Few situations leave people more vulnerable than lying on an operating table.
Patients already face anxiety about the procedure itself, the risk of infection and the uncertainty of recovery. For those scheduled for surgery at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, those fears are likely to be even more acute.
Whistleblower Dr Mohammed Habib has described a picture of clinical failure surrounding hepatobiliary surgery — operations involving the liver, gallbladder and bile ducts — in which 19 patients died.
His intervention last week, supported by the release of internal documents, has left the Scottish Government with little choice but to act.
Over the weekend, Health Secretary Angela Constance announced “an urgent and fully independent review” into what happened. She said: “Patient safety and high-quality care must always be the first concern of all those who work in, and with, the NHS.”
It must be. But is it always?
Dr Habib’s evidence raises serious doubts, and those doubts will remain over NHS Grampian until the review publishes its findings and its recommendations are demonstrably implemented.
To a degree, health service leaders can depend on the deep loyalty to the NHS instilled in many Britons from childhood. Do not make a fuss. Nurses are already overwhelmed. At least it is not like America, where people who cannot pay are supposedly left without care.
Health Secretary Angela Constance has ordered an “urgent” review
That unquestioning allegiance to a mediocre healthcare bureaucracy can survive only so many scandals before public patience runs out and those in charge are held to account.
No amount of loyalty to the NHS can persuade patients to dismiss 19 potentially avoidable deaths — deaths that could have involved them or someone close to them. They may yet do so. Trust can disappear in moments, while restoring it can take years.
NHS Grampian has serious questions to answer, but responsibility does not end there.
Dr Habib said he wrote to the government on four occasions, including three letters addressed personally to the First Minister, to raise concerns. He was not satisfied with the replies.
Nor is the public likely to be satisfied. Despite those repeated warnings, John Swinney and his ministers said nothing. A 2022 NHS Grampian report concluded that 19 of 31 deaths during liver, gallbladder and bile duct operations had been avoidable. Ministers knew of the findings, yet patients were not given that information.
Governments are rarely eager to embrace transparency, but this administration has repeatedly been accused of resisting it. Ministers spent years deflecting and minimising warnings about infection control at Glasgow’s Queen Elizabeth University Hospital. Parliamentary questions and damaging reports were met with obstruction, rehearsed responses and the familiar refrain of devolved Scotland: “Things are worse in Wales.”
It took the courage and persistence of two women, Kimberly Darroch and Louise Slorance, both of whose lives were devastated by the hospital, to keep pressing for answers until they were heard.
Kimberly lost her ten-year-old daughter, Milly Main. Milly had leukaemia and received stem-cell therapy at the Queen Elizabeth in 2017. Although the transplant was successful, she contracted the fatal infection stenotrophomonas maltophilia through medical tubing.
Louise’s husband, Andrew, was a 49-year-old Scottish Government employee who underwent a stem-cell transplant at the Queen Elizabeth for blood cancer. Six weeks later, in December 2020, he died from pneumonia associated with Covid.
MORE STORY: Ex-Cop Claims ‘Allah Told Me’ After Killing Young Jogger
His wife said that, despite his compromised immune system, Andrew was transferred to a Covid ward. Aspergillus mould was also found in his system.
The deaths of Milly and Andrew are now being examined by the Crown Office as possible corporate homicide cases. The review also includes the deaths of Gail Armstrong, 73, Molly Cuddihy, 23, Tony Dynes, 63, and two children, aged three and ten, whose identities have not been disclosed.
In time, the Crown Office may also be required to examine some of the 19 deaths at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary.
The prosecutorial process of establishing the facts can be lengthy and demanding — and, in the interests of justice, it should be. It will be for the law officers to decide whether there is sufficient evidence to bring charges. Prosecutions with little prospect of success cannot be used simply to answer public anger or ease patients’ fears.
Whistleblower Dr Mohammed Habib (right) with lawyer Aamer Anwar
Yet when patients die because of clinical mistakes or inadequate infection control, the absence of corporate homicide prosecutions can itself make it harder to confront the underlying failures.
The Royal College of Emergency Medicine estimates that 818 excess deaths in Scotland were linked to A&E waits of more than 12 hours in 2024. If more than 800 people died in one year while waiting for emergency assistance from the police or fire service, there would be demands for public inquiries.
Preventing avoidable hospital deaths is not simply a question of increased funding or improved organisation. Without meaningful deterrents — including, where appropriate, corporate homicide prosecutions — patients will continue to die unnecessarily or have their lives needlessly shortened.
Clinicians and support staff operate within rules set by hospitals; hospitals work within frameworks established by health boards; and health boards are governed by ministerial decisions. Corporate homicide investigations that focus only on an individual hospital or health board risk allowing those who shaped the wider system to escape scrutiny.
When a death can be traced directly to a ministerial instruction — such as ordering the discharge of particular patients to high-risk environments during a pandemic — that decision should be considered as part of any criminal investigation.
Likewise, ministers should face scrutiny where they ignore warnings from a health board or whistleblower, or withhold information from patients when disclosure is clearly in the public interest.
The weak legislation that introduced “legally binding” waiting-time targets — associated with Nicola Sturgeon’s government — should also be strengthened through fines when targets are repeatedly missed.
The money raised should be directed into a restitution fund, allowing patients to seek compensation where they can show that delayed treatment caused an adverse medical outcome.
If avoidable deaths carry no meaningful consequences, they will continue. If ministerial secrecy and inaction go unpunished, both will remain familiar features of government. Scotland’s devolved system has become a model of weak accountability, with ministers operating under limited effective scrutiny from Holyrood and the civil service.
Patients and their families cannot wait for Westminster to find the interest — or the courage — to address the failures of Holyrood. They need meaningful change now. Opposition parties should make patient safety a priority by introducing legislation with proper sanctions for those responsible for avoidable clinical deaths and for those who conceal information about them.
The SNP and Greens may vote against it. If they do, they should be left to explain publicly why they opposed stronger safeguards and justice for patients. People are already vulnerable when they undergo surgery. They should not also have to fear dying unnecessarily on the operating table.
The people responsible for preventable deaths are the ones who should be worried.