Elizabeth Jimenez still remembers her hands trembling as she dialled the number, grief weighing so heavily on her that her entire body hurt.
A voice suddenly answered. Elizabeth had never spoken to the man before, yet she knew exactly who he was. This was the person who had changed her life forever: the man who, only hours earlier, had driven her daughter Maria’s car after drinking two glasses of wine and crashed at high speed, killing the 24-year-old.
Elizabeth could have unleashed her anger, demanding answers and assigning blame. Instead, she did something few people could imagine.
‘Before I said anything, I listened to my heart,’ she says, her voice quiet but certain. ‘I heard myself say, “Nick, I want you to know that I love you”.’
Elizabeth, 56, from Guildford, understands why people struggle to comprehend her story. She knows it leaves many stunned and causes every parent who hears it to ask how, and why, a mother could say such words.
Where was the rage? The fury? The instinct to seek revenge?
Even if Elizabeth had somehow reached a place of forgiveness, declaring love for the man responsible for her daughter’s death appeared to be an impossible step further.
‘Even Fernando, Maria’s father, who was overwhelmed by grief and anger, couldn’t understand what I had done,’ Elizabeth says. ‘But those words reflected exactly how I felt. Maria was gone, but I didn’t feel anger. I felt only heartbreak and love.’
Elizabeth and Fernando Jimenez with Nick Tay, who had been in a relationship with the couple’s daughter for three months when she died
Maria was 24 when Nick took control of her car after drinking two glasses of wine and crashed at high speed
She insists she was not paralysed by shock. Elizabeth immediately viewed what had happened as a tragic accident and, in her mind, that left no place for blame.
Maria and Nick, then 25, had been together for three months. Nick later said he believed they were soulmates. Elizabeth says she could understand how devastated he must have felt.
There were further extraordinary developments. Elizabeth and Fernando did not simply forgive Nick; they eventually welcomed him into their home and treated him as a son.
Maria had always shared a close bond with her parents and her older brother, Joshua. ‘Maria was born happy,’ says Fernando, 68. ‘She was a wonderful girl and always the life of the party.’
‘She made friends everywhere she went,’ Elizabeth adds. ‘Making people happy made her happy.’
Maria had confided in Elizabeth since she was a teenager. ‘She knew her own mind and made her own choices. But she also knew that, as her mother, I would stand by her whatever happened.’
A gifted student who spoke Spanish and Korean, Maria began studying linguistics at Brighton University in 2014. She was only months away from graduating when she died.
‘Fernando and I were incredibly proud of her. When she told us about her plans after graduation in early 2017, we were thrilled. She had applied to teach in Korea, and it was obvious how excited she was,’ Elizabeth recalls.
It was in March that year that Elizabeth and Fernando, both Evangelical Christians, first heard Nick Tay’s name. ‘Maria told me he had come from Singapore to study at the University of Surrey,’ says Elizabeth. ‘They met through her music group in Guildford, and he also attended our church.
‘One day, while we were at church in Guildford, Maria pointed across the crowded room to a smart, quiet young man. It was Nick. She said he had recently gone through a breakup, as she had, and that they were supporting each other.’
Maria’s parents did not speak to Nick that day, but his name soon began appearing in her regular phone conversations with Elizabeth. ‘From the way Maria described him as kind, thoughtful and lovely, I could tell she liked him. I could also tell that he was a good person.
‘One evening, Maria was getting ready to go out with friends, including members of the music group Nick belonged to. I put her on speaker so Fernando and I could both say goodnight. “Have fun,” I told her, and we ended the call by saying, “I love you”.’
Elizabeth pauses before continuing. ‘I had no idea it would be the last time we ever spoke.’
At 6am the following morning, March 22, 2017, police arrived at the family home. ‘I had always considered myself strong,’ says Fernando. ‘But when the officer said there had been a car accident and Maria had died, I collapsed and cried. I couldn’t take in what I was hearing. I couldn’t accept that my beautiful daughter was gone.’
The family knew very little. Fernando was told only that Maria had died in a ‘one-car accident’ in the early hours and that her boyfriend, whose name had not yet been disclosed, had been driving.
