloth.
A nine-hour examination of the original Sudarium on July 2 produced additional images and measurements for future research. Investigators used imaging, three-dimensional scanning and X-ray fluorescence without taking samples from the cloth.
“Seeing the original with modern instruments changes the way you look at it,” Peinado said.
“The morphology of the wrinkles, in the areas we had predicted, was fully consistent with the hypothesis that the Sudarium was secured to the executed man’s head by external pressure: bandages, cords or something similar.”
The published paper examined the Sudarium alone and did not compare it directly with the Shroud. Peinado’s mathematical comparison of the two fabrics remains separate and preliminary.
He is using computer analysis to compare the shape and position of stains, testing whether they could have originated from the same wounds around the forehead and back of the head.
“Without forming an image, those stains match the geometry of the wounds on the Shroud,” he said.
“The stains need not be identical; in fact, they cannot be, because they formed in different circumstances.”
The proposed sequence places the body upright and then inclined beneath the Sudarium, followed by a face-up position beneath the Shroud—different orientations that would have altered how fluids spread.
“If it is confirmed—and we are very close to publishing it—the hypothesis of the same face will be greatly strengthened,” Peinado said.
“Taken individually, each correspondence could be debated. Taken together, they are very difficult to attribute to chance.”
He added a note of caution: “A poorly verified piece of data does more harm than one that has not yet been released.”
Johnston connected the proposed matches and earlier interpretations of the fabrics’ markings with the Gospel descriptions of Jesus’ death.
“The Shroud shows more than a hundred scourge marks. It shows puncture wounds across the scalp, nail wounds in the wrists and feet, and a wound in the side that bled after death. The legs are not broken,” he said.
Referring to earlier forensic interpretations of the Sudarium, he added: “The Sudarium adds its own testimony. The Spanish team that studied it found blood mixed with fluid from the lungs, which is what you get from a man who died upright, fighting to breathe. That is crucifixion.”
Earlier reports identified type AB blood on both fabrics, although a matching blood type cannot establish the identity of the person who wore them.
“Any one of those could be coincidence. Together they are hard to dismiss,” Johnston said.
A biblical scholar said the findings provide additional evidence supporting the belief that Jesus rose from the dead
Peinado stressed that identifying the deceased as Jesus remains an interpretation based on the evidence as a whole.
“None of them is sufficient on its own. Together, in my view, they make the identification with Jesus the most coherent hypothesis. But it remains a hypothesis,” he said.
The dating of both cloths remains contested. Radiocarbon tests conducted in 1988 placed the sampled Shroud linen between 1260 and 1390 AD, while Peinado said estimates for the Sudarium placed it between the seventh and eighth centuries.
He described dating as the principal scientific objection and questioned the selection of samples and the possibility of contamination.
“Our work does not seek to refute carbon-14 dating. It seeks to provide data that any explanation will have to account for,” he said.
Johnston said evidence that the two fabrics covered the same person would conflict with the medieval dating of the Shroud.
“So if these two cloths covered the same face, the Shroud cannot be medieval,” he said.
“One bloodstained face cannot be both seventh century and 14th century. The match breaks the 1988 date, and it does so even on the skeptic’s own number for the Sudarium.”
Neither study re-dated either relic or overturned the 1988 radiocarbon findings. Even a confirmed link between the cloths and the same body would raise questions about the conflicting dates, but it would not independently prove which dating was incorrect or establish a first-century origin.
Johnston called for modern testing under identical conditions, saying: “Put fibers from both cloths under the same instrument, in the same lab, with stone from Jerusalem, Oviedo and every stop in between.”
Peinado separates the physical investigation from questions of religious belief.
“Our findings neither support nor refute the resurrection,” he said. “Science can study a body, its wounds, its death and its burial. What happened afterwards belongs to the realm of faith.”
For believers, he described the Sudarium as “a silent witness to that morning.”