Share and Follow
NEW YORK – A large group that turned out to support a Palestinian-American man convicted of taking part in a hate crime beating of a Jewish man in a Times Square protest was ejected from a Manhattan courthouse Tuesday after shouting at the judge during his sentencing.
Mahmoud Musa was among a group of men who brutally beat Joseph Borgen after spotting him in public wearing a yarmulke in 2021. They set out that morning “to attack Jewish people,” according to prosecutors, and they found Borgen, who was headed to a pro-Israel rally.
They pummeled him to the floor, kicked him while he was down and doused him with pepper spray.
NEW YORK PROSECUTOR DROPS CHARGES AGAINST GOP COUNCILWOMAN WHO BROUGHT GUN TO PROTEST IN SUPPORT OF ISRAEL
Mahmoud Musa appears in New York Supreme Court for sentencing in Manhattan, New York on Tuesday, Nov. 21, 2023. Musa pleaded guilty to the May 2021 attack against a Jewish man in Times Square and was sentenced to seven years in prison. (John M. Mantel for Fox News Digital)
“I felt a liquid being poured on my face, and at first I thought I was getting urinated on, but it turned out I was getting maced and pepper sprayed,” Borgen told the New York Post shortly after the 2021 attack. “My face was on fire. That pain was worse than the concussion and all this other stuff that followed.”
Video of the attack also showed his assailants berating him with antisemitic slurs as they left him with a concussion and needing a neck brace.
HAMAS’ ‘DAY OF RAGE’ DRAWS HEIGHTENED SECURITY IN MAJOR AMERICAN CITIES, ATTENTION FROM THE FBI
Mahmoud Musa appears in New York Supreme Court for sentencing in Manhattan, New York on Tuesday, Nov. 21, 2023. Musa’s attorney Lance Lazzaro gestures during the hearing before his client was sentenced to seven years behind bars. (John M. Mantel for Fox News Digital)
“If the cops did not come, if they did not save my life, I would have died,” Borgen said during his victim impact statement.
Read Related Also: How old is the Marine Corps?
Borgen’s supporters sat quietly in the courtroom Tuesday, wearing hats and T-shirts demanding justice and condemning antisemitism.
About 30 minutes into the hearing, Musa’s supporters arrived. His defense wanted the minimum, three and a half years, but prosecutors had asked for a six-year sentence.
After Judge Felicia Mennin told Musa he would be spending seven years behind bars, his side of the crowd erupted, calling it “unfair.”
Joseph Borgen speaks to members of the media following the sentencing of Mahmoud Musa outside the New York Supreme Court in Manhattan, New York on Tuesday, Nov. 21, 2023. Musa was sentenced to seven years in prison following the May 2021 attack of Borgen in Times Square. (John M. Mantel for Fox News Digital)
The Post reported that journalists in the back of the courtroom overheard them calling Judge Mennin a “racist” for the sentence, which is less than half of the maximum punishment of 15 years.
Court officers removed them from the building. It was another 20 minutes before the courthouse was cleared and Borgen’s supporters and members of the media were told they could safely head outside.
Borgen said he was happy with the sentence but still worried about antisemitic violence amid ongoing protests about the current war between Israel and Hamas, a Palestinian terror group that launched a surprise attack on the country last month.
“I’m relieved it’s over, I think we got a strong prison sentence and I think it sends a clear message that Jewish blood, for that matter hate crimes in all senses of the word, are not going to be treated lightly in New York City,” Borgen told reporters outside the courthouse.
Two other suspects in the attack have received much shorter sentences, and two more have not yet learned their fate.
