In a case that has sparked attention across North Carolina, a father from the state has taken legal action against his children’s school district. He claims the officials have been unresponsive to concerns about whether biological males are permitted to share restrooms with his fourth-grade daughter.
Brandon Matthews, the father in question, has two children attending Mount Pleasant schools. His daughter is enrolled in fourth grade at Mount Pleasant Elementary School, while his son is gearing up for his senior year at Mount Pleasant High School. In May, Matthews approached the principals at both institutions with a straightforward request: to be informed if any students of the opposite biological sex were allowed to use the same bathrooms or locker rooms as his children.
Importantly, Matthews’s request did not involve an identification of any specific student, as clarified by the details of his federal lawsuit.
According to his attorney, the father remains in the dark, still waiting for answers from the school district.
The federal lawsuit, filed against Cabarrus County Schools, demands transparency regarding the policies and practices related to the access of sex-separated restrooms and locker rooms at the two involved North Carolina schools.
“Brandon Matthews does not currently know whether a male is using his fourth grade daughter’s bathroom,” Nicholas Barry, senior counsel at America First Legal Foundation, told News Media.
“And does he have a constitutional right to know that? We say ‘yes,'” Barry said. “Without that information, he’s just in the dark and… He really can’t make any good decisions without that information.”
Matthews’ concerns over the district’s bathroom practices predate the lawsuit.
At a May 11 school board meeting, Matthews appeared with his daughter and urged officials to keep boys and girls in separate bathrooms.
“Nobody’s targeting a child,” Matthews told the board. “All we’re asking is that the bathrooms are accessible to each gender. If they want that, then create a new bathroom.”
Matthews then turned to his daughter and asked her to address the board.
“I’m personally a girl and I wouldn’t want a boy following me in the girls’ bathroom,” she said. “It’s inappropriate.”
Matthews also used heated language during his remarks. He repeatedly warned officials that he could “get aggressive” and, while discussing protecting his daughter, said, “Anytime somebody touches this little girl, I’m gonna hang them from my garage.”
Less than three weeks later, Matthews put his concerns in writing.
He asked his daughter’s principal to notify him “in the event that any biological male is permitted to use the female restroom facilities” she uses. He made a similar request concerning his son’s facilities.
Brandon Matthews, the father of two Cabarrus County Schools students, is asking a federal judge to require the district to disclose its policies governing access to sex-separated facilities. (TNS/Getty Images, File)
Both principals responded June 8, according to court filings.
The elementary school principal said that “[b]ecause matters involving individual students are confidential,” the school “cannot confirm, disclose, or provide advance notice regarding the status, identity, or accommodations of any particular student.”
The principal told Matthews that if he or his daughter became aware of a specific situation affecting her experience, they could contact the school to discuss his concerns. The high school principal sent a nearly identical response, according to the filing.
Barry argues that didn’t answer Matthews’ question.
“The explanation is fairly straightforward. They don’t want to answer him,” Barry told News Media. “Well, nobody asked for individual student information, so that’s a non-answer,” he added.
Brandon Matthews says he remains unable to determine whether his children could be expected to share school restrooms or locker rooms with members of the opposite sex, according to court filings. (Houston Chronicle via Getty Images, File)
Matthews filed suit in the Middle District of North Carolina against the Cabarrus County Board of Education, Superintendent Dr. John Kopicki and the principals of his children’s schools. America First Legal Foundation and co-counsel Philip Thomas are representing him.
On Friday, Matthews also sought a preliminary injunction asking the court to require the district to disclose its policies governing sex-separated bathrooms and locker rooms and whether members of the opposite sex are permitted to access, or have accessed, facilities used by his children.
Matthews, a practicing Christian, says in his sworn declaration that his religious beliefs include that sex is immutable and that his children should not be expected to undress or use restrooms in the presence of members of the opposite sex.
The lawsuit does not allege that Matthews knows a biological male has used his daughter’s bathroom. His attorneys argue that he cannot determine whether it has happened or is permitted to happen.
Matthews said in a sworn declaration that he has been unable to locate a written, publicly available policy explaining when students at either of his children’s schools may be expected to share restrooms or changing facilities with members of the opposite sex.
Matthews sought a preliminary injunction asking the court to require the district to disclose its policies governing sex-separated bathrooms. (Getty Images, File)
At an April 13 school board meeting, School Board attorney William Isenhour said “the district addresses the [bathroom and locker room] situation at each school on a case-by-case basis with the goal of addressing concerns of all students and their families,” according to court filings.
News Media sent Cabarrus County Schools detailed questions about the allegations, the district’s bathroom policies, whether parents receive advance notice and its response to the lawsuit.
Matthews says he ultimately seeks advance notice and a meaningful opportunity to opt his children out before they are expected or required to use intimate facilities in the presence of a member of the opposite sex. His preliminary-injunction motion asks the court, while the case proceeds, to require the district to disclose its policies and whether opposite-sex individuals are permitted to access, or have accessed, facilities used by his children.
It also seeks notice when a member of the opposite sex “has been authorized to enter, or is expected to enter” a facility used by their child.
Barry told News Media that a victory could have implications beyond Cabarrus County.
“Yes, I think if we continue to push Mahmood forward, and we start getting wins on it, schools around the country are going to have to start disclosing to parents what their policies are and providing parents the opportunity to opt out,” Barry said.
Matthews’ attorneys rely heavily on the Supreme Court’s decision in Mahmoud v. Taylor. (iStock)
“I do think as Mahmoud percolates out and as cases like this get decided, it’s going to require that school districts provide notice and an opportunity to opt out to parents on this specific issue.”
That is Barry’s interpretation of what a victory could require. The court has not yet ruled on Matthews’ claims.
Matthews’ attorneys rely heavily on the Supreme Court’s decision in Mahmoud v. Taylor, which involved parents seeking notice and an opportunity to opt their children out of certain LGBT classroom instruction on religious grounds.
AFL argues that if parents are entitled to notice in that context, the same principle should apply to children sharing bathrooms, locker rooms or changing facilities with members of the opposite sex.
Matthews alleges the district violated his rights under the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment and the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.
The case is America First Legal’s second lawsuit against Cabarrus County Schools over sex-separated facilities.
Its first lawsuit alleges female students at Cox Mill High School were required to share girls’ restrooms, locker rooms and changing spaces with a biological male.
Those allegations are separate from Matthews’ case and do not establish that a biological male has used the restroom at his daughter’s elementary school.
Barry drew the same distinction in his interview with News Media.
“The first lawsuit we filed, there are allegations that a male is using our three client females’ restroom and locker rooms and changing spaces,” Barry said. “Which is different than what we’re doing here. Here, it’s a straightforward attack on Cabarrus County Schools policy to get information about it and to know whether it’s impacting our clients’ daughter and son at school right now.”
Matthews’ attorneys also stressed in their preliminary-injunction motion that he is seeking information and notice, not an order barring another student from a particular facility.
“Plaintiff seeks only notice and information—he does not seek to prevent any student from using any facility,” they wrote.
Cabarrus County Schools did not immediately respond to News Media’s request for comment.
