Gavin Newsom Prioritizes ‘Cultural Burns’ Over Traditional Brush Clearing: What It Means for California’s Wildfire Strategy

California Governor Gavin Newsom has dedicated significant funding to support Native American initiatives, including those focused on “food sovereignty,” owl population monitoring, and “cultural burns.” These traditional fire management practices help tribes maintain a deep connection with the environment by using fire to manage vegetation and protect ecosystems.

Since 2023, CalFire, officially known as the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection, has distributed $24 million to tribal organizations and other nonprofit entities through its “Tribal Wildfire Resilience” program.

Wade Crowfoot, the Natural Resources Secretary, oversees this initiative. He has voiced the belief that California’s history includes a “state-sanctioned policy of genocide,” leading to long-standing issues of land loss, discrimination, and cultural disconnection for Native American communities.

Crowfoot emphasizes that the Newsom administration is working to restore land management roles to California’s Native American tribes.

In alignment with this goal, California has introduced distinct fire-certification processes tailored for both tribal and nontribal communities, supporting the practice of “cultural burning” as part of the state’s broader environmental and cultural strategy.

White, black, Latino and Asian fire bosses must receive technical certifications, including a 40-hour burn-boss course and, in some cases, a federal certificate.

“Cultural fire practitioners,” by contrast, are certified through simple tribal recognition that a person has “substantial experience” burning for cultural purposes. 

The “cultural burns” themselves follow various rituals. Some begin with drumming, sage burning and a prayer. Attendees sometimes go around in a circle, introducing themselves to the land. In the words of Ron Goode, chief of the North Fork Mono Tribe, the land listens to the incantations, and the intention is “to make sure that everything on the landscape — Mother Earth, Creator, everybody — understands why we’re there and what we’re there for.”

Then the burning begins. One tribal member uses a traditional elderberry fire stick instead of a modern lighter. Some use dry branches and cottonwood bundles as kindling. In the words of one tribal chief, “Fire gives life to the land, and everyone benefits from this living spirit.”

While some of the “resiliency” funding has gone toward what appear to be legitimate fire-management projects, a careful examination of the state grant information reveals that much of the program operates as a slush fund for the tribes. 

In recent years, CalFire has awarded grants that have dubious fire-management benefits: $1 million for a grant that will help a tribe provide “forest-themed ingredients” to tribe-owned restaurants; $599,000 for another to help renovate land for use as a Native American summer camp; $166,000 to one that will pay for “[t]ribal staff and members” to observe spotted owl nests; $746,000 to one supporting a tribe’s “food sovereignty” and “Fire-Centered Climate Action Plan”; and $521,000 to one that will help a tribe maintain “close kinship” with plants, animals, and “other natural relatives such as water and fire.” 

In 2022, California projected that tribes, “cultural fire practitioners,” and others would conduct 25,000 acres of prescribed burning annually by 2025. The state has not released any data on the tribes’ progress, and some tribal leaders apparently insist on keeping the fires small. As Ron Goode explained, “We never burn anything bigger than a big beaver hut.”

Download The California Post App, follow us on social, and subscribe to our newsletters

For Butte County’s Maidu Indians, the cultural burn initiative seems less about fire management and more about soliciting state funds for cultural programs.

“Cultural fire has a lot of cultural aspects to it,” said tribal member Magan Herrera. “We’re burning deergrass for basketry, not necessarily for wildfire resilience, right? But it does have both of those worlds.”

In a video released by CalFire, one man is seen starting the process of burning a small lot of land with a modern propane torch, and tribal members later appear to join in.

“We actually learned a lot with this grant,” said one tribal member on the work crew. “When we first started, we really didn’t understand. We thought it was just cutting down trees and piling and burning, but really it was much more.” 

While any group is entitled to preserve its heritage, taxpayers are not obligated to subsidize it. California Democrats have sought to mask their handouts to the tribes as a public good, but these are reckless expenditures for a fiscally strained state, with massive risks.

The dry season is approaching — and California politicians are playing with fire.

Christopher F. Rufo is a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, a contributing editor of City Journal, and the author of America’s Cultural Revolution. Austen Hufford is a senior investigative reporter at City Journal.