Mark Carney Vows to Tackle Antisemitism as Controversy Surrounds New Anti-Hate Council Members

Prime Minister Mark Carney has issued a stark warning that Jewish Canadians are facing severe targeting, while unveiling a new anti-racism council. However, the council’s composition has sparked controversy, as it reportedly includes two individuals who hold contentious views regarding the Jewish state.

In his address on antisemitism, Carney’s announcement was met with outrage. Critics are questioning the suitability of a council designed to combat hate and antisemitism that appears to include members perceived as unsympathetic to Jewish community concerns.

Omar Alghabra, a former cabinet minister and Member of Parliament from the Liberal party, has come under fire for mourning the death of Yasser Arafat, the former Palestinian leader. The Foundation for Defense of Democracies has labeled Arafat as the “father of modern terrorism.” Additionally, Alghabra attracted criticism for not condemning the Oct. 7 Hamas attacks on Israel, as reported by Canada’s Rebel News.

Alghabra’s past statements about Israel have also drawn attention. In 2005, The Jerusalem Post reported that he criticized Toronto’s police chief for participating in a “Walk with Israel” event. He characterized the event as an expression of allegiance to a foreign nation embroiled in unresolved conflict and described Israel as perpetrating a “brutal and the longest contemporary military occupation in the world.”

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney addressed the media at a press conference following a Cabinet meeting, focusing on trade discussions with the U.S. and the Middle Eastern situation. This event took place at the National Press Theater in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, on July 30, 2025. (DAVE CHAN/AFP via Getty Images)

Canada’s opposition leader, Pierre Poilievre, pointed to a separate encounter with him involving a terrorist organization. “I remember Mr. Alghabra lobbying me before he was in politics to keep Hezbollah legal, so I’m not sure that he’s the right guy to combat antisemitism,” he told reporters.

Howeer, the Jerusalem Post reported that Alghabra had described Hamas as a terrorist organization during a 2016 parliamentary debate.

The other controversial member of the council, Avnish Nanda, represented efforts to keep a pro-Palestinian encampment at the University of Alberta in place. Critics of the encampment argued it created a hostile atmosphere for Jewish students following Hamas’ Oct. 7 terror attack on Israel.

In April, B’nai Brith Canada’s League for Human Rights released a report showing that 6,800 antisemitic incidents took place in the country in 2025, representing a 9.4% increase over 2024. On average, this represented 18.6 incidents a day and was the “highest volume” the group has recorded since it began tracking incidents.

“I’m a Canadian-born Jew serving as rabbi of the vibrant Tifereth Beth David Jerusalem community in Montreal, and I was truly shocked to learn that among the people chosen to sit on Prime Minister Carney’s newest council is Omar Alghabra, who publicly mourned the death of Yasser Arafat and remained silent when asked to condemn the attacks of October 7th,” Rabbi Zolly Claman of Montreal’s Tifereth Beth David Jerusalem Congregation told News Media.

“Canadian Jews are struggling to understand how our prime minister believed this would be a constructive appointment,” Claman said.

When announcing the new Council on Rights, Equality and Inclusion, Carney stated, “The council has a clear mission to combat racism and hate in all their forms and to guide the Government of Canada as part of our efforts to build a fairer, more just, more inclusive society,” He also said that, “The crisis of antisemitism in Canada today is specific, it’s severe, and it demands a targeted response. And that is what our government is fully committed to,” Reuters reported.

When asked about Prime Minister Mark Carney’s announcement, B’nai Brith Canada, one of the country’s leading Jewish advocacy organizations said that while it welcomed the prime minister’s acknowledgment of rising antisemitism, it believes additional action is needed to address what it views as a growing crisis facing Canada’s Jewish community.

“B’nai Brith Canada acknowledges the Prime Minister’s solidarity with the Jewish community,” Simon Wolle, the organization’s chief executive officer, told News Media. “He was right to mandate that the Special Advisory Council on Rights, Equality and Inclusion prioritize researching and combating antisemitism.”

At the same time, Wolle questioned whether the newly announced council has the authority and scope necessary to effectively address the problem.

“But we are concerned because the council does not have the power or scale to address this crisis in an appropriate and meaningful manner,” he said. “It is an important aspect of the government’s approach to combating antisemitism, but it is not sufficient.”

Wolle added that B’nai Brith Canada will “continue to call on the government to establish a National Emergency Task Force on Antisemitism, among other initiatives, because the Jewish community needs immediate action, not just words during this time of violence, hate, and threats to our right to exist and participate in Canadian society,” he said. Wolle did not offer comment on either Omar Alghabra and Avnish Nanda appointments.

Claman added, “The Jewish community makes up just 1.2% of Canada’s population, yet is the target of 75% of hate crimes, which is astoundingly disproportionate. Canada does not have a hate problem; it has a Jew-hatred problem. There is a very specific virus spreading rapidly across this country, and our prime minister is administering a broad catch-all antibiotic that will not help.”

Canadian Jewish activist Ariella Kimmel said his speech lacked concrete solutions and failed to address what she described as growing hostility toward Jewish communities.

“There was nothing on the vile chants we hear on the streets, nothing about the mobs that target Jewish neighborhoods, nothing calling for police to enforce the laws that already exist,” she said.

“What Canada doesn’t need is another special council on racism. We need to address the real elephant in the room, the targeting of Jews using ‘Zionism’ as an excusable reason, led by radicalized progressives and Islamist fundamentalists,” she said.

In response to News Media questions, a spokesperson for Canadian Heritage said, “The Ministerial Advisory Council on Rights, Equality, and Inclusion will play a critical role in bringing communities together around our shared values and in confronting hate and racism in our communities, so that all Canadians can live in our country without fear, in safety and dignity.”

The statement continued, “On June 1, 2026, the Prime Minister directed the Council to begin by focusing on antisemitism. The Council has a clear mission: to combat racism and hate in all their forms, and to guide the Government of Canada as we build a fairer, more just, and more inclusive country. Information about the Council, including the terms of reference and member biographies, will be posted online in the near future.”