A former White House technology official has criticized the government’s handling of recent flight disruptions and a broader series of cyber-related problems, warning that attackers could turn their attention to power and water systems if they conclude the United States is vulnerable.
Theresa Payton, who served as White House chief information officer under President George W. Bush, said conflicting statements from Trump administration officials during the nationwide flight interruption raised concerns. She also questioned whether some companies were deploying urgent technology updates without adequately testing them first.
“What I need the White House and what I need corporate America to hear is that Americans don’t expect technology to work perfectly 100 percent of the time,” she said. “But they do expect leadership, and they need leaders to be prepared when technology fails.”
Payton also questioned whether organizations had dependable backup systems and clear rollback procedures to undo defective changes and keep critical services operating when updates malfunction.
“We’re rushing, we don’t have redundancy, we don’t have resiliency, and we don’t appear to be doing the stress and load testing we should be,” she warned.
In her view, such failures could give hostile governments and criminal groups valuable insight into weaknesses they might exploit to create additional disruptions.
Payton said she was watching to see whether Iran might use cyberattacks in retaliation alongside conventional military action. “We do know that Iran is targeting critical infrastructure. We do know that they have been caught spying and pre-positioning things,” she said.
Possible targets include energy networks, telecommunications, transportation, water supplies and financial institutions—systems that keep homes powered, taps running and payments moving. Payton said a series of smaller attacks against several sectors could disrupt everyday life without bringing down the entire country.
Americans have remained on edge as disruptions hit several essential platforms over the past week, prompting some shoppers to stockpile supplies. People in New Jersey are pictured above
Europe has already seen how attacks on connected equipment can produce real-world damage. French authorities blamed an October assault on refrigeration controllers at roughly 700 sites on an Iranian Revolutionary Guard cyber unit.
Officials said the attackers altered defrost settings to raise temperatures, leading to significant inventory losses and fires at least 15 locations.
Payton called those incidents in Europe “a very important warning for us.”
Her concern is that an adversary would not need to take down the entire power grid to create fear and instability across the United States.
“My biggest concern is that, compared to Europe, [the US has] a much larger and deeply interconnected digital footprint,” she said.
“We can have national consequences without a complete energy grid failure,” Payton added, pointing to the router problem that caused hours of nationwide flight disruption.
“That could be a situation where nation-state operatives and cybercriminals watched this thing happen. Here was the response, and here’s how Americans responded.”
A chain of smaller failures across multiple services could interrupt daily routines and erode public confidence in the systems people rely on.
The Federal Aviation Administration imposed a rare nationwide ground stop on Friday after experiencing disruptions. A former White House technology chief has criticized the conflicting accounts from administration officials
“But what I’m concerned about is that they will carry out multiple smaller attacks,” she said.
“They’ll spread them across different sectors, and it will begin to affect the psyche of the American people: Wait a minute, what’s going on here?”
Although Payton believes military strikes have reduced Iran’s cyber capabilities, she cautioned that the country could turn to “cyber mercenaries” to conduct attacks on its behalf.
Potential threats could come from operators linked to the Revolutionary Guard, groups including Cyber Avengers and Handala, as well as independent hacktivists sympathetic to Iran.
The risk, she said, is that repeated attacks on essential services could create confusion and leave Americans wondering which system might fail next—without ever plunging the country into a total blackout.
Her concerns center on what hostile governments and criminal networks might learn by observing technical failures and watching officials struggle to respond.
IN CASE YOU MISSED IT: Princeton Ph.D. Student Eva Yi Xie Detained by ICE at D.C. Airport
The causes of the recent US outages remain under investigation. Senator Mark Warner said there was no evidence that the incidents were caused by a cyberattack, foreign interference or a coordinated campaign.
Payton’s comments come as Washington undergoes a shake-up in its cybersecurity leadership.
Sean Cairncross was replaced as White House national cyber director on Thursday, with Pentagon chief information officer Kirsten Davies assuming the role on an interim basis, according to reports.
Theresa Payton served as White House chief information officer under President George W. Bush
The disruptions of the past week have reached beyond aviation and banking, affecting Microsoft platforms and internal systems at the National Security Agency.
The NSA said it experienced a temporary degradation during scheduled maintenance, while emphasizing that its mission-critical capabilities continued to function.
The agency added that its infrastructure uses multiple layers of redundancy to preserve operations during interruptions.
Payton described the recent succession of outages as “one for the history books” and questioned whether government and corporate leaders had adequately prepared for major system failures.
Warner and former NSA cybersecurity director Anne Neuberger have suggested that pressure to repair software weaknesses identified by artificial intelligence may be contributing to the wider pattern of outages.
Warner said AI was speeding up the discovery of vulnerabilities, compelling organizations to install patches at a pace their infrastructure was not designed to handle.
Payton acknowledged that investigators had not yet determined the causes but questioned whether some companies had rushed out defensive updates after detecting suspicious activity.
“Did these companies see something and create a patch to make sure the bad guys couldn’t get in? Did they rush it, and is that why we had an outage?” she asked.
Regardless of what triggered an update, she questioned whether organizations had effective procedures for reversing defective changes or shifting to backup systems so essential services could continue, even with limited capacity.
Many Americans have been stockpiling essential goods since the technology disruptions began last week
Microsoft’s preliminary investigation illustrates how existing safeguards can still fail under pressure.
The company said a software defect introduced in July, combined with heavier traffic and reduced server capacity, caused a cascading breakdown. At the height of the incident, more than 80 percent of the affected network gateway servers were unresponsive.
Controls designed to isolate failures did not prevent the disruption from spreading worldwide, while standard recovery processes struggled to restore service.
Because the underlying defect had existed for months, Microsoft said its normal tools were unable to reverse the change quickly.
The government’s response to the Federal Aviation Administration outage drew particular criticism.
“We got mixed messages from different people in the same administration,” Payton said. “Why were you carrying out maintenance during a peak flying period? And who authorized it?”
The FAA said the disruption followed a routine replacement at a remote facility, a type of work it had performed during those hours for decades without disrupting operations.
After the outage, the agency said it would review the timing of future maintenance work.
The FAA also said some radio frequencies and radar feeds remained available throughout the incident, enabling controllers to communicate with aircraft and land flights safely.
Payton urged organizations to test security patches before deployment, roll out changes in a limited region before expanding them nationwide and schedule maintenance during periods when fewer customers would be affected.