Colin Baddiel was a difficult, complicated man. He could be irritable and quick to anger, emotionally guarded and demanding. Yet he was also intelligent, witty and passionate about pubs, good food, drinking with friends, Welsh football and sex—an appetite that seemed both relentless and remarkably loud.
So when he was diagnosed in his mid-60s with Pick’s disease, a rare form of dementia known for intensifying anger and irritability while weakening sexual restraint, the condition appeared to magnify traits that had always been part of his character.
He told almost everyone to f*** off, flashed V signs, stuck out his tongue and made sexually inappropriate remarks in restaurants. At his wife Sarah’s funeral in 2014, he propositioned several women in the congregation. Later, he was barred from a Jewish Care centre after punching another man during an argument that began when Colin mocked the size of his nose.
The story is known because Colin’s middle son, David, is a celebrated comedian, novelist, playwright, screenwriter, columnist, presenter, essayist and performer. As his father became increasingly unreachable, David turned to writing and comedy as a way of surviving the experience—finding bleak humour in the pain and making sense of an extraordinary family life.
In 2017, he and his elder brother Ivor made the acclaimed Channel 4 documentary The Trouble With Dad, which captured their strange, frequently darkly amusing relationship with Colin.
More than anything, comedy allowed David to bring his father’s dementia out of silence and into public conversation.
‘It helped me psychologically—it was the way I processed what was happening,’ he says. ‘But it also meant I could reach people in similar situations. They felt able to talk and laugh about it without feeling ashamed.’
Dementia is the UK’s leading cause of death, linked to around 76,000 deaths each year, while more than a million people are living with the gradual loss of memory, personality, independence and dignity. Yet, unlike many other illnesses, dementia is still often discussed with embarrassment or discomfort. The impact on carers can be just as profound as the effect on those diagnosed.
Ivor, Colin and David Baddiel in The Trouble With Dad, the Channel 4 documentary that explored their unusual and often darkly comic family dynamic
Colin, who endured a difficult childhood as an only child after his twin died at two, plays in a pool with his sons during a holiday
That is why David is supporting The Mail on Sunday and Alzheimer’s Society’s Dementia Carers Together campaign, offering an unfiltered account of his father’s illness alongside his reflections on death, family life, end-of-life care and society’s determination to keep loved ones alive at any cost.
‘We tend to write people off the moment they receive a diagnosis, and that is profoundly unfair,’ he says. ‘There are many types and stages of dementia, with plenty of light and shade. In many cases, the person is still very much there.’
Pick’s disease, also known as frontotemporal dementia, affects around 16,000 people. It results from damage to the frontal lobe, the area of the brain responsible for emotions, behaviour, personality and language.
In Colin’s case, the resulting behaviour became so difficult that care homes were unwilling to accept him. In the early stages, even discussing the possibility of dementia was painfully challenging.
‘It takes a lot of courage to tell someone you’re worried about their memory,’ David says. ‘I was nervous and apprehensive. I had been frightened of my father when I was growing up.’
After the diagnosis, Colin refused to acknowledge what was happening. ‘I never heard him admit that he had dementia,’ David recalls.
Sarah, by contrast, responded with anger. She attended a carers’ support group in Harrow where other women spoke warmly about their husbands and described how much they loved and cared for them.
Sarah did not share their sentiments.
‘She would say to me, “I’m furious. I’m so annoyed. I see women with husbands who are 90 and still out playing golf. Why couldn’t I have had one like that?”’
David found her honesty strangely comforting. ‘She wasn’t pretending to be some kind of saint. She was simply telling the truth. My parents had a complicated and fractured relationship.’
Many long marriages carry their own tensions and history. But Colin and Sarah’s relationship was unusually complicated, shaped by a lifetime of emotional baggage.
Colin had grown up in Swansea after losing his twin brother at the age of two. The experience left him angry and closed off. He was highly intelligent and funny, and eventually became a research scientist at Unilever.
But redundancy in the 1980s left him unemployed and unhappy for two years. He later sold Dinky Toys from a stall at Grays Antique Market in Mayfair, while maintaining a deep, often indiscriminate anger—towards life, his sons and Sarah.
Sarah’s past was equally turbulent. A Holocaust survivor and refugee from Nazi Germany, she came from a wealthy Prussian family in Königsberg, now Kaliningrad, whose fortune was confiscated and whose members were largely murdered.
She resisted the suburban life she had built with her family in Cricklewood through a passionate 30-year affair with David White, a golf memorabilia dealer. She wrote him intensely sexual letters and eventually established her own golf memorabilia business, Golfiana—the same name as his company—and became known as north London’s queen of golf collectibles.
‘I think she spent her life trying to reach the other existence she believed had been taken from her,’ David says.
Despite all the conflict, Colin and Sarah also maintained an extraordinarily noisy sex life. ‘They had loud sex almost every night. I was terrified by the sounds my father made,’ David recalls.
An old photograph of Sarah, Colin and David Baddiel; David describes his parents’ marriage as ‘complicated’ and ‘fractured’
David visited his father three times a week and endured a constant stream of insults—perhaps helping him recognise the dark comedy in their situation
For all their difficulties, Sarah became Colin’s principal carer as his condition worsened, just as countless partners and relatives do across the country. For years, she managed alone while both parents tried to reassure their three sons that everything was better than it really was.
