Just weeks before his death, Shane Warne questioned whether Cricket Australia was withholding information about the Sandpapergate scandal.
The legendary leg-spinner had heard the Australian bowlers deny any knowledge of the plan. With rumours continuing to circulate, Warne predicted that “one day the truth will come out”.
More than four years later, Cameron Bancroft—the player filmed using sandpaper in Cape Town—has offered a detailed account alleging that knowledge of the scheme extended beyond the three players punished by Cricket Australia. Bancroft claims the entire team knew.
Pat Cummins continues to reject that claim. Now, the questions Warne raised in 2022 have returned to the centre of the controversy surrounding Cricket Australia.
Warne made the comments on Fox Cricket’s The Follow-On podcast on February 7, shortly after Justin Langer resigned as Australia’s head coach.
Angered by Cricket Australia’s handling of Langer’s departure, Warne turned his attention to the ball-tampering scandal that had preceded the coach’s appointment.
Cameron Bancroft says the entire team knew about the sandpaper plan, which he alleges was discussed during tea in Port Elizabeth before the Cape Town Test
Warne criticised Australia’s so-called “bowling cartel” and the nicknames used by the group, including “Winx” for Pat Cummins and “GOAT” for Nathan Lyon
Warne revisited the Sandpapergate controversy after Justin Langer stepped down as Australia’s coach in February 2022
“We still don’t know the truth about what actually happened at Sandpapergate. Does Cricket Australia know the truth? Do they? Do the same people know the truth about Sandpapergate? Are they hiding anything?” he said.
“We’ve seen that the bowling cartel, as they call themselves, or ‘Winx’ and ‘GOAT’ and all these unbelievable nicknames they have for themselves. These guys wrote a letter saying they had no knowledge of whatever went on.
“That might be correct. But if it’s not, and they’ve done that, there are all sorts of whispers or rumours that we have all heard. And one day the truth will come out.”
Warne also questioned why Steve Smith and David Warner had received the most severe punishments after the scandal.
“Does Cricket Australia know the truth? Is it the truth that we’ve heard? Why should Smith and Warner be the only two? Who knows. But the truth will come out,” he added.
Within days of Bancroft being caught in 2018, Warne described the ball-tampering plot as “premeditated cheating”. However, he also believed Cricket Australia’s penalties had gone too far.
Warne would have removed Smith and Warner from their leadership positions, imposed substantial fines and kept them out of the fourth Test. Cricket Australia instead banned both players for 12 months, while Bancroft received a nine-month suspension.
By 2022, Warne was focusing on a joint statement released by Australia’s bowlers. Cummins, who was nicknamed “Winx” after the champion racehorse, and Nathan Lyon, known as “GOAT”, had signed the statement along with Mitchell Starc and Josh Hazlewood.
Warne labelled the ball-tampering “premeditated cheating” in 2018, while arguing that Cricket Australia’s bans were excessively severe
Michael Clarke said Warne and Glenn McGrath would have considered it an insult if a teammate had taken sandpaper onto the field
Cricket Australia chief executive Todd Greenberg admitted the governing body had helped shape the team culture in place when the scandal occurred
The four bowlers said they did not realise a foreign substance had been taken onto the field until footage appeared on the big screen at Newlands.
Former Australia captain Michael Clarke has since considered how Warne and Glenn McGrath might have responded if a teammate had used sandpaper while they were bowling.
“Imagine if something like sandpaper was taken onto a cricket field with Warnie and McGrath in your team,” Clarke said on the Beyond23 Cricket podcast.
“Mate, they would abuse us and say, ‘Don’t dare insult us. We don’t need any of that. We are the best in the world’.”
In an explosive account published by The West Australian, Bancroft alleges that the use of sandpaper was first discussed during the previous Test in Port Elizabeth. He claims Warner raised the idea during tea on the second day, while head coach Darren Lehmann and bowling coach David Saker were in the dressing room.
Bancroft further alleges that Lehmann later used a walkie-talkie to instruct that the sandpaper be removed after the opener was filmed at Newlands. Lehmann told ABC radio that he needed several days to consider the allegations before giving a detailed response.
Bancroft’s account came after Usman Khawaja made similar claims about wider knowledge in his memoir, Sabr. Cummins said during a 68-minute press conference last week that he had no idea sandpaper was being taken onto the field, and reaffirmed that position through his manager on Thursday.
Some fans viewed Warne’s resurfaced comments as evidence that he suspected the scandal involved more than the three players sanctioned by Cricket Australia.
“The great Warne knew exactly what was going on,” one fan wrote. “Seems like he despised what the bowling group and Cricket Australia did.”
“Shane Warne was a cricket genius,” another added.
Cricket Australia chief executive Todd Greenberg acknowledged on Wednesday that the governing body had contributed to the culture in which the scandal unfolded.
“It’s been an incredibly difficult and uncomfortable time for the game and for everyone who was involved,” Greenberg said.
“What happened then and continues now to play out has a lot to do with the culture that existed back at the time, a culture that CA played a part in creating.”
Cricket Australia said it would need time to assess Bancroft’s allegations and was finalising the terms of reference for a forum where players and staff from the tour could present their accounts of what happened.
Warne died aged 52 on March 4, 2022, after suffering a heart attack while on holiday on Thailand’s Koh Samui.