Dame Jilly Cooper’s standing as one of Britain’s most popular authors is facing fresh scrutiny after she was accused of reproducing material from the work of two other writers.
An investigation claims that the novelist, celebrated for her saucy relationship dramas, borrowed dozens of passages from American author Cyra McFadden’s The Serial for her 1978 novel Prudence.
She has also been accused of using extracts, including sentences that are nearly identical, from Josephine Tey’s 1948 mystery The Franchise Affair.
Caroline, Ms McFadden’s daughter, said the claims could not simply be explained as an accidental error and urged publishers to carry out a comprehensive review of Dame Jilly’s books.
‘It absolutely boils my blood to think of someone stealing my mother’s work because I know how hard she worked at her craft,’ she told the Observer.
‘To steal her work so extensively and to profit off it is unconscionable.
‘I will be looking at legal options as this can’t be allowed to stand. I sincerely hope that all of Dame Cooper’s work will be scrutinised to see if this was a pattern of hers and other talented authors’ work stolen.’
The allegations have surfaced a year after Dame Jilly’s death, which prompted tributes from some of Britain’s most prominent public figures.
Dame Jilly Cooper received tributes from senior figures including Queen Camilla and two former prime ministers after her death in October 2025. She is pictured with Queen Camilla at Clarence House in March 2025
Dame Jilly Cooper became one of Britain’s most cherished authors, but her legacy is now being examined amid plagiarism allegations
Queen Camilla called Dame Jilly a ‘wonderfully witty and compassionate friend’, adding: ‘Very few writers get to be a legend in their own lifetime, but Jilly was one.’
Former prime ministers Sir Keir Starmer and Rishi Sunak also shared public tributes. Mr Sunak described her as ‘a storyteller whose wit and love of character brought joy to millions’.
Her books have sold more than 11 million copies in Britain, where they remain widely read.
Disney+ is currently showing the second season of its successful adaptation of Rivals, based on the most famous novel in Dame Jilly’s Rutshire Chronicles series.
Dominic Treadwell-Collins, whose production company produces the drama, said last month: ‘We have got all these books to plunder. We can make it go on for ever.’
A review of Prudence identified 35 passages that closely resemble sections of The Serial, which appeared ten months earlier, in May 1977.
The alleged parallels include almost all of the dialogue spoken by Berenice, Dame Jilly’s American feminist character and romantic rival to the English heroine, Prudence.
The books both mention parties serving soybean canapes, lentil loaf and carrot cake. They also use the expression ‘a good rap’ in place of a conversation.
In one of the most striking comparisons, Dame Jilly’s character says of her former husband: ‘I wanted an open living relationship based on trust and growth, and all he wanted was his jockey shorts ironed. I mean we weren’t coming from the same place at all.’
McFadden’s character Kate says: ‘I wanted an open, loving relationship, based on growth and trust and sharing, and Harvey wanted his jockey shorts ironed. I mean we just weren’t coming from the same place at all.’
The investigation identified 35 passages in Prudence that appear to echo Cyra McFadden’s The Serial
Dame Jilly Cooper’s Prudence also contains passages alleged to closely resemble Josephine Tey’s 1948 novel The Franchise Affair
Dame Jilly Cooper displays her medal after receiving a CBE at an investiture ceremony in March 2018
Dame Jilly had previously said she had read The Serial. Writing in a Mail on Sunday column in 1982, she said the book had ‘tremendously comforted’ her with its parody of modern feminism, describing it as ‘a marvellously funny send-up of American trendies in the late seventies’.
The Observer’s review also discovered apparent similarities between Prudence and The Franchise Affair, the detective novel by Scottish writer Josephine Tey, who died in 1952.
One comparison involves an almost word-for-word description of the moment a character is revealed to have committed perjury.
Tey wrote: ‘Against my will, my eyes went to Mrs Wynn, and came away at once. It was crucifixion.’
Dame Jilly’s version reads: ‘Against my will, my eyes went to Ricky Wetherby and came away at once. It was crucifixion.’
Both stories also involve a court case falling apart after a secret lover gives evidence, a hotel manager recounting illicit meetings and a handwriting expert entering the proceedings.
In both novels, the jury unusually announces that it has reached a verdict before all the evidence has been heard.
This is not the first occasion on which Dame Jilly has faced claims that her writing echoed other authors’ work.
In 1976, critic Auberon Waugh highlighted what he described as ‘an amazing similarity’ between sections of her debut novel Emily and Georgette Heyer’s Devil’s Cub.
A decade later, Private Eye compared passages from Elaine Dundy’s 1958 novel The Dud Avocado with sections of Dame Jilly’s books Emily and Bella.
Dame Jilly later acknowledged that the similarities were ’embarrassing’, but argued that such incidents ‘can happen to any writer’. She attributed them to a ‘chaotic’ mix-up involving notes she had made while reading Dundy’s novel.
Novelist DJ Taylor, who has written extensively on plagiarism, told the Observer: ‘It’s perfectly legitimate for a writer to conduct their research in other people’s books, but I’m afraid that on this occasion it looks as if Jilly Cooper has driven a coach-and-four through the barrier that separates research and straightforward expropriation.’
Dame Jilly died aged 88 in October 2025, fewer than 24 hours after falling at her home in the Cotswolds and suffering a fractured skull.
After her death, it emerged that her will left an £8.6million estate, divided equally between her two children and her stepdaughter.
Her agent at Curtis Brown and publisher Penguin were contacted for comment.