HomeUSNYC Inspectors Missed Major Cracks Years Before Brooklyn Collapse

NYC Inspectors Missed Major Cracks Years Before Brooklyn Collapse

New York City building inspectors allegedly ignored large cracks spreading across the façade of a Brooklyn tenement for more than a decade, including during on-site inspections, before the structure partially collapsed and killed eight people, The Post has learned.

Google Earth images reviewed by The Post show damage on the brick façade of the Flatbush Avenue building as early as 2011. The deterioration became increasingly widespread over the years.

Despite the visible damage, there is no public record showing that the NYC Department of Buildings issued fines or warnings—or even documented the façade’s deteriorating condition.

Instead, the agency issued a series of summonses over an illegally displayed sign that read, “This Could Be Your Ad.”

After a May 2019 inspection, DOB inspectors issued 13 summonses to notorious slumlord Olufemi Falade for improperly displaying the sign along the north side of 1321 Flatbush Ave. That was the same section of the building that collapsed Nov. 11 beside an excavation site, according to agency records.

Nine of the 13 summonses remain unpaid, leaving Falade responsible for $170,000 in fines, records show. 

Councilwoman Joann Ariola (R-Queens) called it a disgrace that city inspectors had apparently “overlooked” the building’s obvious structural deterioration for years.

“The DOB saw these cracks years ago and did nothing about it, yet City Hall keeps telling us to trust the agencies and accept less oversight,” she said.

“Now we have a tragedy. These agencies don’t care about public safety; they care about easy summonses and pushing political agendas, and there needs to be more accountability across the board.”

Several real estate experts said the building’s condition may have been missed amid bureaucratic failures and staffing shortages at the DOB, which is already stretched thin by the volume of development projects across New York City.

“They certainly could have [flagged it], but the DOB inspectors are spread thin and only look at the subject of the complaint before moving on,” said a city-based real estate lawyer.

Still, the lawyer added, “the owner of the building that collapsed should have taken action to deal with the crack—it’s clear negligence.”

An engineer based in New York City who asked not to be identified said cracks are common in buildings, but construction activity should prompt closer scrutiny.

“Many buildings have cracks, and nothing comes of them, but if construction work is being done they should be flagged and monitored,” the engineer said.

Over the past year, the DOB also failed to act on troubling reports from private firms that warned of possible structural problems at the building.

A geotechnical report prepared in November 2025 for a project to demolish a one-story building at 2625 Bedford Avenue and replace it with a three-story mixed-use structure warned that cracks found on nearby buildings—including 1321 Flatbush Ave.—should be monitored with gauges during the pre-construction survey to determine whether they were widening.

Crack-monitoring gauges are instruments commonly used during construction to detect slight movement or deformation in buildings, retaining walls and soil. The measurements can help engineers identify instability and intervene before a collapse.

The report was prepared by Queens-based International Geotechnical/Structural Lab Inc. and filed with the DOB.

In March, Brooklyn-based Quiver League issued a separate pre-construction inspection report, also filed with the DOB, that warned Yossi Kopfstein, executive vice president of construction contractor Promont NYC, about potential hazards.

The report said the Flatbush Avenue building’s “north façade” was “in poor condition with noticeable cracks,” making it necessary to monitor the wall during demolition and other construction work at the neighboring site.

The DOB declined to explain why its inspectors failed to cite the structural damage before the collapse or take enforcement action to have it repaired. The agency also did not answer questions about whether gauges had been installed to track additional movement during the excavation next door.

Instead, DOB Commissioner Ahmed Tigani, who was appointed by Mayor Zohran Mamdani in January, said in a statement that the collapse remains under investigation. The agency, he said, “is doing everything we can to understand exactly how this collapse occurred, so that the responsible parties can be held to account.”

Kopfstein, Falade and Robert Fischman, the owner of the Bedford Avenue property, did not respond to requests for comment.

Two weeks after Quiver League issued its report, the DOB ordered work halted and imposed a $2,500 fine for failing to provide adequate overhead protection for neighboring properties.

In April, a DOB inspector found that N Tech Design, the company Fischman hired to handle the demolition, had continued working despite the stop-work order. The firm was fined $10,000.

However, once N Tech paid the fine, the DOB approved the resumption of construction without addressing the apparent foundation problems at the neighboring building.