Elizabeth remembers leaving the bathroom and seeing the shock on Fernando’s face. ‘When he said, “I have to tell you something”, a cold fear swept over me. Then he told me to sit down and began to cry. I knew something terrible had happened.’
Fernando knelt at Elizabeth’s feet and held her hands. ‘It was difficult to understand what he was saying. Then, with horror, I realised what he was trying to tell me.’
Elizabeth describes the grief as an almost physical blow. ‘Time appeared to stop as we cried in each other’s arms, while Joshua learned that his sister was dead. When I heard the police had mentioned a boyfriend, Nick was the first person I thought of.’
The couple spent hours at the hospital waiting to be allowed to see Maria’s body. ‘Friends began arriving, including the pastor of our church and Nick’s. He was the one who told us Nick had been driving, had been arrested and was being held at the police station.’
That was when an unexpected thought entered Elizabeth’s mind. ‘I suddenly thought, “Nick is completely alone. I’m here with all these people and with Maria, but he has nobody. His parents are in Singapore. He must be terrified”.
‘I didn’t feel any desire for revenge. I didn’t want to find Nick so I could scream at him or punish him for what had happened. I simply needed to know that he was all right.’
At that stage, Elizabeth and Fernando knew only that Nick had caused the crash. While others might have focused on his reckless actions, Elizabeth saw the death as a devastating tragedy. ‘Nick caused the accident, but to me it was still an accident. I realise that may be difficult for people to understand, but that is how I have always seen it.’
Eventually, the couple were taken to Maria. ‘We were allowed to see her only through a window,’ says Elizabeth. ‘It felt like a waking nightmare.’
Fernando says: ‘In my grief, I blamed myself for buying Maria the car the previous year. It was the car she died in. But I also blamed Nick. I was consumed by anger and thoughts of revenge. I wanted him dead.’
The couple did not discuss their very different reactions. ‘We didn’t consciously decide to keep our feelings from each other,’ Elizabeth says. ‘I wasn’t thinking clearly enough for that. We were so deep in grief that we simply didn’t talk about what we felt towards Nick.’
That night, after returning home and learning that Nick had been released from custody and was staying with their pastor, Elizabeth called him.
ALSO READ: Florida DMV Worker Faces 360 Felonies in License Test Scheme
‘I hadn’t prepared anything to say. Everything was a blur. The only part I remember clearly is saying, “I love you”. I needed him to hear those words.
‘Nick cried and cried. When I knew he understood how I felt, it was as though a weight had lifted from my heart.’
Over the following days, the family discovered that Nick had been drinking before driving Maria’s car. Maria, who rarely drank, had consumed more alcohol than Nick and asked him to drive. He agreed, despite not having car insurance.
The car reached 110mph in a 50mph zone before crossing two lanes of a dual carriageway and striking the central reservation. It overturned, throwing Maria from the vehicle and killing her. Nick was not injured.
Police breathalysed Nick at the scene, but he was below the legal limit.
The new details did not alter Elizabeth’s feelings of love or forgiveness. Fernando, however, continued to struggle with his anger and his urge to seek revenge.
‘I understood his pain,’ Elizabeth says. ‘Maria was gone, and her absence was an unbearable, constant pain for me too. But I couldn’t accept the idea that Nick would become another victim of this senseless tragedy.’
Two days after Maria’s death, Elizabeth asked Fernando whether she could invite Nick to see them. Recognising how important the meeting was to her, Fernando agreed.
She remembers the silence that filled the living room when Nick entered. ‘He looked so frightened that my heart broke for him,’ she says. Holding her breath and unsure how Fernando would react, she heard Nick say, ‘Please forgive me.’
‘Responding to Maria’s death with love rather than hate has helped us both enormously,’ Elizabeth says. Pictured: Maria
‘I genuinely didn’t know how I would feel when I saw him,’ Fernando recalls. ‘I didn’t know whether I could face him. But when I opened my arms and embraced him, we both fell to the floor crying. I felt a wave of compassion and said, “I forgive you, son” — and I meant it.
