Dear Vanessa,
I’m 62, still working, and my wife and I have finally paid off our family home. We had been looking forward to entering retirement with real financial security.
Our son and his partner are both in their 30s and desperate to buy their first home. But saving a deposit seems almost impossible for them.
They’ve now asked us to act as guarantors on their mortgage, using our home as security.
My wife believes we should help. She says younger people face far greater challenges getting into the property market today. But the thought of putting our home at risk terrifies me.
Our son says he will always keep up the repayments. But what if he loses his job, becomes ill or something else goes wrong?
I feel guilty for even hesitating. Am I being selfish?
David
Money educator Vanessa Stoykov (pictured) advises a father concerned about going guarantor on his son’s mortgage
Dear David,
You are not being selfish. In fact, your unease is highlighting a risk that deserves careful attention.
As soaring property prices make it harder for younger buyers to enter the market, more parents are being asked to become the Bank of Mum and Dad. But supporting your children should not come at the expense of your own retirement security.
I recently discussed this exact dilemma with financial adviser Harry Moustakas on my new program, Money Dilemmas. He agreed that your caution is entirely reasonable.
‘Once you go guarantor, the key thing to understand is that you become legally responsible,’ he explained.
If your son is unable to meet the repayments because of unemployment, illness or a relationship breakdown, the lender could pursue you. In the worst-case scenario, offering your home as security could put it at risk.
For example, imagine your son buys a $1million property with a $950,000 mortgage. If the property’s value drops by 10 per cent and he has to sell, the proceeds may not be enough to cover the remaining loan and selling costs. You could then be left responsible for the shortfall.
At 62, with retirement getting closer, that is a substantial risk to take.
Financial adviser Harry Moustakas (pictured) says David is right to be cautious
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE: Real Estate Brothers’ “Hunting” Boasts End in 30-Year Prison Terms
Harry made a point that every parent should consider: ‘The first thing they should be thinking about is themselves.’
That is not the same as turning your back on your children. It means establishing whether you are in a strong enough financial position to help without compromising your own future.
Before making any commitment, Harry recommends meeting with a financial adviser to assess your retirement income, superannuation and expected future costs. If you need help finding an adviser, my free service is here.
You should also have a frank discussion with your son and his partner. Can they comfortably manage the repayments? What would happen if interest rates increased? Do they have suitable insurance and enough savings to handle an emergency?
If they cannot currently put together a deposit, they also need to examine how they would cover a mortgage, council rates, maintenance and the many other costs that come with owning a home.
There may be ways to help without guaranteeing the full loan. Harry noted that some lenders provide limited guarantees or accept cash as security. Depending on your financial position, a smaller gift or a formally documented family loan could also be considered. Every option carries potential risks, so independent professional advice is essential.
One suggestion from Harry stood out to me: instead of immediately putting your home on the line, consider paying for your son to receive professional financial advice.
‘I think that’s the best gift you can give,’ he said.
That support could help your son understand what he can genuinely afford while taking some of the emotional burden away from you.
I often describe situations like this as financial flashpoints — moments when emotions are intense, but the decisions made can shape a family’s finances for decades. This is one of those moments. The excitement of finding the right property should not push your family into a commitment you may later regret.
Your son has many years to build his financial future. You and your wife have less time to recover if something goes wrong. You can love and support your children while still deciding that the answer is no.
David, the most important step now is to slow down and understand every potential consequence before making a decision that could put the retirement you worked so hard for at risk.
Many families are facing this same dilemma: how to help adult children buy a home without undermining their own financial security.
Harry and I examined your situation in greater detail in the latest episode of Money Dilemmas, including alternatives to becoming a guarantor that many parents may not realise are available.
Watch the full conversation on my YouTube channel.
All the best,
Vanessa
You can subscribe to Vanessa’s free newsletter here.