Orphans Sue Landlord After Parents Die of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning

Three children whose lives were upended after both parents died from carbon monoxide poisoning at a California property are suing the homeowners and the...
HomeUSRetired Judge Michael Ruiz Says Clancy Appeal Could Backfire

Retired Judge Michael Ruiz Says Clancy Appeal Could Backfire

Lindsay Clancy, the Massachusetts mother accused of killing her three young children while their father was out running errands in 2023, received a limited legal victory Thursday when her appeal was sent to the state’s Supreme Judicial Court, legal experts said.

Earlier this week, Clancy’s attorneys appealed Justice William Sullivan’s decision rejecting their motion to dismiss the case on double-jeopardy grounds. The appeal was filed with Justice Elizabeth Dewar.

Dewar referred the matter to the full court Thursday. Briefing deadlines are set for next month, with oral arguments scheduled for January. Separately, jury selection for Clancy’s retrial is expected to begin March 29.

“This is a small win for the defense,” said Jack Lu, a retired Massachusetts judge and legal scholar who has followed the case. He said the appeal could potentially “unravel” future trials.

Lindsay Clancy cries during trial.

Lindsay Clancy reacts during her murder trial at Plymouth Superior Court in Plymouth, Massachusetts, Monday, Aug. 17, 2026. (Greg Derr/Pool The Patriot Ledger via AP)

“This remains difficult and unforgiving terrain,” Lu said. “From a common-sense perspective, the defendant’s position would interfere with jury deliberations in future cases and create an unworkable framework for addressing complaints involving deliberating jurors.”

Clancy’s first trial ended in a hung jury Sept. 4, following a week of deliberations. Her defense contends that the lone juror who voted to convict should have been removed and replaced by an alternate after the foreperson accused him of failing to apply the law concerning “reasonable doubt.”

In his earlier ruling, Sullivan said he was skeptical of the foreperson’s accusation. The holdout juror, Michael Desronvil, has said in post-trial interviews that he believes the evidence proves Clancy was guilty of murdering Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months.

During the trial, Clancy’s defense argued that she experienced postpartum psychosis and should not be found guilty because of a mental disease or defect.

Three young Clancy children in pajamas sit together on a couch, the smiling baby resting against his older brother, with their sister beside them.

Callan, left, Dawson and Cora Clancy. The three children were killed at their home in Duxbury, Massachusetts, in January 2023. (Lindsay Marie Clancy/Facebook)

Prosecutors alleged that Clancy planned the killings, sent her husband out to run errands and killed the children before he returned. She then jumped from a second-story window in an attempted suicide that left her paralyzed.

Clancy did not dispute at trial that she strangled the children with exercise bands on Jan. 24, 2023.

In an interview with Fox News after the trial, Desronvil said the prosecution’s evidence persuaded him that Clancy had methodically and logically planned what he called the “execution” of her children. He pointed in particular to the courtroom playback of Patrick Clancy’s 911 call.

Lindsay Clancy's husband, Patrick Clancy leaves court

Patrick Clancy leaves Plymouth Superior Court in Plymouth, Massachusetts, Monday, July 27, 2026. (David McGlynn for News Media)

Patrick Clancy, who was 36 at the time, returned from running errands and found his then-wife gravely injured in the yard and their three children in the basement.

“That was really big for me, you know, watching the video and listening in the courtroom,” Desronvil said. “The thought process that goes behind … fulfilling the commitment of doing that.”

Michael Desronvil in a waterfront interview across from Kayleigh McEnany

Michael Desronvil speaks with Fox News’ Kayleigh McEnany. (Fox News)

The appeal centers on whether there was “manifest necessity” to declare a mistrial after the jury failed to reach a unanimous verdict. Clancy’s attorney, Kevin Reddington, had asked that the holdout juror be dismissed and replaced with an alternate after the foreperson accused him of disregarding reasonable doubt in the prosecution’s case.

In a 17-page order issued earlier this month, Sullivan ruled that “manifest necessity” did exist. He also said he was skeptical of the foreperson’s allegation against Desronvil.

Carol Erskine, a retired judge and child welfare advocate, said it is difficult to persuade the full SJC to hear an appeal of this kind. During her career as an attorney, she filed three such appeals and said only one was accepted.

“The issue must involve exceptional circumstances, constitutional rights, urgency, and a situation in which the case cannot wait for the ordinary appellate process,” she told News Media.