A glampsite owner is embroiled in a £135,000 legal battle with her neighbours after attempting to stop them driving their car across a shared track to park in their own garden.
Carol Esteban, 60, runs a farm-based glamping business on the edge of Wales’s Brecon Beacons National Park. She became involved in a dispute with Neil and Nadine Gould over the driveway linking both of their properties.
Ms Esteban promotes her business as offering ‘blissful staycations’, with glamping pods set among 60 acres of ancient woodland, each equipped with its own hot tub.
However, the tranquil setting has been overshadowed by a bitter neighbour dispute. The couple say the parties have been ‘shouting and harassing one another’ and blocking the shared track, leading to court proceedings.
Ms Esteban argued that the Goulds’ right to use the driveway ended directly opposite their front door. That would prevent them from reaching the parking area beside their home, just a few feet farther along the track.
The dispute escalated when Ms Esteban placed ‘boulders’ across the track north of the couple’s detached cottage, Cwmtawe Villa. The Goulds sued her in July last year and won their case at the High Court.
The judge described Ms Esteban’s interpretation as ‘absurd’ and ruled that Mr and Mrs Gould were entitled to drive far enough along the track to turn into their parking area.
Ms Esteban has refused to accept the ruling, challenging both the judgment and the £135,000 costs order issued against her at the Court of Appeal in London.
Carol Esteban, 60, runs a farm business on the edge of the Brecon Beacons National Park and became embroiled in a dispute with Neil and Nadine Gould over the shared driveway leading to their properties (pictured outside London’s Court of Appeal)
Neil and Nadine Gould’s detached cottage, Cwmtawe Villa, in Caerbont. The disputed parking space is visible to the north of the house, on the left
In his ruling last year, Judge Milwyn Jarman KC explained that the Goulds’ detached cottage near Swansea is entirely surrounded by land belonging to Cwmtawe Farm, where Ms Esteban operates her glamping business.
The properties were once owned by the same person. The house was sold separately in 1949, although the documents from that transaction have since been lost.
A conveyancing document from 1964 states that the owners of Cwmtawe Villa have an ‘easement’ allowing them to use a farm-owned track to reach their home, either on foot or in vehicles.
However, a missing letter on a map attached to the document triggered the dispute over how far the easement extends along the track.
The judge noted that the map marks the beginning of the right of way as ‘point A’, shown as a circled capital letter in black near the track’s junction with the main road. But, he added: ‘There is no point marked B’ to indicate where the route ends.
Ms Esteban and her lawyers argued that a later map established the location of point ‘B’ as directly outside the Goulds’ front door. On that interpretation, the couple would not be legally entitled to drive the few extra feet needed to reach the hardstanding they built for parking immediately north of the house.
The glampsite owner also argued that a thick hedge surrounded the villa when the right of way was created. She said it would have made no sense for the easement to extend beyond the opening in the hedge beside the front door.
But Judge Jarman rejected that argument, saying Ms Esteban’s position ‘has the potential to lead to impracticability, if not absurdity’.
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE: Bayesian Crew ‘Never Had a Chance’: They Didn’t Know It Was Doomed
‘It would mean that those entitled to use the right of way could drive a vehicle up to a point adjacent to the front door of the villa, but no further and not onto the villa. They could not park on the track for any length of time, or on the farm land.
‘Assuming a right so interpreted would allow them to turn the vehicle around rather than reverse down the track, they would then have to drive off and find somewhere else to park.
‘In my judgment, the claimants are entitled to a declaration that their vehicular right of way extends to the space at the north side of the villa, where they presently park their vehicles.’
Ms Esteban advertises ‘blissful staycations’ in glamping pods set within 60 acres of ancient woodland, with each pod featuring its own hot tub
Appealing the ruling on behalf of Ms Esteban, Daniel Bromilow argued that the High Court judge ‘did not base his decision by construing the 1949 conveyance and the conveyance plan, but simply determined what he thought the parties should have agreed to in relation to the right of way.
‘When interpreting a contract, a judge should avoid re-writing it in an attempt to assist an unwise party or to penalise an astute party,’ he said.
‘There was no evidence that the track shown on the conveyance plan extended beyond the front door of Cwmtawe and no evidence on which the judge could have concluded that the lost 1949 conveyance provided for a right of way over that extent of the adjoining land.
‘The judge was wrong to find that the right of way which exists for the benefit of Cwmtawe extended beyond the location of the small opening in the hedge at Cwmtawe leading to the front door of the house.’
He also challenged the decision to make Ms Esteban pay the couple’s legal costs. Mr Bromilow said she had ‘succeeded to a significant extent on her counterclaim’, including securing a finding that the Goulds had unlawfully installed a new water pipe on her land and successfully resisting ‘substantial elements’ of their case.
Owen Curry, representing Mr and Mrs Gould, urged the appeal judges to uphold the original decision.
He said: ‘The appeal concerns the scope and extent of express an easement, with or without vehicles, leading across Ms Esteban’s land to Mr and Mrs Gould’s house, Cwmtawe.
‘The dispute on appeal is whether the easement stops in line with the front door of Cwmtawe or whether it permits them to reach parking spaces at the side of their house, which involves travelling a few feet past the line of the front door.
‘If it does not, then the easement, despite expressly including vehicles — a fact that was in dispute at trial but not on appeal — will be of little to no practical utility, save as a footpath.
‘The construction preferred by the judge at trial gives practical and commonsense effect to what the grantor of the easement must have intended. The construction advanced by the appellant on appeal is not supported by the words of the grant or by a commonsense approach.
‘The layout of the land shows there is not, and has never been, any obvious physical feature which would stop them driving onto their parking spaces, or, indeed, stop them walking a little past their front door before turning onto their land.
‘The learned judge reached the right conclusion in this case, and the appeal should be dismissed. The construction of the easement advanced by the appellant makes no sense and ignores the plain words of the grant.’
The appeal judges are expected to issue their decision at a later date.