Science fiction has a long history of turning ambitious films into lucrative franchises. The Marvel Cinematic Universe, for instance, is packed with sci-fi concepts, from Norse gods reimagined as aliens to portals connecting distant dimensions. The “Avatar” films continue to draw audiences into elaborate adventures among rival Na’vi groups, while “Star Wars” keeps expanding across movies and television series set on wildly imaginative worlds. Hollywood has produced plenty of costly sci-fi failures, but the genre’s most successful franchises explain why studios keep coming back: The potential payoff is enormous.
That promise also helps explain why some sci-fi flops receive sequels despite disappointing theatrical runs. In many genres, a financial failure effectively ends a franchise. Science fiction, however, has repeatedly allowed movies to recover years — and sometimes decades — later. Cult followings, home-video success, and enduring brand recognition can all make another installment seem worthwhile. Here are five notable examples of sci-fi box office disappointments that eventually received sequels.
Not every follow-up was driven by genuine audience demand. Some reflect studios’ determination to extract every possible dollar from a recognizable title. Taken together, these films demonstrate the unusual staying power of science fiction: Even a box office dud can be treated as a long-term asset when the right audience, format, or business opportunity eventually emerges.
Blade Runner
“Blade Runner” is now widely regarded as one of the greatest science fiction films ever made. Its striking visual style and richly realized dystopian setting have influenced generations of filmmakers, artists, and storytellers. Yet when Ridley Scott’s film opened in 1982, audiences largely stayed away. The movie earned only $27.5 million domestically against a reported $28 million budget, and it was overshadowed by more accessible sci-fi hits — most notably “E.T.”
The film’s bleak atmosphere, deliberate pace, and lack of conventional spectacle made it a difficult sell during a crowded summer movie season. Over time, however, “Blade Runner” found the audience it missed in theaters. Its reputation grew through home video, critical reassessment, and a devoted fan base, eventually leading to a sequel that seemed unimaginable in 1982. “Blade Runner 2049” arrived in 2017, shifting the focus to a new Replicant protagonist played by Ryan Gosling.
Ironically, even that long-awaited continuation struggled commercially. Despite the original’s expanded cult following and “Blade Runner 2049’s” strong reviews, the sequel also lost money at the box office. The series’ influence has endured, but mainstream moviegoers have never embraced the “Blade Runner” films strongly enough to make them reliable hits.
The Thing
John Carpenter’s “The Thing” is now celebrated as a horror classic, but its initial failure affected the director deeply. Carpenter later said the film’s poor reception and the harsh responses it generated hit him particularly hard. Released in 1982, amid the feel-good success of movies such as “E.T.” and “Rocky III,” the film’s story of isolated men turning against one another during a crisis offered audiences little comfort. Its relentless tension, bleak outlook, and graphic body horror proved especially difficult for mainstream viewers at the time.
Like the alien organism at its center, however, “The Thing” changed over the years. Its ensemble cast, practical effects, claustrophobic setting, and sustained atmosphere gradually earned the praise the movie had been denied at release. That rehabilitation eventually encouraged Universal to make a prequel, 2011’s “The Thing.” The film also failed commercially and became associated with its decision to replace much of its impressive practical-effects work with computer-generated imagery during post-production.
Even so, the fact that “The Thing” continues to inspire new projects reflects how dramatically its reputation has recovered. Universal and Blumhouse have been developing plans to revisit the property again, giving the once-rejected horror film another chance to expand its legacy.
R.I.P.D.
Universal Pictures and its 1440 Entertainment division continue to support the direct-to-video sequel business, even as many other studios have moved away from it. The division has produced follow-ups to properties including “Half Baked,” “Dragonheart,” and “Tremors.” A film does not necessarily need to be a theatrical hit — or even turn a profit — to receive another installment. The 2013 disaster “47 Ronin,” for example, eventually led to the 2022 sequel “Blade of the 47 Ronin.” The same strategy produced a home-video follow-up to the ill-fated “R.I.P.D.”
IN CASE YOU MISSED IT: Mom Filmed Trying to Flee in Uber After Toddler Overdoses
Starring Ryan Reynolds and Jeff Bridges, “R.I.P.D.” follows deceased law-enforcement officers who battle evil spirits attempting to invade the world of the living. Its broad comedy, awkward character designs, and relentlessly noisy presentation failed to win over audiences. Still, writer-director Paul Leyden returned with “R.I.P.D. 2: Rise of the Damned,” which introduced new R.I.P.D. agents, played by Jeffrey Donovan and Penelope Mitchell, in a Western-inspired story featuring undead villains.
“Rise of the Damned” has made little impact on popular culture since its release. In strictly commercial terms, the sequel appears less like a response to strong demand than an example of how a familiar name can be repurposed for the direct-to-video market, regardless of whether the original developed a substantial following.
Terminator: Genisys
In 1991, “Terminator 2: Judgment Day” dominated the domestic box office and became a landmark in visual effects. But the franchise’s once-unstoppable momentum faded considerably in the years that followed. “Terminator: Salvation,” released in 2009, finished behind 22 films at the domestic box office, including “Paul Blart: Mall Cop” and “The Proposal.” The warning signs were clear, yet Hollywood continued trying to revive the property.
Six years later, Paramount and Skydance released “Terminator: Genisys,” another attempt to recapture the cultural and financial impact of “Judgment Day.” The film earned $432 million worldwide, a total buoyed by unexpectedly strong business in China. In North America, however, it made only $89.7 million — the first “Terminator” sequel to fall short of $100 million domestically. Its domestic haul trailed films such as “Planes,” “Madea Goes to Jail,” and “Kindergarten Cop,” despite those movies carrying far smaller budgets.
The “Terminator” brand had clearly lost much of its power, but Skydance pressed ahead. “Genisys” was followed by “Terminator: Dark Fate,” which also became a major box office disappointment. The franchise’s decline from the peak of “Judgment Day” remains one of Hollywood’s clearest examples of a once-dominant sci-fi property losing its audience.
Highlander
The “Highlander” franchise has proved remarkably difficult to kill. It has expanded into multiple movies and television series, and another reboot is in development from Amazon and United Artists. “John Wick” director Chad Stahelski is attached to lead the project, which is expected to star Henry Cavill, Karen Gillan, Dave Bautista, and Russell Crowe. That continued interest is striking because the original 1986 film was a clear theatrical failure.
Unlike many long-running franchises, “Highlander” did not begin with a blockbuster. Made for $16 million, the March 1986 release earned just $12.9 million worldwide, leaving little doubt that it lost money in theaters. The five-year delay before “Highlander II: The Quickening” also suggests that the studio was not rushing to capitalize on an immediate hit.
The first film eventually found a much more receptive audience on home video, becoming a popular rental-store favorite and building the cult following that made additional stories possible. Even with that VHS success, it remains remarkable that an entire film and television universe grew from such a modest theatrical performer.
No subsequent “Highlander” movie has surpassed roughly $15 million worldwide, reinforcing the idea that the brand has never fully connected with moviegoers. The coming reboot will therefore have to overcome a long box office history that began with the original film’s failure. If the franchise’s famous slogan still applies, perhaps there truly can be only one.
MORE ON THIS: Trump Lobbying Crisis Deepens Over Payment to Wiles’ Daughter’s Firm