Young Paraglider Dies After Reported Emergency Crash in Illinois Field

An Illinois paraglider died in a weekend crash after reportedly suffering an emergency during flight.Officials identified the victim Saturday as Giovanni Lopez, 21,...
HomeNewsFather recounts Covid quarantine ordeal after daughter’s suicide

Father recounts Covid quarantine ordeal after daughter’s suicide

The circumstances behind an international lawyer’s decision to sue the Victorian Government after being confined in hotel quarantine can now be revealed.

Hayden Flinn’s legal battle over the state’s refusal to allow him and his son to quarantine at home was due to begin on Tuesday, but the case was quietly settled on the morning the trial was scheduled to start.

The terms of the settlement have not been made public. However, the Daily Mail understands that Mr Flinn and his son had travelled from Hong Kong to Melbourne in May 2021.

Mr Flinn’s 13-year-old daughter, Sophie, had died by suicide on May 2.

Although Mr Flinn and his son were both fully vaccinated, Victorian health authorities required them to remain in a Melbourne hotel under the state’s strict quarantine rules.

They spent another two weeks in isolation while the rest of their family mourned and made arrangements for the teenager’s funeral without them.

Sophie was a talented basketball player who attended the Australian International School in Hong Kong, where her father remains a governor.

Mr Flinn, a corporate lawyer based in Hong Kong, was there when he learned of his daughter’s death.

Sophie Flinn, 13, tragically took her own life as Victorians faced their fourth Covid-19 lockdown

Sophie Flinn, 13, tragically took her own life as Victorians faced their fourth Covid-19 lockdown

The grieving father had returned two negative Covid tests before boarding a Cathay Pacific flight to Melbourne as a fully vaccinated traveller who had received two Pfizer doses.

Instead of being permitted to stay with relatives, he and his distressed teenage son spent the next two weeks confined to a small hotel room in Richmond.

On May 3, 2021—the day after Sophie’s death—Victoria recorded only one new Covid-19 case, with no new locally acquired infections.

The state had not entered lockdown since February.

By then, Victorians had already endured three lockdowns dating back to March the previous year.

After 159 days of restrictions, residents were just weeks away from a fourth Covid-19 lockdown, which began on May 27 and ended on June 10 that year.

In the lawsuit, which has now been settled, Mr Flinn claimed he was prevented from viewing his daughter’s body and was unable to support his grieving wife as she organised their child’s funeral.

He launched proceedings against the state of Victoria and the Department of Health, seeking damages for what he described as ‘indignity and insult’, loss of liberty and psychological distress.

The trial was expected to hear evidence from former chief health officer Brett Sutton and his deputy, Allen Cheng, about how the decision in Mr Flinn’s case was made and how other pandemic exemptions were handled.

Hayden Flinn (centre) arrives at the Supreme Court of Victoria on Tuesday in what was supposed to be the start of his civil trial against the Victorian Government. It had already been settled

Hayden Flinn (centre) arrives at the Supreme Court of Victoria on Tuesday in what was supposed to be the start of his civil trial against the Victorian Government. It had already been settled

Court documents alleged that the government knew why Mr Flinn needed to leave quarantine but continued to detain him, The Age reported.

‘The level of distress being experienced by the family was assessed as too high for the family to maintain [detention] requirements,’ a Health Department email sent on May 4, 2021, stated.

‘The alternative of going home to wife and family would pose a COVID-19 risk to family and public health.’

Mr Flinn argued that ‘the decisions recorded in Detention Notices 1 and 2 were unlawful and/or incorrect’, according to the court documents.

The records also included an email from Mr Flinn to the Health Department asking that he and his son be released.

‘Her body is at the Coroner’s Court. I would like to leave the hotel to see her. Thank you. Hayden,’ he wrote.

After that request was rejected, he contacted the department again, expressing concern about being confined with his teenage son while experiencing profound grief.

As correspondence continued between different government departments, including Mr Sutton’s office, the family was told that their request to complete quarantine at home had been refused.

Government records showed that, in the three weeks before Mr Flinn’s application, Covid-19 Quarantine Victoria had received 236 exemption requests. Four were approved because of exceptional medical circumstances.

Former chief health officer Brett Sutton was the mastermind of Victoria's covid response

Former chief health officer Brett Sutton was the mastermind of Victoria’s covid response

Mr Flinn and his son were eventually allowed to leave the hotel at about 5.30pm on May 17, 2021, after completing their two-week quarantine period.

Sophie’s funeral was held on May 22, 2021, almost three weeks after her death.

The Daily Mail does not suggest that Sophie’s death was connected to lockdowns or Covid restrictions.

The settlement amount is expected to remain confidential, although legal sources said it was likely to be substantial given the corporate lawyer’s determination to take the matter to trial.

Mr Flinn was due to speak to reporters about the case on Thursday but withdrew after the settlement was formally finalised.

The Daily Mail contacted him for comment but received no response.

porty law student Natalie Boyce was 21 when she died on March 27, 2022 at The Alfred hospital in Melbourne, five weeks after receiving a Moderna vaccine booster

Sporty law student Natalie Boyce was 21 when she died on March 27, 2022 at The Alfred hospital in Melbourne, five weeks after receiving a Moderna vaccine booster

Earlier this week, a separate case before the Coroners Court of Victoria examined the death of 21-year-old Natalie Boyce, who died five weeks after receiving a Moderna booster, as well as the impact of Covid hospital visiting restrictions on her mother, single parent Deborah Hamilton.

Ms Hamilton has repeatedly accused former premier Daniel Andrews of receiving special treatment during his 2021 hospital stay for a back injury.

She said an Alfred nurse told her that Mr Andrews could receive visitors whenever he wished and was not subject to time limits while in hospital.

Ms Hamilton told a Senate committee in May 2023: ‘Daniel Andrews forced us.’

‘I think Dan Andrews is the most corrupt person out there, and I don’t understand why he has different rules than the rest of us.

‘It is just so unfair.’

In March 2026, the Victorian Government, led at the time by former premier Jacinta Allan, agreed to a $125 million settlement with retail businesses over the hotel quarantine controversy.

The Supreme Court of Victoria approved that settlement on October 21.

Daniel Andrews during his hospital stay in 2021. Deborah Hamilton has accused him of receiving special treatment

Daniel Andrews during his hospital stay in 2021. Deborah Hamilton has accused him of receiving special treatment

The class action alleged that operational failures in the hotel quarantine system—particularly outbreaks associated with the Rydges and Stamford Plaza hotels—contributed to Victoria’s second Covid-19 wave and the Stage 3 and Stage 4 lockdowns imposed between July and October 2020.

The Victorian Government settled the matter without admitting liability.

If you or someone you know needs support, contact Lifeline on 13 11 14 or Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636. In an emergency, call Triple Zero on 000