Judge John Lyke has been a familiar figure in the legal proceedings of Alphanso Talley for over three years. Talley, aged 26, found himself once again standing before Lyke on Tuesday, marking the first time since he faced charges related to a fatal shooting at a North Side hospital.
In a development that has attracted attention, court documents obtained by ABC7 have illuminated Judge Lyke’s decision late last year not to detain Talley, despite a history marked by violent criminal behavior. This decision has come under scrutiny, especially in light of recent events.
ABC7 Chicago is now streaming 24/7. Click here to watch
Talley is scheduled to return to court on Thursday concerning the murder of Chicago Police Officer John Bartholomew and the attempted murder of another officer during Saturday’s tragic incident at Swedish Hospital. The case has cast a somber shadow over the community, with many seeking answers and justice.
On Tuesday, the Chicago Police Department released a poignant photo of Officer Bartholomew, accompanied by a heartfelt statement: “Officer Bartholomew dedicated his life to protecting his fellow Chicagoans. Above all, he was a beloved father, husband, son, and brother. We promise to ensure his sacrifice will never be forgotten.” The tribute underscores the profound loss felt by both the force and the community.
Interestingly, the hearing on Tuesday was not directly related to the recent charges but rather addressed alleged crimes Talley committed in May 2025. This detail adds another layer to the unfolding legal narrative surrounding Talley.
Talley’s case has renewed the hot-button issue of electronic monitoring for violent repeat offenders, and Lyke is facing heavy criticism from police supporters for not detaining Talley back in Deceber.
SEE ALSO | Swedish Hospital shooting: What we know about suspected cop killer’s lengthy criminal history
Court records show Talley had an arrest warrant pending for violating his electronic monitoring before Saturday’s shooting. According to those records, Talley first got an electronic monitor last year on Dec. 11, but his monitor alerted two violations within three days in early March.
“We established that he had four pending violent felonies, and in spite of that, he was placed on electronic monitoring. Electronic monitoring system is broken. It does not work. It is not keeping people safe,” said Cook County State’s Attorney Eileen O’Neill Burke.
O’Neill Burke believes her office did its job in presenting the case for Talley to be detained during a December 2025 hearing stemming from an alleged armed carjacking and armed robbery eight months earlier.
Court documents ABC7 obtained from that December hearing show Lyke admitted that “The mere fact that he has four pending cases is egregious in and of itself and it may in certain instances shock the conscience.” But under Illinois law, judges are required to evaluate each case individually.
And while referencing Talley recently becoming a father, Lyke said, “It appears his mind is finally developing, and he may be on the path to making better decisions.”
Lyke also acknowledged at the December hearing that under the state’s old cash bail system, Talley would have faced a minimum bail of $1 million.
“Our esteemed legislature says, no, we’re not going to do that anymore. We’re going to make judges take a critical look at it,” Lyke said, at the time, before eventually ruling despite the “state’s rigorous objection” to let Talley out with an ankle bracelet.
Court transcripts from that hearingreveal prosecutors argued Talley should remain behind bars, telling the court, “There are no conditions… that can guarantee the defendant’s compliance with any other former of pretrial release, including electronic monitoring.”
“When the state’s attorney’s office asked for detention, we ask for detention because we believe that person presents a danger to the public,” O’Neill Burke said.
A legal analyst ABC7 spoke with says the judge’s decision was based on the evidence at the time.
“Unfortunately, with this case, we are looking at it with the lens of knowing that an absolute tragedy occurred,” said Sarah Toney with the Toney Law Firm and theIllinois State Bar Association.
Toney said the failure in this case cannot be attributed to one person or issue.
“When he failed to appear in court in March, the judge didn’t just let that slide. He issued a warrant, as he exactly should have. And unfortunately, that warrant never got executed there,” Toney said.
Tuesday’s hearing for Talley’s carjacking and armed robbery charges lasted roughly two minutes. There was no interaction between Talley and Lyke, and Lyke only briefly mentioned another “matter,” apparently referencing Talley’s murder charge.
CPD Officer Carlos Yanez Jr., who was shot in the face during a shooting that took the life of his partner, Officer Ella French, attended Tuesday’s hearing. Yanez says he was there to see if there would be any accountability from the judge.
