When staunch Europhile Tony Blair cautions our unelected Prime Minister against rejoining the European Union unless the bloc embraces technological innovation, his warning deserves attention.
Blair understands that the EU is highly unlikely to dismantle the bureaucracy and regulations that are holding back emerging technologies, including artificial intelligence.
The former prime minister is urging Andy Burnham to slow down. Two former Labour Cabinet ministers with strong pro-European views, Lord Blunkett and Alan Johnson, also advised our apparently frantic Prime Minister to show restraint yesterday.
Writing in one newspaper, Blunkett said he was ‘sceptical’ about Burnham’s courtship of Brussels and warned that ‘the electorate are not yet ready for even bolder moves to integration’. Johnson used another newspaper column to tell the Prime Minister to ‘leave alone’ the idea of a second divisive referendum.
Will the occupant of No 10 listen to his former colleagues – or to former Conservative prime minister Theresa May, who said yesterday that he should ‘accept Brexit and move on?’ Will he take seriously the criticism from former Tory premiers Boris Johnson and Rishi Sunak?
I doubt it. Andy Burnham appears to have decided that dragging Britain back into the loveless, expensive embrace of the European Union will define his time as prime minister.
Andy Burnham with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and European Council President Antonio Costa on Friday
He also seems convinced that restoring Britain’s place at the centre of Europe, and eventually rejoining the EU, will prove a winning strategy at the next election, which could take place as soon as next year.
Driven by that ambition, he appears willing to accept almost any indignity as Brussels negotiates aggressively and demands tens of billions of euros for the closer relationship he so desperately wants.
Consider Andy’s expression as he held hands with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and European Council President Antonio Costa on Friday. He looked ecstatic – as though he had just collected the EuroMillions jackpot.
There will undoubtedly be some winners from the arrangement. Those taking their dogs to the Continent or exporting molluscs to France may face less paperwork than the mountain of forms Brussels has imposed since Britain left the EU.
For most people, however, the so-called ‘reset’ is a poor bargain. The removal of post-Brexit checks and restrictions on food and agricultural products is being presented as a benefit. But why? EU food exports to Britain are worth more than three times the value of British exports to the bloc.
The agreement also leaves Britain bound by future EU rules in these areas without any representation in their creation. In effect, the UK has entered the Single Market for food. Nigel Farage is therefore right to argue that Labour has broken its manifesto promise not to rejoin the Single Market.
Tony Blair has warned the Prime Minister against rejoining the European Union unless the bloc modernises its approach to technology
Even so, Brussels demanded further concessions. As many as 100,000 young Europeans will be permitted to work in Britain, competing for jobs with young Britons who are already struggling to find employment. Although the arrangement is reciprocal, significantly more people are expected to come here than travel in the opposite direction.
That still did not satisfy the Eurocrats. In a late intervention, they demanded that Burnham reduce the annual tuition fee for EU students at British universities from £38,000 to the domestic rate of £9,970.
The measure could cost close to £500 million every year, with the bill falling on the Government, universities or both. Several vice-chancellors have already voiced serious concerns.
NEXT UP: Australia’s Climate and Energy Minister Chris Bowen Accepts Blame for Collapse of Climate Talks
Anand Menon, director of the pro-EU organisation UK In A Changing Europe, says Brussels’s proposed arrangement would especially benefit Eurocrats, many of whom send their children to Britain’s most prestigious universities.
Britain does not subsidise students from Australia, India or the United States, so why should it fund students from EU countries? It is an extraordinary demand and another sign that Brussels regards the UK as a source of money to be tapped.
It is also apparent – despite efforts by the Government and Brussels to minimise the issue – that the entire ‘reset’ could collapse unless Britain agrees to subsidise EU students. The Prime Minister has been given six months to respond. Almost certainly, the answer will be ‘Yes’.
The Government says the ‘reset’ could add ‘up to’ 0.5 per cent to GDP by 2040. That deadline is so far away that the estimate might as well have been scribbled on the back of a rail ticket during Andy Burnham’s Eurostar journey to Brussels.
The Conservatives calculate that the agreement could add £281 a year to the average British household’s energy bill, because the Government has agreed to rejoin the EU’s Emissions Trading System. The carbon market is designed to speed the drive towards Net Zero by reducing pollution.
Burnham has called his arrangement – despite not yet having secured one – ‘win, win’. A collection of slippery Cabinet ministers, including Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband, have repeated the phrase with mechanical enthusiasm.
Our Prime Minister appears to have an unusual desire to turn the clock back – to the Britain of the 1970s, despite its economic weakness, and to the European Union, even as some of its leading members move sharply to the Right.
He seems prepared to endure repeated humiliations and accept almost any compromise Brussels places before him if it brings Britain closer to the heart of Europe.
EU negotiators know that the Prime Minister wants a closer relationship at almost any price. They regard him with the indulgent amusement of casino croupiers watching a naïve young gambler arrive with pockets full of cash.
For Andy Burnham to portray Friday’s crushing defeat as a triumph borders on the absurd. Only those who share his desire to rejoin the European Union regardless of the cost will view the ‘reset’ as a success.
Many others – including people who do not necessarily support Brexit – will see through the spin. They are unlikely to admire a British prime minister who repeatedly allows Brussels to take advantage of him.
It would be reasonable to conclude that Burnham is his own worst enemy, and that his unrestrained enthusiasm for Europe will eventually damage him. I would not be so confident.
Those who accept Brexit should worry that Burnham may call an election next year, before the full extent of his concessions to Brussels becomes clear. Labour’s manifesto is likely to contain only broad pledges about building closer ties with Europe.
Yet who seriously doubts that, if Andy Burnham wins and secures a five-year term, he would try to lead Britain back into the European Union?
Nor should anyone assume that a second referendum would prevent it. In 2004, Tony Blair promised a vote on a new European Constitution, only to abandon that commitment when the Lisbon Treaty later provided a broadly similar settlement.
The warning is clear. Andy Burnham’s devotion to the European Union may appear unbalanced, but he is also a calculating politician who will use every available means to achieve his ambition.