![]()
NEW YORK – Expectations were already low ahead of this year’s United Nations climate summit in Turkey. Yet the outcome announced Sunday fell even further short: negotiators failed to reach a broad agreement on combating climate change as rising temperatures continue to drive more frequent and destructive extreme weather.
Building momentum at COP31 was always going to be difficult. Governments and the public are confronting a long list of competing crises, including wars, fragile economies and growing concerns about artificial intelligence, alongside climate disasters. Last year’s U.N. climate conference in Brazil appeared to have the potential for a historic breakthrough but instead ended in disappointment. For the second consecutive year, the United States — the world’s wealthiest nation and historically its largest polluter — was absent after the Trump administration withdrew from international climate negotiations.
Even so, veteran environmental advocates, climate scientists and negotiators from countries around the world remained hopeful that the summit might make progress on the central driver of global warming: coal, oil and gas.
The science has been settled for decades.
Burning fossil fuels releases greenhouse gases into the atmosphere. Those gases increase global average temperatures, disrupt ecosystems and contribute to more frequent and severe extreme weather events.
The basic answer is straightforward: countries must gradually burn less coal, oil and gas while expanding cleaner energy sources such as solar, wind and geothermal power. Reaching agreement on how to do that, however, is anything but simple — especially with major oil producers including Saudi Arabia, Russia and the United States, as well as major coal users such as China and India, at the negotiating table.
As a result, the words “fossil fuels” have become extraordinarily difficult to include in a final climate agreement, even though fossil fuels are the primary cause of climate change and U.N. summits are convened to address the crisis. Agreeing on a detailed plan to move away from them has proved even more elusive.
In three decades of climate negotiations, the main exception came at COP28 in Dubai, where the final decision urged countries to “transition away from fossil fuels.” The term did not appear in the final agreements at either of the next two conferences. This year’s summit ended without a final agreement at all.
Emerging fault lines finally cracked
The talks unfolded against a stark backdrop: communities worldwide were enduring deadly and costly extreme weather, while the leading international forum created to address the climate emergency struggled to move beyond limited steps. Eventually, that contradiction became impossible to contain.
At earlier climate conferences, countries often threatened to leave if negotiators failed to reach a strong agreement on fossil fuels. In the end, they typically aired their objections during closing sessions and accepted the outcome, reasoning that there would be another opportunity the following year and that preserving the broader negotiating process remained essential.
By the final week of this year’s summit, however — a week that extended into overtime and made the conference the longest on record — it was clear that many nations, including the European Union, were no longer prepared to follow that pattern.
Earlier in the week, Panama’s environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, appeared to capture the frustration shared by many participants when he said the COP process was being “held hostage by the petroleum mafia.”
Navarro compared the situation to “Stockholm syndrome,” in which captives — in this case, people concerned about the planet’s future — become “in love with our kidnappers,” referring to the oil industry.
The “petroleum guys” had persuaded the world that “they destroy nature to help us,” Navarro said.
Carbon removal became another major point of contention
The breakdown was not solely the result of leaving the main cause of climate change out of the final agreement. It also reflected what negotiators attempted to include. Draft versions, including the final text released early Sunday, encouraged countries to expand technologies designed to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and store it.
The oil industry strongly supports such technology, but it is energy-intensive, expensive and nowhere near widespread deployment. So far, carbon removal captures and stores far less than 1% of the estimated 60 billion tons of greenhouse gases emitted worldwide each year. For many participants, including carbon removal in the agreement represented either a misguided effort to promote a limited solution or, more troublingly, a way for major polluters to continue business as usual. If carbon pollution can supposedly be removed later, critics asked, what incentive is there to stop producing it now?
In the months ahead, governments and climate advocates will revisit what happened in Turkey and consider what it means for the next round of negotiations, scheduled to take place in Ethiopia next year. Longstanding doubts about the effectiveness of the U.N. climate process are likely to receive more scrutiny than ever.
Has the system reached the end of its usefulness, or could major reforms restore its credibility as a forum for confronting climate change? Proposals raised over the years include shortening the current two-week conference, limiting attendance to official delegates and reducing the summit’s overall size. In recent years, the gatherings have expanded so dramatically that they can feel more like trade fairs than negotiations focused on one of humanity’s greatest challenges.
Whatever happens to the U.N. climate process, extreme weather will continue — and likely worsen — as global temperatures climb. Many scientists expect 2026 to become the hottest year on record.
“Temperatures keep shattering records. Climate extremes keep intensifying. Emissions remain far too high,” United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres said in response to the outcome. “And every delay makes our task harder and more costly.”
___
Peter Prengaman has served as AP’s climate and environment news director since 2021 and can be followed here.
___
The Associated Press’ climate and environmental coverage receives financial support from multiple private foundations. AP is solely responsible for all content. Information about AP’s standards for working with philanthropies, its supporters and the areas covered by funded journalism is available at AP.org.
Copyright 2026 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.