Arielle Kebbel’s Dating History: The Familiar Faces Linked to The Marshals Star

Arielle Kebbel plays Deputy U.S. Marshal Belle Skinner on television’s adrenaline-fueled “Marshals,” but her personal life became noticeably quieter in 2026. The actress is currently single after revealing early in the year that she had changed her relationship status. Although Kebbel has been romantically linked to several recognizable names over the years, she said she is now using this period to focus on herself. “Now I’m in a place of really leaning into my own life choices, I feel like probably for the first time in my life,” she said during a February 2026 appearance on the “Off the Vine with Kaitlyn Bristowe” podcast.

Reaching this point has involved plenty of emotional highs and lows. “I don’t think I was really ready to get to know myself in [this] way,” Kebbel admitted. Now in her early 40s, she has been reassessing her priorities and examining the patterns she wants to change. “What do I need to explore to really change patterns for myself in the future, for my heart, for my soul, for what I want moving forward?” she asked.

Kebbel said she is thankful for the personal transformation, explaining that she had never before felt able to be completely truthful with herself. While her romantic future remains uncertain, she has previously spoken about wanting to build a family. “At some point I want a family. I feel being a film producer and more behind-the-camera will help to give me more control over my schedule than I have today,” she told Bedford & New Canaan Magazine in 2023. Her past relationships have included several high-profile men, though none ultimately lasted.

Making “Vampire Diaries” fans’ hearts explode with joy, Arielle Kebbel’s relationship with Zach Roerig came to light at a fan convention in Covington, Georgia, in April 2026, when fans shared a video of Roerig surprising her with flowers before they shared a kiss. “I meet this woman, I fall in love with her, and I get to work with her,” Roerig tells fans, to a resounding collective “Aw.” However, the timeline of their romance is a bit blurry. 

Kebbel and the Hallmark actor first worked together briefly on the popular teen series in 2009 and reunited on the show again in 2017. Their connection resurfaced while filming the 2023 movie “Love in the Great Smoky Mountains: A National Park Romance.” In September 2024, the pair attended a New York City screening of the short-film series “Window to the West,” where they appeared to be a couple. The event, pictured above, seems to have been their only major public appearance together. After sharing a steamy kiss at a convention, Kebbel and Roerig largely kept their relationship private.

Kebbel confirmed that she and Roerig had ended their relationship during her February 2026 interview on “Off the Vine with Kaitlyn Bristowe.” “I haven’t been in a relationship in quite some time,” she told Bristowe. The actress did not clarify exactly how long it had been, although her comments suggest the breakup may have occurred in 2025. She also declined to discuss the details, but indicated that the split was deeply painful. “It was one of the hardest things I’ve ever done,” she said.

Kebbel began dating polo player Nic Roldan in 2018, connecting in part over their shared love of horses. That September, the Argentina-born athlete moved back to his home country to compete in South America, a region that dominates the sport. Roldan expected the relocation to be temporary and planned to return to the United States, where he was raised, in December. Still, he acknowledged that the long-distance arrangement would be difficult for the new couple.

Roldan and Kebbel had been together for only a few months when he relocated to Buenos Aires, making the timing especially challenging. “It’s not easy. It’s still very new — we’ve only been dating for three months — but obviously it’s hard,” he told Argentina’s Infobae in Spanish in November 2018. They planned to see each other at least once a month, with the partner who had more availability traveling to visit the other.

Kebbel was filming “Midnight, Texas” at the time, making frequent travel difficult. “Now that she just premiered a series, she’s swamped and can’t come, so I’m going to visit her for four days,” Roldan said. Polo players regularly travel for open tournaments, meaning his demanding schedule was unlikely to ease. “The hardest part is the beginning — if we make it through this, we’re set!” he added. The relationship apparently did not survive the distance, although the exact breakup date is unknown and it appears to have been relatively brief.

CONTINUE READING: Banana Ball Goes Global: What to Know Before You Flip Out

In the early 2010s, Kebbel was romantically involved with Aaron Bay-Schuck, who has served as CEO of Warner Records since 2017. During their relationship, Bay-Schuck became president of A&R at Interscope Geffen A&M, working with artists including Gwen Stefani, Imagine Dragons, Lady Gaga, Lana Del Rey, Maroon 5, MGK, and Selena Gomez. Few details about their romance were made public, but the couple attended several prominent events together beginning in 2012.

Their last widely documented appearance together appears to have been the Art of Elysium and Samsung Galaxy gala at Hangar 8 in January 2015, pictured above. The timing of their split is uncertain, with some reports placing it in 2016. By 2017, however, Bay-Schuck was dating fellow music executive Hannah Montgomery, whom he married in November 2020. While it lasted, his relationship with Kebbel appeared to be a serious one.

Beautiful day at the crib celebrating my mom’s 70th bday with @ArielleKebbel, @TheRealNimoy, family and great friends pic.twitter.com/MOpGMiZ0dO

— Aaron Bay-Schuck (@bayschuck) March 9, 2013

In 2013, Kebbel was next to Bay-Schuck and his family when they gathered to celebrate his mother, a moment he marked on X with a picture of the two together (seen above). “Beautiful day at the crib celebrating my mom’s 70th bday with @ArielleKebbel, @TheRealNimoy, family and great friends,” he wrote, also tagging his late stepfather, Leonard Nimoy. When he was appointed president of Interscope Geffen A&M Records in 2014, he highlighted his then-girlfriend’s support. “@ArielleKebbel my #1 fan :-),” he posted. 

Near the end of Kebbel’s “Gilmore Girls” era, she began dating film producer Brahman Turner. As with several of her relationships, the precise timeline is unclear, but their joint appearances at Hollywood events between 2004 and 2006 offer a rough indication. They made their public debut as a couple at the “Mean Girls” premiere in April 2004, shown above.

The pair also worked together professionally when Turner directed Kebbel in “Daydreamer,” the 2007 film in which she starred opposite Aaron Paul. Its release came around what appears to have been the final stage of their relationship. Although little is known about their romance, the two were frequently seen enjoying Hollywood parties during the mid-2000s. One photo shows them having fun at the Ashlee Simpson record-release party hosted by Mean Magazine in July 2004.

Turner later married model Jessica Stam. The couple began dating in 2016, roughly a decade after his relationship with Kebbel ended. They have two children and live in Hawaii.