First Non-Muslim Caned Under Indonesia’s Sharia Law

The scene appeared to belong to another era, evoking images of public punishment from medieval history. With her head lowered before a watching crowd, a...
HomeNewsTrump Faces a Nightmare Scenario in Final Midterm Reckoning

Trump Faces a Nightmare Scenario in Final Midterm Reckoning

For Donald Trump, the election represents his last major test at the ballot box—and a public verdict on the opening half of his second term.

By the close of Tuesday’s voting, more than 100 million Americans will have cast ballots in House and Senate contests nationwide, deciding whether Democrats can seize control of both chambers of Congress.

Some forecasts have warned that Republicans could be overwhelmed by a “blue wave” or even a “blue tsunami.” Other analysts remain less convinced, cautioning that polling can miss the mark—as it has in the past.

Conversations with voters across the country suggest that the cost of living, gasoline and diesel prices, and growing discontent over the Iran war are the dominant concerns, cutting across traditional party divisions.

Much of the public anger is directed at President Trump. His approval rating recently fell to a record-low 36 percent in the average of polls, while more than 60 percent of respondents said they disapproved of his performance.

In an aggressive final push, Trump held 25 rallies in battleground and vulnerable states during October, seeking to energize Republican voters and drive turnout for the GOP.

Yet some political observers argue that his impact could work against Republicans as well, with his presence and rhetoric alienating independents—a phenomenon one expert described as a “red undertow.”

Several Republican candidates have therefore attempted to navigate a delicate political balance, supporting elements of Trump’s agenda while creating distance from him over the Iran war.

President Trump launched himself into two dozen rallies in October but will it save Republicans?

President Trump staged two dozen rallies in October—but will his campaign blitz be enough to protect Republican candidates?

If Democrats win both the House and Senate, Trump could spend the final two years of his presidency unable to advance much of his agenda. He would also face a wave of congressional investigations involving him and members of his family.

Held halfway through a president’s four-year term, the midterm elections include all 435 House seats and 35 of the Senate’s 100 seats. Voters are also choosing 36 governors.

Republicans currently hold a narrow 218-214 advantage in the House. Two seats are vacant, while one independent member caucuses with the GOP.

Democrats therefore need to flip just three Republican-held seats to take control, and virtually every respected forecast lists them as heavy favorites to do so. The bigger question is how large their majority will be—an outcome that would determine how much authority Hakeem Jeffries, the likely future Speaker, has to contain the more left-wing, democratic socialist faction of his party.

As of Friday, prediction market Kalshi gave Democrats roughly a 93 percent chance of winning the House and a 71 percent probability of taking the Senate.

With a Democratic House victory viewed as highly likely, attention has shifted to the Senate, where Republicans currently hold a 53-47 majority.

A 50-50 Senate after the November 3 election would still leave Republicans in charge, thanks to Vice President JD Vance’s tie-breaking vote. The GOP would also retain control of the committees Democrats hope to use to investigate Trump.

President Trump campaigned for Ashley Hinson, the Republican Senate candidate in Iowa

President Trump campaigned alongside Ashley Hinson, the Republican Senate candidate in Iowa

Democrats must achieve a net gain of four seats to reach the 51-seat majority needed for outright control.

Republicans are defending 22 of the 35 Senate seats on the ballot, while Democrats are defending the remaining 13.

The most straightforward path for Democrats would be to retain the vulnerable Michigan seat and then capture four contests from a group that includes North Carolina, Ohio, Alaska, Iowa, Maine, Texas, Kansas and South Carolina.

If Republicans were to take Michigan it would be an enormous setback for Democrats and it has become a focus of the battle in the final days.

The seat is open as Democratic senator Gary Peters did not seek reelection.

Abdul El-Sayed, 42, the Democratic nominee, who would be America’s first Muslim senator, has proved to be a lightning rod for Republicans.

President Trump has attacked him perhaps more than any other candidate, calling him a ‘jihadist,’ while Mike Rogers, 63, the Republican candidate, has tried to tie him to the Muslim Brotherhood.

El-Sayed, a former public health official, has disavowed the group and denied any connection with it. He has also faced a backlash over links to the controversial Twitch streamer Hasan Piker.

