Home Blog Page 621

Judge Rejects Trump’s Bid to Shift Manhattan Criminal Case to Federal Court as Insufficient

0

In a moment of high significance, President Donald Trump was photographed speaking just outside the Oval Office at the White House on Monday, April 13, 2026, as documented by AP Photo/Alex Brandon.

In a recent development from the Manhattan courts, a federal judge has dismissed former President Donald Trump’s plea to move his longstanding criminal case, arising from activities in New York City, to federal jurisdiction.

“The defendant, Donald J. Trump, has cited grounds for a second removal that are neither novel nor legally adequate,” stated a comprehensive 35-page ruling released on Friday. “He has not demonstrated cause or substantial diligence, leading to the denial of his request to file another notice of removal.”

Despite being convicted of 34 separate felonies, Trump has consistently faced setbacks in his attempts to elevate his local court proceedings to a federal level.

The legal proceedings, overseen by U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein, who was appointed by Bill Clinton, initiated with a notice of removal in May 2023.

After fast and fierce motions practice, the court ruled against Trump in July 2023 and sent the case back to the New York Supreme Court in New York County, the formal name for the trial court in Manhattan.

Appeals went nowhere. In May 2024, the 45th president was convicted. In late August 2024, he filed a second removal notice. Roughly two months later, Trump beat Kamala Harris in the 2024 presidential election and later assumed office as the 47th president.

The prospect of Trump’s sentencing hung in the air while the removal attempt continued, only to be decided in the then-president-elect’s favor in the form of an “unconditional discharge” issued by New York Supreme Court Judge Juan Merchan. Trump’s hush-money case over funds paid to Stormy Daniels ahead of the 2020 election ended without any adverse legal consequences for the defendant, but with his conviction for falsifying business records still on the books.

Between the election and sentencing decision, the district court denied the removal notice again — and denied a motion to stay the ruling. The case then went up the appellate ladder and came before the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in June 2025.

In November 2025, the appellate court sent the case back to the district court to reconsider the president’s motion in light of the U.S. Supreme Court’s landmark opinion on presidential immunity.

Now, Hellerstein has considered months’ worth of motions and hearings — and is still resolutely not convinced.

“President Trump must show that ‘he acted diligently and without undue delay to remove the case based on’ new grounds, here, principally the issuance of the United States Supreme Court’s decision in Trump v. United States, in order to ‘show good cause for the untimely filing at issue,'” the court’s order reads. “He fails to do so.”

The judge recites the timelines of the various cases, noting that Trump “made a strategic decision” to use presidential immunity claims as a defense in his criminal trial instead of as a removal basis during the trial. Then, Trump used immunity claims as a basis to dismiss after the trial — again not as a basis for removal.

“Finally, 64 days later, and when it became apparent that the New York court likely intended to deny his motion to dismiss and sentence him two days after, Trump filed his motion in federal court,” the judge explains.

But by then it was too late for such a removal claim, the judge found.

“A party seeking to remove must do so promptly no later than 30 days after arraignment or any time before trial, whichever is earlier,” the order continues. “If he misses this window, he can seek leave to remove despite his lateness by showing ‘good cause.’ But he cannot play one court against another; he cannot seek victory in one court, and then, when it becomes apparent that the court will rule against him, seek to remove his case to another court.”

Hellerstein cites precedent to note that the removal statute does not mean “a party may experiment” in state court and then “transfer it to the federal court” if the experiment fails.

But that is admittedly what Trump and his legal team did here.

“At oral argument before the Court of Appeals, Trump’s counsel acknowledged ‘he could have sought removal immediately following the Supreme Court’s decision,'” the order goes on. “He instead elected to litigate immunity in state court.”

The judge notes “Trump himself recognizes” the second removal bid only came after it was clear immunity would fail in Empire State court.

“Trump seeks a ‘second bite at the apple,’ a result the law disfavors,” Hellerstein continues. “Trump’s delay in filing for removal constitutes a ‘quintessential strategic decision,’ and the ‘fact that he later came to view that decision as a poor one is not sufficient.”

The judge also said the lengthy gulf before filing was “inconsistent with good cause” in and of itself.

“The U.S. Supreme Court issued its decision July 1, 2024,” Hellerstein went on. “It took 64 more days for Trump to move in this court for leave to remove on September 3, 2024. I hold that President Trump failed to show good cause.”