‘That was when I understood that bitterness, anger and the desire for revenge would eventually destroy me.’
Joshua was able to accept his parents’ decision, although the couple knew that many people would find their response difficult to understand.
‘Our forgiveness of Nick, the daily conversations we had with him and our determination that he should not go to prison seemed very strange to many people,’ says Elizabeth. ‘None of our friends or relatives confronted us, even when Nick attended Maria’s funeral in the months that followed. But some family members became distant. I believe they simply couldn’t understand our relationship with him.’
Elizabeth immersed herself in Nick’s defence, attending police interviews and court hearings. She wanted to understand every detail and repeatedly asked for the prosecution to be abandoned.
‘At every meeting, it was clear that the police thought I was mad to defend Nick,’ she says. ‘But Maria was dead, and sending Nick to prison could not change that. Punishing him would not make anything better; it only added to my suffering.’
While Elizabeth devoted herself to helping Nick, Fernando kept his distance from the case.
‘I supported Elizabeth and could see that fighting for Nick helped her, but I couldn’t face learning all the details of Maria’s death. My precious daughter was gone. I needed to keep my memories of her as vivid as possible rather than constantly revisiting the day she died.’
Elizabeth acknowledges that helping Nick also gave her a way to avoid confronting the full weight of her grief. ‘The legal process and caring for Nick filled every hour. I didn’t have time to grieve, and that definitely helped me cope.’
Although Elizabeth was the one who worked on Nick’s defence, she and Fernando agreed on their next extraordinary step: four months after Maria’s death, they invited Nick to live with them. Before the crash, he had been living in university accommodation.
‘Despite everything I did, the prosecution continued, and Nick’s entire family was still in Singapore,’ Elizabeth says. ‘Other members of the church offered him a place to stay, but he chose us. In the days after the crash, he had wanted to take his own life, so we made sure he was never left alone.
‘Having him in our home for those six weeks helped me enormously. It healed something in me to see him cooking with Fernando. I realised how alike they were and understood what Maria had seen in him.’
Elizabeth stresses that, although the couple gave Nick food and somewhere to live, he did not depend on them financially.
By then, Elizabeth had begun to fill the role of a mother figure in Nick’s life. But how did Fernando feel?
‘Spending time with him helped me heal as well,’ he says. ‘The moment he asked me to forgive him, he became my son. My anger never returned.’
‘We believe that when an apology is genuine and sincere, nothing more is required,’ Elizabeth says. ‘Even so, whenever we spoke about Maria and the accident, we hugged, cried and Nick apologised again.’
At his trial in November 2017, Nick pleaded guilty to causing death by dangerous driving and causing death by driving an uninsured vehicle.
‘I wasn’t permitted to speak, but I had written a letter to the judge asking for leniency,’ Elizabeth says. ‘When Nick received a five-year sentence, I was devastated. I collapsed in court as he was taken away. I felt certain that this was not what Maria would have wanted.’
The couple visited Nick in prison every week. ‘Each time, we told him that we loved him and forgave him,’ says Fernando. ‘I wanted to support him and ensure he did not sink into depression and despair.’
Nick was released in September 2019 after serving almost two years, and was immediately deported to Singapore.
‘It was extremely difficult not to see him before he left,’ Elizabeth says. ‘Then the pandemic began, so I couldn’t travel to Singapore. I missed him terribly.’
They continued speaking every day. Elizabeth was delighted when Nick met his future wife, married and had three children. The couple now regularly travel to Singapore to visit them.
‘Our relationship has grown stronger with every year,’ Elizabeth says. ‘We still speak daily. Nick calls us Papi and Mum, and he is more like a son to us than ever. I’m so happy about the life he has built.’
Today, Elizabeth and Fernando have no doubt that they chose the right path.
‘Answering Maria’s death with love instead of hate has helped both of us enormously,’ Elizabeth says. ‘Forgiveness is not always easy, but I believe Maria can see me and is proud of what I have done.’
MORE ON THIS: Who Is Naresh Bhatt? Nurse Mamta Kafle Bhatt Murder Trial