The crew of the ill-fated superyacht Bayesian did not know about a safety vulnerability that left the vessel exposed to powerful winds before it sank, investigators have concluded.
British technology billionaire Mike Lynch, 59, and his 18-year-old daughter Hannah were among seven people who died when the luxury yacht sank off Sicily in winds reaching 80mph.
The storm, described as a “downburst”, pushed the Bayesian on to its side in just 15 seconds. The 186ft vessel sank within 16 minutes in August 2024.
No individual or organisation was held responsible for the tragedy in the 90-page report published by the UK Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB).
Instead, investigators focused on the crew’s lack of awareness of the yacht’s vulnerabilities in exceptionally strong winds.
The findings are expected to contrast sharply with an Italian investigation which, according to reports in the local media, is likely to conclude next month that the crew was responsible rather than defects in the yacht.
The Bayesian, valued at more than £30million and known for its 237ft mast, was carrying 22 passengers and crew when it capsized near the fishing village of Porticello.
Mr Lynch had chartered the yacht partly to celebrate his acquittal on fraud charges connected to Hewlett-Packard’s 2011 purchase of his software company, Autonomy. His daughter had recently completed her A-levels and secured a place to study English at Oxford University.
New images show the Bayesian superyacht after its wreckage was recovered during a salvage operation
Brilliant student Hannah Lynch, 18, was among seven people who died when the luxury yacht sank off Sicily in 80mph winds
The other victims were Britons Jonathan Bloomer, 70, chairman of Morgan Stanley International, and his wife Judy, 71; American lawyer Chris Morvillo, 59, who worked for Clifford Chance, and his wife Neda, 57; and the yacht’s Canadian-Antiguan chef, Recaldo Thomas, 59.
Fifteen people, including Mr Lynch’s wife Angela Bacares, were rescued.
The MAIB report said that “official weather forecasts for the area, although broadly accurate, did not communicate the potential severity and impact of the predicted thunderstorms”.
Investigators found that the Bayesian was susceptible to strong winds but had never been properly assessed while anchored with its sails lowered and its retractable keel raised.
They also concluded that the crew had not received adequate warning about the risk.
Lead investigator David Robertson told a press briefing on Wednesday: “The forecast didn’t mention the chance of violent winds, crew training hadn’t covered it and guidance didn’t cover it.
“All of that combined to limit the crew’s ability to recognise the developing hazard and take timely action.”
The investigators said the yacht’s “vulnerabilities” in high winds were “unknown to either the owner or the crew of Bayesian” because they were not listed in the Stability Information Book carried on board.
The booklet, which serves as an operating manual and sets out the vessel’s physical limitations, did not include weaknesses in the yacht’s design.
Instead, it contained only “generic instructions” and was of “limited usefulness in supporting the crew’s preparations for an approaching storm when the yacht was at anchor”, investigators said.
“These vulnerabilities were not identified. Consequently, these vulnerabilities were also unknown to either the owner or the crew of Bayesian,” they added.
Seven people, including technology billionaire Mike Lynch and his daughter Hannah, died when the Bayesian sank in a freak storm in 2024
YOU MAY ALSO READ: Susan Smith Prosecutor Opposes Release, Says It Would Force Grieving Father to Face Her “Every Day”
New Zealand national James Cutfield, 51, was captain of the Bayesian
At around 4am on the morning of the disaster, the wind reached 80mph. The Bayesian heeled over by 90 degrees before sinking.
“People, furniture and loose items fell across the deck,” the report said, with several passengers and crew members injured by “falling or items falling on them”.
Some guests used drawers from furniture as makeshift ladders, climbing along the internal walls before reaching the wheelhouse and jumping into the sea.
None of the yacht’s life rafts automatically floated free and inflated during the sinking, meaning the crew had to release them manually, the report found.
MAIB principal inspector Simon Graves said: “The crew were reacting to the situation they found themselves in. The weather forecasts for that day gave generally reasonable weather with the possibility of thunderstorms, but none of the forecasts described the weather that they actually experienced.”
He added: “Unfortunately, they were overtaken by events and the speed of the knockdown.
“They went from being in a calm situation to a violent storm, to being knocked over in a very short space of time, which gave them very little time to react. Once the vessel had been knocked down, they set off the emergency rescue beacon and released the life raft.
“They managed to get some of the guests out of the vessel and into the life raft, giving them the best chance of survival.”
The MAIB’s conclusions are likely to conflict with those of the ongoing Italian investigation.
Earlier this month, a file reportedly sent to Italian prosecutors concluded that the Bayesian was “well-built, safe and designed to withstand a weather event such as the one that struck the vessel on the night it sank”.
While the MAIB described the weather as a freak storm, Italian experts reportedly characterised it as “little more than a squall” and blamed “human incompetence” for the deaths. Sicilian prosecutors say the keel should have been lowered rather than raised and that the weather conditions were “manageable”.
On the differences between the British and Italian inquiries, Mr Graves said they were “entirely separate and it’s quite reasonable that they will come to different conclusions because their objectives are different”.
Bayesian captain James Cutfield, a New Zealander; British chief engineer Tim Parker Eaton; and British deckhand Matthew Griffiths, who was on watch on the night of the sinking, are all under investigation in Italy. They could face charges of multiple manslaughter and causing a disaster, offences that each carry a maximum sentence of 15 years in prison.
A survivor who escaped with her one-year-old daughter is suing the crew for damages.
According to court documents seen by The Sun, Charlotte Golunski and her partner James Emslie claim that no alarm sounded as the yacht capsized. Ms Golunski alleges that the crew failed to warn guests, provide a safety briefing for her daughter or explain how to reach the life jackets.
She further claims that the order to abandon ship was not given “until it was too late” and that the emergency lighting failed. “For two seconds I lost my daughter in the sea then quickly hugged her amid the fury of the waves,” Ms Golunski previously told Italian media.
The MAIB report recommended that industry guidance address the risk of yachts being knocked down in high winds when their sails are not deployed. It also called on the Maritime and Coastguard Agency to review guidance on extreme-weather downbursts.
Rob Loder, the UK’s chief inspector of marine accidents, said: “Our investigation found that Bayesian had a vulnerability to high winds that was not recognised, because the yacht had never been assessed at anchor with its sails down. The extreme winds that night were also not explicitly forecast, so the crew had no warning of the risk.
“MAIB has published a safety flyer for the industry and a report which makes recommendations covering vessel design standards, crew training and how rare but severe weather is represented in forecasts. I urge everyone with a part to play, including regulators, training providers and weather services, to read our report and act on it, so that a tragedy like this is not repeated.”
UK inquests are examining the deaths of Mr Lynch, his daughter and Mr and Mrs Bloomer. The Maritime and Coastguard Agency is also investigating the yacht’s sinking.
READ MORE
RELATED: Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang Is Already Planning the Company’s Return