Michigan Democrat senatorial candidate Abdul El-Sayed has been a focus for Republicans as Democrats try to hang on to Michigan

Michigan Democrat senatorial candidate Abdul El-Sayed has been a focus for Republicans as Democrats try to hang on to Michigan

The race had been rated a toss-up by the influential Cook Report, which assesses that no state is giving Democrats as much ‘heartburn’ as Michigan.

However, late Monday, the site changed its rating to ‘Lean D’ as part of a prediction that saw the Democrats gaining 3-6 Senate seats.  

Meanwhile, Democrats are highly confident of taking North Carolina. Former governor Roy Cooper holds an eight-point lead in polls over former Republican party chair, and Trump ally, Michael Whatley. Republican-aligned groups have pulled advertising money from the state to direct elsewhere.

Should North Carolina go blue, Democrats would need three more wins from states currently rated ‘toss-ups’ by the Cook Report – Ohio, Maine, Iowa, Texas and Kansas, which hasn’t elected a Democratic senator since 1932. South Carolina, which hasn’t done so since 1998, is also in the mix.

While voters’ concerns about the economy are universal, each state has its own issues and candidate dynamics affecting their race.

In Texas, which has threatened to go blue before, Democrat James Talarico, 37, a seminarian, has made his Christian faith at the center of his campaign.

But some on the religious right have accused him of deceiving voters and attacked him over previous comments about Jesus being ‘non-binary’ and there being ‘six genders.’

Trump has laid into him as ‘Talafreako,’ falsely accusing him of being a vegan, and tried to boost the Republican candidate Ken Paxton, who has been beset by marital and corruption scandals.

Texas Democrat James Talarico could turn Texas blue but President Trump has dubbed him 'Talafreako'

Texas Democrat James Talarico could turn Texas blue but President Trump has dubbed him ‘Talafreako’

In Alaska, Democrat Mary Peltola is ahead in polls against sitting Republican Dan Sullivan. But the race has been roiled in the final week as the Justice Department escalates a criminal investigation into whether Democrats recruited a separate candidate in an effort to confuse voters.

Sullivan appears on ballots as ‘Dan S. Sullivan’ alongside the labels of ‘Republican’ and “Incumbent,” but a previously unheralded challenger is listed as ‘Daniel J. Sullivan Jr,’ without any party affiliation indicated,

In Maine, Democrats were on the backfoot in July when their nominee Graham Platner dropped out after a sexual assault allegation, which he has denied.

However, his replacement Troy Jackson, a former logger, now has a three-point lead in an average of polls over Republican Susan Collins, who is seeking her sixth term.

A supporter of Democratic candidate for US Senate James Talarico holds up a sign at a rally in Dallas, Texas

A supporter of Democratic candidate for US Senate James Talarico holds up a sign at a rally in Dallas, Texas

Voters wait in line to cast their ballot at a polling station in Austin, Texas

Voters wait in line to cast their ballot at a polling station in Austin, Texas

In Ohio, Jon Husted was appointed to take over the Senate seat of JD Vance when he became Vice President but is now losing in polls to former Democratic governor Sherrod Brown.

The race has been one of the country’s most expensive this cycle with Brown raising over $68 million by mid-October, to Husted’s $20 million. Hundreds of millions of dollars more has poured in from outside groups.

Husted, a former college football player, received unusual praise from Trump about his physique. The President told a rally: ‘His a** is like a pile of muscle.’

Ohio’s gubernatorial race has also received significant attention as Trump ally Vivek Ramaswamy runs against Democrat Amy Acton, a physician.

Ramaswamy ran the most controversial advert in the entire midterm cycle, featuring Acton’s estranged mother calling her a ‘liar’ and insinuating she has mental health issues.

The mother, Donna Arthur, lost custody of her children after her husband, the children’s stepfather, was indicted for raping Acton.

Amid uproar, Trump backed Ramaswamy, saying the advert was like ‘hitting pay dirt.’

