Married Osceola Deputy Matthew Pippin Fired for On-Duty Sexting

A married Florida deputy was fired after allegedly using his department-issued phone to exchange sexually explicit photos while on duty, reportedly to keep the...
HomeNewsJudge Releases Defendant Despite 38 Prior Arrests

Judge Releases Defendant Despite 38 Prior Arrests

A New York judge released a man with 38 prior arrests just one day before he allegedly entered a woman’s apartment, sexually assaulted her and strangled her to death.

Manhattan Criminal Court Judge Juliet Howard ordered 25-year-old Alexander Florentino released under supervision on Thursday, despite prosecutors seeking $3,000 in cash bail or a $9,000 bond, the New York Post reported.

The homeless defendant had five other criminal cases pending and had repeatedly failed to appear in court, prompting the issuance of arrest warrants.

Howard, a Democrat who took office in January after previously working for The Legal Aid Society, freed Florentino following his appearance on petit larceny and criminal possession of stolen property charges.

The next afternoon, prosecutors say, Florentino entered a woman’s apartment on Catherine Street in Chinatown and carried out a violent attack that killed her and left her 66-year-old roommate hospitalized.

Prosecutors said Sunday that Florentino allegedly used a black cord to strangle the woman and subjected her to unwanted sexual contact in what appeared to be an attempted burglary.

The 64-year-old victim, according to testimony in court, was found lying face down in a pool of her own blood. She was partially undressed, with her underwear around one ankle and her sweatshirt unzipped.

Investigators observed ligature marks on her neck, while her face and lips were badly swollen and her skin had turned purple.

Manhattan Criminal Court Judge Juliet Howard ordered Alexander Florentino, 25, released under supervision Thursday despite prosecutors requesting $3,000 cash bail or a $9,000 bond

Judge Juliet Howard released 25-year-old Alexander Florentino under supervision despite prosecutors seeking $3,000 in cash bail or a $9,000 bond

The homeless suspect already had five other criminal cases pending and had repeatedly missed court appearances, resulting in warrants for his arrest

Florentino had five pending criminal cases and a history of missed court appearances that led to arrest warrants

Prosecutors revealed Sunday that Florentino allegedly strangled the woman with a black cord and subjected her to unwanted sexual contact during what appeared to be a botched burglary

Prosecutors allege that Florentino strangled the woman with a black cord and sexually assaulted her during an apparent burglary

The assault was interrupted when the woman’s roommate, who lived in the apartment with her and her husband, came home and confronted the intruder.

Florentino allegedly struck the man on the head with a beer bottle and tried to strangle him before escaping.

The roommate sustained a brain hemorrhage and facial injuries and remained in the hospital recovering.

Prosecutors said Florentino later attempted to enter another apartment one block away, but a resident prevented him from getting inside by securing a basement door.

He then ran across rooftops and scaffolding as police pursued him. Authorities said he broke a window at 9 Henry Street and barricaded himself inside a basement bathroom.

Investigators also recovered distinctive red shoes that Florentino allegedly wore in surveillance video recorded before the attack.

The case has intensified public anger over Florentino’s release despite his extensive criminal record.

New York City Councilman Phil Wong, a Democrat who sits on the public safety committee, criticized the decision and urged officials to strengthen bail policies.

The killing has sparked outrage over the decision to release Florentino despite his lengthy criminal history

Florentino’s release despite his lengthy criminal history has fueled outrage following the killing

New York City Councilman Phil Wong, a Democrat who serves on the public safety committee, slammed Howard's decision and called for tighter bail rules

Councilman Phil Wong criticized the release and called for stricter bail rules

‘This criminal should have been detained. He never should have been released,’ Wong told the Post.

‘There is a problem with the criminal justice system, which is a revolving door. They get released before the paperwork is complete.’

Wong said New York’s cashless bail rules should be reconsidered and tightened so repeat offenders cannot quickly return to the streets.

Florentino had also been released by another Manhattan judge only days earlier.

On November 13, Judge Valentina Morales released him under non-monetary conditions despite charges related to drug possession, criminal mischief, attempted arson and stolen property.

His record also showed an October 21 warrant issued after he failed to appear in court.

Morales, a former public defender appointed by then-Mayor Bill de Blasio in 2021, was reappointed by Mayor Zohran Mamdani earlier this month.

Judge Jeffrey Gershuny had likewise released Florentino after a September 28 arrest on petit larceny and stolen property charges.

Gershuny received a public censure in October over a courtroom experiment involving a handgun.

Florentino appeared in Manhattan Criminal Court on Sunday for his arraignment. He smiled while handcuffed and dressed in a protective jumpsuit and hood.

He faces 11 charges, including murder, attempted murder, strangulation, burglary and assault.

Judge Rachel Pauley ordered him held without bail, citing concerns that he would not return to court if released.

Authorities have not publicly identified the victim.