An Ohio woman convicted of suffocating her foster son and dumping his body in a sewer erupted at her attorney during a tense courtroom confrontation.
“You are the Antichrist!” Pammy Maye shouted at attorney Samuel Shamansky during her Nov. 19 sentencing hearing in Franklin County. “Yes, you are!”
Maye was convicted of aggravated murder, tampering with evidence and gross abuse of a corpse in the death of 5-year-old Darnell Taylor, according to court records reviewed by Oxygen.
“I need your cooperation,” Judge Mark Serrott told Maye as deputies restrained her. “You were well-behaved during the trial. What you do today could affect your sentence.”
“No, I’m not going to stop,” the 51-year-old replied before deputies escorted her from the courtroom.
After Maye returned, Shamansky told the judge he would withdraw from the case because Maye no longer wanted him as her attorney, Court TV reported.
“He represented me like he was a prosecutor instead of defending me,” Maye told the judge. “Plus, everything that was in the footage about me was edited.”
Serrott, however, praised Shamansky’s performance, calling it “one of the best closing arguments I’ve ever seen with nothing really to work with.”
Maye responded by muttering about “God’s wrath” and saying she had been “possessed by demons” before Jesus visited her a month earlier.
Serrott described Maye as “profoundly mentally ill” before sentencing her to 29 years to life in prison, with the possibility of parole.
Despite her earlier outburst, Maye cried while listening to statements from the victim’s family.
“I was very selfish,” she said, according to Court TV. “He was a loving child. He was a perfect child.”
The killing occurred on Feb. 13, 2024, after Maye became enraged when she discovered Darnell was “sneaking a granola bar and peanut butter crackers into his bed for a snack,” prosecutor Katherine Wolfe said.
“It was at that time,” Wolfe said, “she decided she was going to take his life.”
EXPLORE MORE: Premier League confirm nominees for Player & Manager of the Month for February 2024 – NewsFinale
The following evening, Columbus police received a disturbing call from Maye’s husband.
He told authorities that he had not seen Darnell all day. At about 3 a.m., Maye entered their bedroom, switched on the lights and delivered a chilling message: Darnell was dead.
During the 911 call, Maye allegedly placed her hand over her husband’s mouth and said she had a plan before leaving the home, according to a probable cause affidavit obtained by Oxygen.
Two hours later, Maye’s silver Jeep Cherokee was discovered abandoned in suburban Cleveland, according to the Franklin County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office. Maye remained missing until the next evening, when she appeared at a business with plastic bags covering her feet.
She was taken to a hospital, where she confessed to killing Darnell and told police where they could find his body.
Prosecutors said Maye admitted suffocating Darnell with a trash bag, tying it around his neck and placing his body inside additional garbage bags, which she hid in a living room closet.
She later put the boy’s body in the back of her Jeep, prosecutors said, then moved him to the front for a “quick transaction” before dumping his remains in a sewer drain.
Maye told investigators that she had planned the killing, citing Darnell’s bedtime snacks as the reason she decided to murder him.
Officers found Darnell’s body on Feb. 16 in a Franklin Township sewer.
During the trial, Shamansky acknowledged that Maye had killed Darnell but argued that she was not guilty by reason of insanity.
“The woman who committed this unspeakable and horrible act was so consumed with mental illness, mental illnesses we can only begin to imagine,” he said, according to Court TV. “She was most certainly unable and ill-equipped to understand how wrong this act was, to appreciate the wrongfulness of her act.”
The prosecution countered that although Maye suffered from mental illness, it did not prevent her from understanding that her actions were wrong when she killed Darnell.
The jury deliberated for just three hours before finding Maye guilty on every count.