Democratic candidate Mary Peltola has been declared the winner of Alaska’s fiercely contested Senate race, one of the most closely watched battles of the midterm elections.
Peltola defeated Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan in his bid for re-election, giving Democrats their ninth pickup and 56th seat overall in the Senate.
The Associated Press called the race almost exactly two weeks after Election Day, with Peltola holding a 4.3-point lead over Sullivan.
With 99 percent of ballots counted, Peltola led by nearly 12,500 votes, completing a political setback for Donald Trump after a midterm “bluenami” had already handed Democrats control of Congress.
The senator-elect shared a statement on social media, writing: “As a lifelong Alaskan who has dedicated my career to serving our state, there is no greater honor than having Alaskans’ support in our fight to take on corporate greed, lower costs, and put Alaska first.”
“Thank you, Alaska. Let’s get to work,” she added. Peltola is the first Alaska Native ever elected to serve in Congress.
Alaska’s Senate contest attracted extraordinary international attention after Democrats were accused of helping place a “decoy” candidate with a name similar to the Republican nominee on the ballot to confuse voters and improve Peltola’s chances.
On Monday, Sullivan posted that he “will not be commenting on individual ballot updates or outside projections” and said his campaign “will have more to say by the end of this week.”
While the outcome remained unsettled, Trump himself attempted to declare Sullivan the winner, even though 25 percent of the vote was still outstanding.
Mary Peltola has received most of the votes in Alaska’s controversial Senate race
Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan sought a third term. He and other conservatives, including President Trump, repeatedly claimed that a second “decoy” Dan Sullivan on the ballot was a liberal plant
Trump posted on November 7: “The Alaska Race is OVER” and “Dan Sullivan WON, BY A LOT!” No one else had declared a winner at that point.
He repeated the claim last week, arguing that votes cast for the “Fake Dan Sullivan” should be awarded to the Republican nominee and calling the Senate contest a “rigged election.”
The “rigged” election allegation centered on a second Dan Sullivan listed on the ballot: Daniel J Sullivan Jr., a retired schoolteacher from the fishing town of Petersburg. His name appeared as “Sullivan, Daniel J Jr.” The senator was listed as “Sullivan, Dan S,” alongside the labels “Republican” and “Incumbent.”
Republicans spent months portraying the second candidate as a “decoy” whose purpose was to mislead voters.
He ran without an official party affiliation and received 4,760 votes, a total that did not determine the final outcome.
State officials attempted to remove him from the ballot, contending that his candidacy was not made in good faith. The Alaska Supreme Court, however, ruled that he could remain in the race.
The second Sullivan denied being a planted candidate but disappeared after a New York Times investigation was published in late October.
The report alleged that operatives aligned with Peltola’s campaign, her attorneys and senior aides at the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee helped recruit him as part of an effort internally known as the “ballot composition project.”
Peltola’s campaign and the DSCC denied involvement, while Peltola said she “knew nothing” about the effort. Sullivan called it the biggest scandal in Alaska’s electoral history and accused Peltola of “still lying.”
The report was published after nearly one in 10 registered Alaskans had already cast their ballots.
Alaska Governor Mike Dunleavy ordered an investigation into Peltola’s campaign, while federal prosecutors launched a criminal inquiry.
Even before the report appeared, the Justice Department had sued Alaska election officials at Trump’s direction. The department asked a court to block certification if Sullivan lost and votes for the second Sullivan would have changed the result under ranked-choice voting.
The DOJ later amended its lawsuit to include the Times’ findings. Senator Lisa Murkowski, an Alaska Republican, said the department should never have filed the case. Peltola’s campaign and the DSCC urged a judge to dismiss it, describing the action as an unprecedented pre-emptive strike against democratic elections.
An Alaska judge eventually dismissed the DOJ lawsuit, blocking the Trump administration’s effort to intervene before the result was certified.
Despite Trump’s claims that Sullivan had won the midterm contest, Peltola was declared the victor
The second Dan Sullivan reportedly left his hometown of Petersburg last week and has not been heard from since
A second Dan Sullivan also appeared on Alaska’s ballot and was alleged to have been recruited by Democrats to confuse voters
The Justice Department argued that Daniel J Sullivan had entered the race as a “frivolous candidate to confuse voters.”
But US District Judge Sharon Gleason ruled that the Trump administration lacked standing to bring the lawsuit, which sought to force Alaska to separate the ballots if Dan S Sullivan lost his re-election bid to Peltola.
The DOJ has appealed the decision.
A separate investigation by the House Oversight Committee is also continuing.
At the same time, the FBI has stepped up its criminal inquiry into Alaska’s “decoy” candidate controversy.
Two sources familiar with the investigation told the Daily Mail that agents questioned Peltola’s former campaign manager on Election Day.
The FBI approached Elisa Rios in Chicago on November 3, according to the sources.
“Full speed ahead,” one source said of the investigation.
Rios was allegedly involved in recruiting the second Dan Sullivan.
She told the New York Times that Peltola “definitely” knew about an effort involving the DSCC to find another Sullivan and improve her chances of winning the Senate seat.
The former campaign manager said she left Peltola’s campaign in August during a broader staff shake-up, only months before the election. She did not explain the reason for her abrupt departure.
Cheryl Bruce, who had been the campaign’s deputy manager, replaced her.
Peltola, the most recent Democrat to win statewide office in Alaska, won a 2022 special election for the state’s only House seat, defeating Sarah Palin under ranked-choice voting. She lost the seat in 2024, after which Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer personally recruited her to run for the Senate.
The rising cost of living was a defining issue in the campaign.
In late August, a store in the remote village of Shungnak was charging $26.82 a gallon for gasoline, up from $13.99 the previous day. The statewide average was just above $5.
Peltola also posted photographs showing a rural grocery store selling paper plates for $53.99.
The Democrat blamed the war in Iran, saying Sullivan had voted for it 14 times. Sullivan acknowledged that high prices were hurting Alaskans but blamed energy policies from the Biden administration.
Fish was another unusual focal point in the race. Peltola built part of her campaign around the slogan “fish, family and freedom.”
She supported banning large factory trawlers from outside Alaska and creating stronger financial protections for local fishermen. Sullivan, meanwhile, said he wanted to keep foreign seafood fleets out of Alaska’s waters and the US market.
The candidates differed over which vessels should be barred from Alaska’s waters. Peltola supported banning factory trawlers from the Lower 48 states, while Sullivan opposed that proposal and instead backed a ban on unregulated foreign operators.