Lindsay Arnold Reveals Sister Rylee Arnold’s DWTS Fitness Routine

Lindsay Arnold is sharing how her younger sister, Rylee Arnold, is staying in peak condition as she prepares for the season 35 semifinals of...
HomeNewsSherlock Holmes-Inspiring Pub Drawn Into Mystery Over Lost Cash

Sherlock Holmes-Inspiring Pub Drawn Into Mystery Over Lost Cash

A historic pub linked to a Sherlock Holmes story became the setting for a real-life mystery involving unpaid bills and missing takings, a court heard.

Clive Stockton and his wife, Sue, ran the 16th-century Hill House Inn in Happisburgh, Norfolk, when they received an unexpected £21,000 utility bill after the business fell behind with its payments.

They began investigating the pub’s finances and expenditure, uncovering what prosecutor Oliver Haswell described as a series of financial “anomalies”, including repeated payments of money.

The mystery was resolved when Clive’s son, Sam Stockton, 47, was confronted. He admitted taking cash while working at the pub and managing its accounts.

He later admitted spending much of the money on gambling and cocaine, which he said he used to manage pain caused by a debilitating medical condition.

Sam, who arrived at court using a walking stick, was charged with stealing £63,572 from the pub between January 2018 and November 2020 after his parents reported the matter to police.

Sam Stockton, 47, stole cash from the pub run by his parents, Clive and Sue, in Happisburgh, Norfolk

Sam Stockton, 47, stole money from the Happisburgh pub run by his parents, Clive and Sue

The thief admitted taking up to £53,000 from 16th century Hill House Inn

The defendant admitted taking between £48,000 and £53,000 from the 16th-century Hill House Inn

He initially denied the offence when he appeared at Norwich Crown Court, but later pleaded guilty on the basis that he had taken between £48,000 and £53,000. The prosecution accepted that basis.

The diabetic defendant, who is in remission from cancer, had been warned at an earlier hearing that he was likely to receive a prison sentence. However, Recorder Nicola Fitches showed him mercy despite describing his offending as “despicably dishonest”.

She imposed a 30-month prison sentence, suspended for three years, and ordered him to complete 200 hours of unpaid work. The judge ruled that the thefts were unsophisticated and had not been carefully planned.

Sam’s wife, Jenny, 46, who lives with him in Norwich, had faced the same theft charge. The case was not proceeded with following his guilty plea, and Recorder Fitches ordered that the charge lie on file.

The Hill House Inn is associated with the Sherlock Holmes canon after Sir Arthur Conan Doyle stayed there during a motoring holiday in 1903.

While at the pub, landlord’s son Gilbert Cubitt showed Doyle a strange script he had created using drawings of pin men. The discovery inspired the author to write a story based on the drawings.

Clive Stockton died earlier this year, before he saw his son face justice

Clive Stockton died earlier this year before seeing his son brought to justice

His story, The Dancing Men, first appeared in Strand magazine before being renamed The Adventures of the Dancing Men. It featured a fictional Norfolk squire, Hilton Cubitt, who asked Holmes to investigate a series of pictures showing dancing men that had been sent to his wife.

Holmes used his renowned detective skills to establish that the images formed a secret code whose messages placed the Cubitts in grave danger.

The Grade II-listed pub has a blue plaque commemorating the connection and also inspired the name of the Dancing Men brewery, which operates from the premises.

The court heard yesterday that Sam and Jenny had been employed by his father and lived rent-free in the upstairs flat, with all bills paid, alongside their four children. Clive and Sue lived in a smaller annexe.

Mr Haswell said the pub office was located in a small room within the upstairs accommodation. It was initially used by Clive, a former chairman of North Norfolk District Council, and Sue.

However, Sam and Jenny complained that his parents’ use of the office invaded their privacy and asked them to stop using it.

The pub inspired a Sherlock Holmes tale after Sir Arthur Conan Doyle booked a room at the pub while on a motoring holiday in 1903

The pub inspired a Sherlock Holmes story after Sir Arthur Conan Doyle stayed there during a 1903 motoring holiday

The Dancing Men involved a fictional Norfolk squire called Hilton Cubitt who asked the detective to solve the mystery of a series of pictures of stick men sent to his wife.

The Dancing Men featured a fictional Norfolk squire, Hilton Cubitt, who asked Holmes to investigate drawings of stick men sent to his wife

Sam subsequently took responsibility for all the pub’s accounts, including staff payroll. He transferred the payroll from paper records to digital software to comply with new Government rules for small businesses.

Mr Haswell said Sam admitted taking the money when challenged by his father, explaining that he had used it to fund his drug and gambling habits before telling him: “So, you had better call the police.”

Jenny wrote a letter apologising to her husband’s parents and “cobbled together” £5,437 as a partial repayment, while asking them not to contact police, Mr Haswell said.

However, the prosecutor said Clive had been obliged to report the theft because the pub was partly owned by people outside the family.

Mr Haswell said Sam adopted “a rather robust stance” during his initial police interview, claiming he had been underpaid by his parents and earned only £130 a week, while “forgetting that he was provided with accommodation, including bills”.

His wife later clarified that Sam was actually paid £230 a week, while she received £130, Mr Haswell added.

The defendant's wife, Jenny, 46, had faced an identical theft charge but the case was not proceeded with as a result of his guilty plea

Sam’s wife, Jenny, 46, faced the same theft charge, but the case was not proceeded with after he pleaded guilty

The police investigation was complicated by the disappearance of much of the paperwork. Officers and Sam’s parents were also unable to access the pub’s online accounts.

The court heard that Clive Stockton had died earlier this year following a period of ill health.

In a victim impact statement, Sue said the thefts had destroyed their retirement plans and left them unable to fund essential maintenance at the pub.

Andrew Oliver, defending, said his client had worked extremely long hours, sometimes as many as 100 a week.

“There were feelings of resentment because his pay was low, albeit he also had living accommodation in the pub,” he added.

The court was told that Sam also had unresolved issues with his father over the way he had been treated as a child. He had been left in “constant pain” by a “debilitating” illness that prescribed medication had failed to treat adequately.

Mr Oliver said: “He accepts there were occasions when he was using cocaine as pain relief and he accepts that he was gambling regularly and this had become a problem.

“It was the result of the stress of working in the pub and a distraction from the pain he was experiencing.”

Sam expressed remorse and accepted that his thefts had “deeply affected” his relationship with his parents, causing them “upset and distress”.

His relationship with his father had “remained fractious” until Clive’s death, Mr Oliver added.

He continued: “This was mean-spirited offending committed against people who should have been able to trust him. He has let them down in a very big way.”

Recorder Fitches told Sam: “You stole money from others, including your own parents. This was a despicably dishonest crime which had a devastating impact on your parents and others.”