The Lord Speaker has warned that plans for a Star Trek-style transformation of Parliament could saddle taxpayers with a bill of up to £40 billion.
Lord Forsyth of Drumlean has challenged the proposals being presented to MPs and peers, with a decisive vote expected within weeks.
In a letter to members, he said politicians were being asked to approve billions of pounds in preliminary spending without a clear understanding of the project’s “scope, affordability and consequences”.
Lord Forsyth said the plans required a fundamental rethink, pointing to the “exceptionally difficult choices over public expenditure” confronting the country.
A costed options report published by parliamentary authorities in February presented politicians with two possible approaches.
Under the first, MPs would leave the Palace of Westminster for eight to 10 years, while peers could be relocated for as long as 15 years. The proposal could cost taxpayers £15.6 billion.
Lord Forsyth of Drumlean has challenged the options facing MPs and peers ahead of a crucial vote expected within weeks
The proposals include plans for a dramatic new area beneath Central Lobby
A glass-roofed visitor entrance could be built beside the Houses of Parliament, according to the report
The second option would keep MPs on the historic site while moving peers to a nearby facility, potentially the QE2 conference centre. That building would be equipped with parliamentary amenities including catering facilities and a library.
The work could take between 38 and 61 years to complete, with the total cost reaching £39.2 billion, the report said.
A vote expected next month will ask MPs and peers to approve seven years of initial work at the Palace of Westminster, costing as much as £3 billion.
Parliament would then choose between the two recommended strategies in the mid-2030s. However, senior MPs have questioned whether that timetable is realistic, given the repeated delays surrounding the project.
The future of the Westminster estate has been disputed for decades. Critics describe the site as a mouse-infested fire hazard plagued by power failures and unreliable heating.
The report also unveiled striking concepts for the crumbling buildings at the centre of British democracy.
The designs feature spacious underground atriums beneath glass roofs, along with lavish new courtyards where MPs could meet constituents.
Lord Forsyth, a former Conservative who became Lord Speaker, said there was “no doubt that the Palace needs substantial restoration”.
However, he questioned whether the proposals, drawn up before he took the role, had clearly separated essential restoration from upgrades that could be postponed or delivered independently.
MORE ON THIS: Gut Bug Now Leading Explanation for Young-Onset Bowel Cancer
He also noted that delays to the Northern Estate project since the report was published could, in the worst-case scenario, add seven years to the timetable for the full decant option.
Lord Forsyth compared the plans with the refurbishment of Buckingham Palace, which took a decade and cost £400 million.
By comparison, converting the QEII conference centre into temporary accommodation for peers alone is expected to cost more than £400 million.
Lord Forsyth asked whether Parliament should reconsider its sitting calendar and make greater use of recesses to carry out major works.
“Is a September sitting essential if another arrangement would allow significant restoration work to be completed faster, more efficiently and at a lower cost?”
He also questioned whether it was responsible to treat the parliamentary timetable as completely fixed while considering a project of such scale.
“Are the costs of more than £400 million to convert the QEII Conference Centre into accommodation for the Lords justified, and are the proposed arrangements practical?”
He added: “How would State Openings of Parliament and other important ceremonies be conducted?”
Lord Forsyth stressed that essential work should not be postponed.
“The cost and risks of inaction are considerable,” he said. “But there is a crucial distinction between carrying out necessary safety and conservation work and committing billions of pounds to a programme whose scope, affordability and consequences have not yet been agreed.
“The question facing Parliament is not whether earlier decisions were reasonable when they were made, but whether they remain the right decisions today.
“At a time when the country is confronting exceptionally difficult choices over public spending, Parliament must show that expenditure on its own buildings has faced the most rigorous scrutiny. I urge colleagues to read the Costed Proposals report and consider these questions carefully before the debate.
The future of the Westminster estate, seen by critics as a mouse-infested fire risk plagued by power cuts and heating failures, has been debated for decades
One proposal would move MPs out of Parliament for eight to 10 years and peers for up to 15 years, at a potential cost of £15.6 billion
“The Palace of Westminster is a national treasure that we have a duty to preserve. We also have a duty to ensure that the method chosen is necessary, affordable and properly accountable.”
Kemi Badenoch has already called for a fundamental rethink of the restoration programme.
The Conservative leader has accused taxpayers of being asked to fund the transformation of the Palace of Westminster into a “Net-Zero Dubai hotel”.
“This was supposed to be essential work to keep a cherished historic building safe and operational. Instead, it has become a basket-case white-elephant project,” she said in February.
MUST READ: NYC Woman Says LGBTQ+ Activist Hit Her After She Questioned Trans Youth Treatments