‘He rejected help, while she was remarkably capable of coping,’ David says. ‘Looking back, I think we should have arranged professional support for my father sooner.’
Then Sarah died suddenly in 2014. ‘I believe it was an accidental overdose,’ David says. ‘She had undergone an operation in her 50s and took a lot of painkillers. She used them for the pain, but also to switch off a little, and one night she took too many.’
David and Ivor spent a traumatic day at the hospital as their mother drifted in and out of consciousness, all the while worrying about Colin alone at home. He could not be brought to the hospital because it would have been impossible to manage.
When they returned and told him Sarah had died, Colin collapsed emotionally. ‘It was striking because their relationship had not been particularly happy, but there was clearly a profound co-dependence,’ David says.
Around 45 minutes later, the brothers had to tell him again. Once more, he fell apart.
This continued for roughly a year. A note fixed to his tray explaining that Sarah had died eventually helped him understand, although he would still occasionally ask how she had passed away.
With Sarah gone, the family’s situation became even more difficult. David’s younger brother Dan returned from America for several months to care for Colin, but the responsibility proved overwhelming.
The family approached several care homes, but none would take Colin without additional funding for the extra staff they believed would be necessary to supervise him.
‘Fortunately, we could collectively afford live-in carers and found a company called Consultas,’ David says. That allowed Colin to remain in familiar surroundings, where he was considerably calmer.
‘He had always been naturally lazy, so he mostly sat in his chair watching television. We did not have to deal with him wandering away and being found on the high street, which can be one of the most frightening aspects of dementia.’
The years continued to pass.
David visited three times a week, often receiving insults and abuse from his father. ‘He was constantly attacking me verbally,’ he says. ‘Though, to be fair, he had always been somewhat like that.’
Perhaps that history was what enabled David to identify the grimly comic moments amid the distress.
There was the occasion they went to a pub in Harrow and Colin locked himself inside the car with the keys still in the ignition, drawing a crowd of around 30 people who tried to help.
His loss of sexual inhibition made him so explicit and foul-mouthed that David had to warn restaurant staff before they were seated.
On another occasion, Colin needed a hip operation and the family had to deceive him to get him through the hospital entrance.
‘He sat there shouting at people and telling them to f*** off. Even while being wheeled into theatre, he was making V signs at the nurses.’
But behind the jokes, David admits the experience could become unbearable.
‘Yes, absolutely,’ he says, his voice softening. ‘There were times when I simply could not cope with it.’
He still has a photograph of Colin at a Wetherspoons pub in Harrow.
‘It is heartbreaking. Somewhere inside him, I can sense the person he used to be—clever and funny—but he is trapped in there.’
As the disease advanced, David found that it was erasing his own memories of his father, too.
‘I had forgotten that he could sometimes be a good father. I remembered one occasion when he came backstage after one of my shows and told me how good it had been.’
He also became increasingly alert to his own memory lapses. ‘When you are the adult child of someone with dementia, you become hyper-aware of every moment of forgetfulness.’
Still, he continued to visit—from the years of foul language, abuse and uninhibited behaviour to the later period when Colin became almost entirely blank and unresponsive.
‘I loved him, despite the fact that he was difficult,’ David says. ‘I needed to know that we still had some kind of relationship. I could not bear the idea that this difficult man had disappeared. But I never really felt he was gone. It was more as though he was locked away, buried beneath the rubble of dementia.’
Colin died in January 2022, leaving David devastated despite the long years of difficulty and grief
As the illness progressed, Colin eventually stopped speaking.
‘Often he would say nothing at all. Sometimes he might stick out his tongue, and I would speak with the carers instead.’
David would then drive home, frequently in tears.
He came to understand that, like so many relatives caring for someone with dementia, he was visiting in the hope of seeing a brief glimpse of the old Colin—a familiar catchphrase such as ‘Your face, my a***!’ or a moment of interest in the football on television.
In his final years, Colin developed numerous other health problems but could no longer understand what was happening. Repeated urinary tract infections sent him to hospital, sometimes appearing to bring him close to death, only for him to recover again.
‘There is something deeply complicated in the way our society keeps people alive long after nature seems to have decided that their life should end,’ David says.
Colin Baddiel eventually died in January 2022. Even after years of anguish, exhaustion and anticipating the loss, David was devastated.
He shared a photograph on social media showing his father laughing with his three sons in the sea, writing that Colin had left ‘a huge hole in my sky’.
‘No matter how diminished someone becomes, they remain enormously important in your life,’ he says. ‘When they are gone, you are disoriented. You do not know how to make sense of the absence. There is this enormous space left behind.’
Watching someone you love slowly disappear through dementia is a devastating form of grief.
Some people withdraw. Others turn to support groups or professional help. David responded by speaking openly about the difficulties his remarkable family endured, becoming an ambassador for Alzheimer’s Society and offering solidarity to others facing the same bewildering experience.
Above all, he has chosen to remember and celebrate his deeply complicated, often brilliant parents through humour.
MUST READ: California Therapist Who Vanished With Patient Accused of Preying on Abused Boys: Lawsuit