Hundreds Mourn Smiling Construction Worker Killed in Brooklyn Collapse

Gabriel Siguencia, one of the construction workers killed in the Brooklyn building collapse, was remembered Saturday night as a loving and joyful young man...
HomeUSMother Outraged After Restaurant Adds Automatic Tip for Party of Five

Mother Outraged After Restaurant Adds Automatic Tip for Party of Five

A New Jersey woman says she was outraged after a restaurant automatically added an 18 percent gratuity to her bill, despite its menu stating that the charge applied only to parties of six or more.

Vanessa Cruz was celebrating her mother-in-law’s birthday at a restaurant in Elizabeth, New Jersey, last month.

Cruz attended the meal with her mother-in-law, her husband and their two children, who are six and two years old. She recounted the experience in a social media video that has since gone viral.

“I’m looking at the menu, and I read the fine print—they’re talking about gratuity. It said for parties of six or more, they’re going to add 18 percent. That’s fine, because there were five of us,” Cruz said in the video, which has fueled debate about tipping culture in the United States.

After the meal, the family received a bill totaling slightly more than $300, Cruz said.

“And then they go and add the tip—they automatically add the tip, 18 percent. I said, ‘No, that’s not happening,’” she continued.

Cruz stressed that she was not refusing to tip the waitress. Instead, she objected to the automatic gratuity being added when, in her view, the stated party-size requirement had not been met.

When Cruz and her husband questioned the waitress, they were told that the automatic gratuity applied to bills exceeding $200.

Vanessa Cruz shared her outrage after a local restaurant added an automatic gratuity to her party of five, even though the restaurant claimed the rule only applies to parties of six or more (stock)

Vanessa Cruz shared her outrage after a local restaurant added an automatic gratuity to her party of five, even though the restaurant claimed the rule only applies to parties of six or more (stock)

Mother Outraged After Restaurant Adds Automatic Tip for Party of Five

‘I think what peeved me the most was just the assumption that I have to give the 18% when it was already not part of that policy,’ Vanessa Cruz said after a restaurant applied an automatic gratuity rule to her party of five when it stated it only applies to parties of six or more (stock)

A new nationwide survey found that 78 percent of Americans believe tipping culture has become 'ridiculous' (stock)

A new nationwide survey found that 78 percent of Americans believe tipping culture has become ‘ridiculous’ (stock)

The waitress then offered to bring in the manager, which Cruz agreed to. 

When the manager arrived, Cruz brought up the fine print which stated an automatic gratuity is only applied to parties of six or more, and they were only a party of five. 

‘The system is not saying that – you don’t have that in the fine print. So if you can state one thing, why are you guys making up a rule so you can charge me the automatic 18 per cent?’

‘A livable wage should be the owner’s responsibility,’ Cruz wrote, ‘If food food prices need to be increased to make that happen, then they should do it. It’s a lose-lose for the customer in either scenario so just increase the prices.  

Cruz described the waitress’s service as: ‘not rude, but nothing special. I could’ve done without her, how about that.’

In the end, Cruz and her family paid the automatic gratuity fee, but plan not to return to the establishment. 

According to Cruz, the manager told her to put the complaint in writing after they had a conversation in which he ended up recognizing her argument. 

‘I think what peeved me the most was just the assumption that I have to give the 18 per cent when it was already not part of that policy,’ Cruz told Fox News Digital, ‘It was just that, like, my choice of tipping was taken away from me, and it was more demanded.’

The topic of automatic gratuity and tipping in general has sparked outrage in the American public over the past few years especially, which can be observed from consumer survey trends and trending discussions on social media. 

A recent nationwide survey found that 78 percent of Americans believe tipping culture has grown ‘ridiculous,’ and nearly half say they have actively cut back on gratuities in 2026 as household budgets come under increasing pressure. 

‘There is growing resentment over tipping, which is partly driven by the fact everyone is feeling squeezed financially,’ Retail analyst Neil Saunders told the Daily Mail back in June.

Earlier this week, a gastropub in North Carolina received backlash from locals after a patron took a picture of the automatic gratuity notice hanging inside the restaurant and shared it to a neighborhood Reddit group. 

‘If our employees have two separate instances of you not tipping well without any explanation, we will add a 20 percent auto-gratuity fee on your bill,’ the notice read.’ 

Similarly, customers of a Tommy Bahama outpost in Florida threatened to boycott the restaurant due to similar discrepancies regarding automatic gratuity earlier this month.  

The Daily Mail has reached out to Vanessa Cruz for further information.