Unite NY is renewing its campaign to establish open primaries in New York City, submitting a new petition with 75,000 signatures amid an ongoing legal dispute with City Hall and opposition from Mayor Zohran Mamdani.
The nonpartisan group delivered the petitions to the City Clerk’s Office as a replacement for the 42,000 signatures it submitted in July. City officials rejected that filing, saying the signatures were invalid and effectively blocking the group’s effort to place the open-primary proposal on the ballot, according to a press release.
The latest petition drive is intended to restart the process and put the measure before voters ahead of the 2029 mayoral election. It also offers Unite NY a way to move forward while its lawsuit challenging the city’s handling of the July petitions remains pending.
Democrats outnumber Republicans in New York City by roughly six to one, meaning general-election outcomes are often determined during Democratic primaries months earlier. Critics say that leaves more than 1 million unaffiliated voters largely shut out of the city’s most consequential contests.
“More than 110,000 New Yorkers have signed petitions because they believe every voter deserves a voice in our elections,” Unite NY Executive Director Anthony Thomas said.
“Expanding voter participation and giving New Yorkers more choices at the ballot box is worth the effort. We intend to see this process through.”
Mamdani, who pulled off a surprise victory in the 2025 Democratic primary before defeating Democrat Andrew Cuomo in November while Cuomo ran on an independent line, has defended the city’s closed-primary system as officials continue to oppose the ballot initiative.
SEE ALSO: Napa Wine Expert and ‘Somm’ Star Ian Cauble Dies at 46
“I am quite content with the system of primaries that we have thus far,” Mamdani said in July, according to Gothamist. “I think that we’ve seen it’s a system that’s been in effect for quite some time. And it’s also a system that doesn’t preclude greater participation.”
Citizens Union, a New York City good-government organization, says the existing rules often mean mayors are “effectively chosen” by fewer than 10% of eligible voters. The group also argues that younger and minority voters, who are disproportionately unaffiliated, are excluded from the process while Super PACs gain greater influence.
According to nonprofit Reinvent Albany, only six of the nation’s 100 largest cities — Baltimore, Buffalo, Charlotte, New York, Philadelphia and Pittsburgh — hold closed primaries. New York City and Buffalo are the only two that allow candidates to appear on multiple party lines.
Unite NY said more than half of the city’s voters would be more likely to participate in elections if open primaries were adopted. The group maintains that the proposal has support among Democrats, Republicans and independent voters.
Advocates must complete two petitioning rounds to qualify the measure for the ballot: at least 30,000 signatures in the first round and 15,000 in the second. Unite NY said it was seeking 15,000 additional signatures; if the city accepts them, the new filing could make its legal challenge over the July petitions unnecessary.
City Hall did not immediately respond to a request for comment from The Post.