Dear Amanda,
I’m a woman in my late 40s and I’ve fallen for my daughter’s former boyfriend. He’s 28, she’s 25, and we’re both single.
This feels like more than physical attraction. We have a genuine bond, and I keep wondering what a life together might look like.
My daughter ended the relationship and has moved on, but I fear pursuing anything with him would make me a terrible mother and destroy my relationship with her.
I haven’t told her how I feel, and I don’t even know whether he feels the same. Still, I’m tempted to find out.
Is there ever a situation in which acting on these feelings would be acceptable, or should I force myself to let them go? Would following my heart mean risking too much?
Tempted Mum.
A woman who has fallen for her daughter’s former boyfriend asks Amanda whether pursuing a relationship would cross the line. (Stock image posed by models)
Dear Tempted Mum,
Let me put it as plainly as possible: no, non, nein, nyet, não — and an emphatic absolutely not.
Of all the attractive, available men in the world, you’ve chosen the one who is unquestionably off-limits.
I often remind myself in situations like this: there are billions of men on the planet, so why become obsessed with this particular one?
This is your daughter’s ex — someone who shared her memories, her bed and an intimate part of her life. What, exactly, are you thinking? Is this some kind of midlife madness? Should someone take away your phone before you make a terrible decision?
And before anyone accuses me of being prudish, let me be clear: I’m not. I adore younger men — their energy, their charm and the way they appreciate older women. I’m entirely comfortable with an age gap, especially when so many men my age are still complaining about their ex-wives and what they lost two decades ago.
But I know a woman who actually began sleeping with her daughter’s ex. Her daughter stopped speaking to her for two years, the man eventually lost interest, and I lost all respect for the mother. There is something deeply inappropriate and unsettling about the whole situation.
I don’t often discuss my personal life, but I have an adult daughter. If I ever caught myself looking twice at her boyfriend, I’d be profoundly uncomfortable.
Daily Mail columnist Amanda Goff (pictured) offers advice to two women facing very different relationship dilemmas
The idea is so far outside my imagination that even writing about it makes my skin crawl. I’d do anything for my children — but sleeping with someone they once loved is not on that list.
You haven’t said whether you’ve spoken to this man, whether he returns your feelings or whether there is any realistic future between you. Frankly, none of that matters. Stop before this goes any further.
You can’t always control who attracts you, and I understand that. There’s a married father who lives near me, and whenever I see him my heart skips and I think, “Well, hello.”
But having an involuntary thought is very different from choosing to act on it.
Your daughter may have moved on, which is good news. But that does not give her mother permission to treat her former partner as available territory.
It would be a devastating betrayal.
My advice is simple: do nothing. Join Hinge, widen your dating preferences if you must, and meet someone who isn’t connected to your daughter. There may be billions of men in the world, but you have only one daughter.
This is the kind of decision you could regret for the rest of your life.
Dear Amanda,
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE: WATCH: IDF Forces in Disguise Raid Hospital and Kill Hamas Leader, Pro-Hamas Libs Freak Out – NewsFinale
My new partner is constantly asking me to describe the men I’ve slept with whenever we’re in bed. He says imagining me with other men is a huge turn-on.
At first I didn’t mind, but this has gone on for so long that I’m now inventing scenarios and running out of ideas.
How can I raise the subject with him? And if this is what excites him most, what happens if I no longer want to participate?
Miss ‘Sick of Scenarios’.
A woman tired of describing her past sexual experiences to her partner asks Amanda how to handle the situation. (Stock image posed by models)
Dear ‘Miss Sick of Scenarios’,
I don’t envy you. That sounds utterly exhausting.
The room is dimly lit, the candle is burning, you’ve made an effort and you’re feeling relaxed. You climb into bed with the person you love, ready to enjoy yourselves.
Then the interrogation begins.
Your mind starts racing through old memories, searching for some long-forgotten man from your past who might provide the necessary spark. Was it the waiter in Spain? The man from that restaurant? Do you even have another synonym for penis?
Good grief. Whatever happened to simply enjoying sex without having to produce a new story on demand? I’m worn out just imagining it.
That said, I understand the appeal. This is a surprisingly common fantasy among men. I’ve lost count of the number who have told me, “I’m not gay, but imagining you with another man drives me wild.”
I’ve had to stretch my own imagination at times, occasionally resorting to wildly improbable stories simply because I needed to keep the fantasy going.
But you’re his partner, not an audiobook filled with endless erotic tales. No wonder you’re frustrated — and slightly panicked — as your supply of plotlines begins to run dry.
Enjoying this fantasy occasionally is one thing. Having to perform it every time you have sex is quite another. Even a creative person can run out of scenarios.
The strange thing about fantasies is that they don’t always operate logically. For many men, imagining their partner with someone else is exciting not because they are interested in the other man himself, but because the scenario makes their partner seem intensely desired. It combines jealousy, competition, forbidden pleasure and a hint of voyeurism.
If it ever happened in real life, he might be far less enthusiastic about sharing you than he is in fantasy.
The important point is this: sex should work for both of you. You are not there to provide a private entertainment service, and your presence should be enough. Your needs matter too.
Does he ever ask what excites you? Have you told him about your fantasies? What happens when you don’t provide one of your stories?
Most importantly, have you discussed this properly? Not during sex, but while you’re both dressed, sitting comfortably on the sofa and having an honest conversation?
Tell him you appreciate his openness, but that the fantasy has started to feel like work. Then ask what aspect of it appeals to him most.
Perhaps it’s the idea of you being uninhibited, the thrill of watching without being able to look away, or the possessive edge. Once you understand that, you may be able to find other ways to explore the same feelings.
And remember this: his fantasy is not an instruction you are obliged to follow. You might fantasise about him handing over his credit card and encouraging you to spend the day shopping — would he automatically be delighted by that?
You are allowed to say, “I’ve had enough.” You don’t need his permission, and you have no reason to feel guilty.
If he genuinely struggles to become aroused without these stories, you still have choices: try different kinds of erotic material together, consult a sex therapist, or acknowledge that you may not be sexually compatible.
But don’t assume this means he isn’t attracted to you. He may simply enjoy the idea that everyone else wants you too.