“Just acknowledging that you know, he released him back out into the streets, and then he goes and continues committing acts of violence. I mean, like he should have never been out on the streets,” Yanez said. “And it breaks my heart, because there’s a pattern there, you know, not everybody can be rehabilitated.”
During an ABC7 town hall on Tuesday afternoon, Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson was asked about the shooting and how Talley managed to be out of jail, despite his criminal history and warrants out for his arrest.
“One act of violence is one too many. And what I’ve always said, we have to hold individuals accountable. We also have to do it constitutionally,” Johnson said.
Chief Judge Charles Beach issued a statement, saying, “Chief Judge Beach extends his deepest condolences to the family of Officer John Bartholomew and to the men and women of the Chicago Police Department. This is a devastating loss.
The Chief Judge takes seriously any concern about the effectiveness of electronic monitoring and the safety of our communities. As he has stated since taking office, accountability and continuous improvement are non-negotiable. This office proactively strengthened its EM protocols in January, and remains committed to the continuous evaluation and improvement of its oversight processes.
Out of respect for the integrity of the ongoing criminal proceedings, the Office of the Chief Judge will not comment further on the specifics of this case at this time.”
Questions surround how suspect brought gun into hospital
Police sources told ABC7 that the suspect was likely searched at least three times but still managed to sneak a gun into the hospital.
Police sources told ABC7 that the suspect was likely searched at least three times but still managed to sneak a gun into the hospital.
“He knew exactly what he was going to do when he got on his way to the hospital,” said ABC7 police affairs consultant Bill Kushner.
Law enforcement sources believe Talley hid the gun in his body, where officers were apparently reluctant to search.
“Police do not want to be put in a situation where they’re being accused of sexual assault simply for trying to make sure someone isn’t hiding a gun or a knife in somebody bodily orifice,” said 15th Ward Ald. Ray Lopez.
When Bartholomew unlocked Talley’s handcuffs, prosecutors say, he was able to grab the weapon and shoot the officer in the head, killing him. He then allegedly shot a second officer in the face, leaving him critically injured.
Police sources say Talley likely made up a story that he had swallowed bags of drugs in order to be taken to the hospital. They say he has done this numerous times in his past.
“They’re feigning that they swallowed a bag of dope, is a great way to facilitate an escape attempt,” Kushner said.
Tributes for fallen CPD officer pour in
People in the community are doing what they can to support our first responders.
Meanwhile, tributes to Bartholomew are pouring in.
The Chicago Police Department is honoring Bartholomew as a person who dedicated his life to protecting his city with a vow to ensure his sacrifice is not forgotten.
The Greek Orthodox Metropolis of Chicago organized a prayer service. Bartholomew was solemnly honored Sunday at St. Andrew’s Greek Orthodox Church.
And Reilly’s Daughter Irish Pub is stepping up once again, selling T-shirts this Friday with a tribute to Bartholomew on the back.
“Anything we can do to help ease the financial burden and help out the community, that’s what we love to do,” said Brendan O’Brien, the owner of Reilly’s Daughter Irish Pub in Oak Lawn.
All the funds raised, the owner said, will go directly to his family.
“A lot of my friends, family, members, etc. are Chicago cops, fireman, and city workers,” O’Brien said. “My grandfather was a battalion chief of the Chicago Fire Department. My uncle was a lieutenant, a lot of my uncles are Chicago police…It’s just something you do to help out with your community and help out first responders and other families.”
This isn’t the first time O’Brien has done this.
The bar also raised several thousand dollars for fallen Firefighter Michael Altman’s family earlier this year, when he was killed in the line of duty.
“Unfortunately, when we have to do this, we’ve probably done this 15 plus times for officers over the years and fireman over the years,” O’Brien said. “We’ve done it repeatedly. When we have to make a shirt it’s not a good thing.”
People in the community are doing what they can to support first responders.
“It’s a really hard job,” O’Brien said. “The men and women of the city of Chicago and the first responders. My heart goes out to them, and I just really hope that we can do our best to raise as much money as we can for his family.”
If you want to support this effort, you can purchase a T-shirt in person at Reilly’s Daughter in Oak Lawn at 6 p.m. on Friday.
Afterwards, they will transition to online sales so people can continue supporting the cause that way.
INTERACTIVE SAFETY TRACKER Track crime and safety in your neighborhood
Copyright © 2026 WLS-TV. All Rights Reserved.
