Jacksonville Pharmacy Owner Accused in $51 Million Fraud Scheme

Federal prosecutors allege that a sprawling fraud scheme generated $51 million in insurance reimbursements for HIV medications. Two men are now facing federal charges. ...
HomeUSNYC Mayor Appoints Controversial Judge Days After Disbanding NYPD Squad

NYC Mayor Appoints Controversial Judge Days After Disbanding NYPD Squad

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has reappointed a judge criticized for lenient bail decisions, just days after disbanding an elite NYPD counterterrorism unit.

Mamdani this week announced 10 new judicial appointments to New York City’s family and criminal courts and renewed the terms of six others, including Manhattan Criminal Court Judge Valentina Morales, who has been labeled “Judge Let-em-Go” by critics.

Morales, a former public defender who joined the bench in 2021, has faced scrutiny for releasing repeat defendants, including people accused of violent offenses, back into the community.

According to the New York Post, Morales released 83 of 101 alleged violent offenders without bail during a six-month period from January through June 2024.

Among them was Eric Taylor, a homeless repeat offender whom Morales released in March 2024 after he allegedly attacked 24-year-old Jill Burke in Manhattan as she headed to work. Taylor’s criminal record included two felony convictions and dozens of misdemeanor cases.

Others released without bail included Walter Almachi Leal, a Venezuelan migrant accused of stabbing a man with a broken beer bottle, and an 18-year-old Manhattan gang member accused of firing a gun in the street.

Morales is one of six current or former public defenders among Mamdani’s judicial selections, as the Democratic socialist mayor continues advancing a left-leaning approach to public safety and policing.

Mamdani also announced this week that he would disband the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group, or SRG, an elite unit that has drawn criticism from his political allies over its handling of protests across the city.

NYC Mayor Appoints Controversial Judge Days After Disbanding NYPD Squad

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has reappointed a judge criticized for releasing alleged offenders back onto the streets without bail

Manhattan Criminal Court Judge Valentina Morales has earned such a notorious reputation for leniency she has been dubbed 'Judge Let-em-Go'

Manhattan Criminal Court Judge Valentina Morales has earned the nickname “Judge Let-em-Go” because of her reputation for lenient rulings

Among Morales's most controversial moves includes freeing homeless recidivist Eric Taylor in March 2024, after he violently attacked a young woman, despite a rap sheet counting two felonies and dozens of misdemeanors

Morales drew criticism after releasing homeless repeat offender Eric Taylor in March 2024 following his alleged attack on a young woman

Morales’s reappointment comes despite a series of decisions in which she released defendants accused of violent crimes without bail, sometimes over prosecutors’ objections.

In 2022, Morales released former inmate Frankie Centeno while he faced gun charges, allowing him to remain under electronic monitoring. Centeno later evaded the court process and fled the country.

Morales also released Venezuelan migrant Walter Almachi Leal without bail in 2023 after he allegedly stabbed a man with a broken beer bottle.

That year, she also released Kalifa Quattara, an 18-year-old alleged member of Manhattan’s “Up the Hill” gang, without bail following a reported street shootout, according to the Post.

Other appointees include Queens Criminal Court Judge Jennifer Saint-Preux, a former Legal Aid attorney, and Acting Queens Supreme Court Justice Toni Cimino, who previously worked as a criminal defense lawyer.

In a statement announcing the appointments, Mamdani said: “The decision made in our courts can change the course of a New Yorker’s life.

“That is why the people entrusted with serving on the bench must bring the highest standards of fairness, integrity and accountability to their work.”

In 2023, Morales also sprunt Venezuelan migrant Walter Almachi Leal without bail, after he allegedly stabbed a man with a smashed beer bottle

In 2023, Morales released Venezuelan migrant Walter Almachi Leal without bail after he allegedly stabbed a man with a broken beer bottle

Mamdani controversially disband the NYPD's Strategic Response Group (SRG) this week - an elite police unit that has been a target for his woke allies over its response to protests in the city

Mamdani announced plans to disband the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group, an elite unit criticized by his allies over its response to protests

NYPD officers arrest demonstrators during an anti-ICE protest in NYC on June 11, 2025

NYPD officers arrest demonstrators during an anti-ICE protest in New York City on June 11, 2025

Police unions and other law enforcement organizations have repeatedly criticized Mamdani’s mayoral tenure. The NYPD recorded a 35 percent increase in resignations after he won the mayoral election in 2025.

Before taking office, Mamdani regularly used social media to call for defunding the police and has a lengthy record of criticizing the NYPD.

The Democratic mayor has also described the department as “racist, anti-queer and a major threat to public safety.”

This week, Mamdani moved forward with one of his most controversial campaign pledges: eliminating the SRG and replacing it with what he called a “civilian-led approach.”

The unit had faced opposition from Mamdani’s allies over its handling of demonstrations. It is expected to be replaced by the Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division, a civilian-led body.

The new division is not expected to begin operating until 2028. Its staff will be unarmed civilians who lack the authority to make arrests.

The decision to dissolve the SRG followed increasing pressure from fellow Democratic Socialists, including Congresswoman-elect Darializa Avila Chevalier.

Mamdani is understood to have reviewed his position on the SRG after it became a point of tension with his far-left ally Darializa Avila Chevalier

Mamdani is understood to have reconsidered his position on the SRG after the unit became a source of tension with his far-left ally Darializa Avila Chevalier

Chevalier was arrested at a demonstration outside the UN in September, where Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was speaking

Chevalier was arrested during a September demonstration outside the United Nations while Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was speaking

Mamdani endorsed Chevalier’s congressional campaign in May. She is now headed to Capitol Hill after winning the midterm election in New York’s 13th Congressional District.

Chevalier, who has previously argued that the NYPD should be abolished, has been a prominent critic of the SRG. The unit arrested her last month during a demonstration outside the United Nations while Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was visiting.

Chevalier and Mamdani had held similar views on counterterrorism policy and the future of the SRG before the mayor’s administration postponed action on the unit.

The Post reported at the time that Mamdani’s team was angered by Chevalier’s calls for Police Commissioner Tisch to be dismissed, viewing them as an attempt to “undermine” the mayor.

After Chevalier’s midterm victory, however, sources told the New York Post that Mamdani’s team was seeking to repair relations with her by reviving efforts to scale back the SRG.

The move represented a shift from the administration’s earlier position, in which plans affecting the unit had reportedly been “put on the back burner,” the outlet said.