President Trump decided not to go to Kansas and Iowa at the weekend and to hold 'tele-rallies' instead

President Trump decided not to go to Kansas and Iowa at the weekend and to hold ‘tele-rallies’ instead

A billboard critical of President Donald Trump in Toledo, Ohio

A billboard critical of President Donald Trump in Toledo, Ohio

In Iowa, Republican Ashley Hinson, a former broadcast journalist and staunch Trump ally, distanced herself in the final days of campaigning, declaring she would be a ‘thorn’ in the President’s side if he was not good for Iowa. She is in a tied race with Democratic candidate Josh Turek, a double gold-medal winning Paralympic basketball player.

One of the Senate seats most unexpectedly in play is Kansas, where Trump won in a landslide in three presidential elections.

Like Texas, Democrats are running a candidate whose faith is at the forefront of his campaign. Adam Hamilton is the pastor of the state’s biggest megachurch and has accused sitting Republican Roger Marshall, a doctor, of suing his patients and living out of state.

In the bitter campaign, Marshall has hit Hamilton over a historic church abuse scandal and run an advert accusing him of ‘protecting a pedophile.’

In Kansas, the overwhelming issue is soaring diesel prices, caused by the Iran war, as farmers struggle during harvest time.

Meanwhile, Democrat’s last-minute hopes are rising in deep red South Carolina, which Trump won by 18 points in 2024.

A poll shortly before Election Day put Darline Graham, the sister of the late Republican senator Lindsey Graham, in a tie with Annie Andrews, a Democratic pediatrician and gun control advocate.

Trump made two visits to South Carolina in eight days in a rescue mission, branding the Democrat ‘Tranny Annie’ over her previous comments about transgenderism, and painting her as a ‘radical lunatic’ who would ‘take your guns.’

Democrat Dr Annie Andrews, a pediatrician, is running Republican Darline Graham close in a Senate race in South Carolina

Democrat Dr Annie Andrews, a pediatrician, is running Republican Darline Graham close in a Senate race in South Carolina

Going into the final days, Democratic Senate candidates were ahead in an average of polls by 3.6 points in Alaska, three points in Ohio, 2.5 points in Texas, and 2.4 points in Maine.

However, the polling guru Nate Silver concluded that all were just a ‘normal-sized polling error away from flipping’ to Republicans.

Averages of polls measuring the generic ballot, voters’ preference for which party should control the House, show Democrats about eight points ahead.

That margin would mean a gain of 24 seats in the House and a 239-196 majority, according to a model produced by Alan Abramowitz, Professor Emeritus of Political Science at Emory University.

It would also mean Democrats gaining of six seats in the Senate, resulting in a 53-47 majority in the upper chamber.

Given its margin of error, the model showed a two-thirds probability of Democrats gaining between 15 and 33 seats in the House, and between three and nine Senate seats.

There was a one-in-six chance of Democrats gaining three or fewer seats in the Senate, leaving Republicans in control.

Professor Abramowitz concluded there is a ‘realistic chance that Democrats could fall short of the 51 seats they need to control the Senate.’

After months of campaigning over 100 million ballots are expected to be cast

After months of campaigning over 100 million ballots are expected to be cast

Traditionally, in midterm elections, the party in power receives a slap down from voters.

In 2006, a so-called ‘blue wave’ saw Democrats pick up 31 seats in the House, ushering in the first era of Nancy Pelosi as Speaker.

Four years later, President Barack Obama called his party’s defeat a ‘shellacking’ as they lost over 60 House seats.

In 2018, when Trump’s Republicans were in control, the GOP lost 40 House seats.

However, amid all the suggestions of a Democratic surge, it is worth noting that in Trump’s first term, Republicans somewhat bucked the historical trend by increasing their Senate majority by two.

His poll numbers are lower this time though. A recent poll put his net approval rating for how he has handled the economy at minus 33, and for inflation, it is at a rock-bottom minus 48.

Republicans have spent big to stave off losses.

Elon Musk alone has spent about $366 million to support Republican candidates, according to campaign finance records.  

The SpaceX boss, who voted early in Texas, said: ‘The Democrats intend to cement one-party rule forever and make “democracy” meaningless.’

Overall, a record $3.8 billion had been spent on political advertisements by both parties and outside groups by October 12, with more pouring in for the final stretch.

Top spending came in the US Senate races in Texas, Ohio and Michigan, according to AdImpact, which tracks the numbers.