The post Judge says Trump’s effort to move Manhattan criminal case to federal court is ‘neither new nor legally sufficient’ first appeared on Law & Crime.

Russian Strike on Kyiv Region Leaves 27+ Dead: Latest Update

0

Officials have confirmed that a Russian assault on the Bucha district, situated near Ukraine’s capital, Kyiv, has resulted in the tragic loss of at least 27 lives as of Saturday.

Tymur Tkachenko, who leads the local regional military administration, reported that the attack caused damage to at least 50 residential buildings. The assault also ignited a massive fire that extended to residences and a nearby restaurant.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky released a statement indicating that a warehouse in the village of Myla was hit, triggering an explosion.

While he provided no further specifics about the location, Zelensky mentioned that legal action had been initiated on grounds of official negligence.

Zelensky emphasized existing regulations, stating, “Ammunition cannot be stored near homes or other residential areas.”

The Ukrainian leader wrote that a care home for elderly people and people with disabilities and residential buildings were damaged.

“More than 370 people have already been evacuated, and the evacuation is ongoing,” he said.

Almost constant air raids in Kyiv have now reached their third day, choking the economy in the Ukrainian capital and severely disrupting civilian life more than four and a half years after Russia’s full-scale invasion of its neighbor.

Surviving Nepal’s Devastating Flash Floods: A Closer Look

0

Along the tumultuous path to Kathmandu, where disorder reigns as far as the eye can survey, travelers cling to hope amidst growing dread of an unfolding calamity.

Amidst the gridlocked traffic, droves of weary pedestrians press northward, seeking family members who remain unreachable since a catastrophic flash flood descended from the Himalayas on Wednesday morning.

As entire structures, bridges, and neighborhoods seem to have vanished, and with the grim death toll escalating hourly, an eerie silence conveys the heavy realization that, in the wake of such a monumental disaster, no updates often spell the worst possible news.

In the relentless downpour, I encountered Prem Bahdur Tamang, trudging with despair, clutching a mobile phone showcasing a photo of his nephew, Sangyam Rumba, smiling with arms folded—a poignant image trapped behind the phone’s cracked screen.

He moved from one person to another, displaying the cherished photo and asking if they had laid eyes on his young relative. Each time, he braced himself for the answer he dreaded most.

‘We haven’t seen him since the water came,’ Prem told me, referring to the destructive wave of mud and debris which seemed to destroy everything in its wake. ‘His parents have been crying and haven’t eaten for almost three days because they know that the outcome is not going to be good.’ 

Workers use excavators to clear the mud at the Dhunge Bazaar in Nepal's Nuwakot district after flash floods and landslides hit

Workers use excavators to clear the mud at the Dhunge Bazaar in Nepal’s Nuwakot district after flash floods and landslides hit

Kanchi & Mili spoke with Vivek and are heartbroken with what has happened and hope the missing people are found

Kanchi & Mili spoke with Vivek and are heartbroken with what has happened and hope the missing people are found

Prem Bahdur Tamamg told Vivek how his family is struggling

Prem Bahdur Tamamg told Vivek how his family is struggling

The catastrophic floods that struck Nepal and Tibet are reported to have surged as high as 650ft, killing at least 538 people and leaving more than 1,500 missing

The catastrophic floods that struck Nepal and Tibet are reported to have surged as high as 650ft, killing at least 538 people and leaving more than 1,500 missing

People stand near a collapsed bridge after flash floods at Devighat in Nepal's Nuwakot district on August 28

People stand near a collapsed bridge after flash floods at Devighat in Nepal’s Nuwakot district on August 28

A drone view of a broken bridge and damaged houses after the flash floods and mudslide, at Devighat, Nuwakot district, Nepal

A drone view of a broken bridge and damaged houses after the flash floods and mudslide, at Devighat, Nuwakot district, Nepal

A man walks past damaged structures after flash flooding in the Devighat area of Nuwakot district in Nepal

A man walks past damaged structures after flash flooding in the Devighat area of Nuwakot district in Nepal

An aerial view of destroyed houses and roads covered in muds along the Trishuli River

An aerial view of destroyed houses and roads covered in muds along the Trishuli River

Staring at his phone as his eyes filled with tears, Prem revealed that Sangyam worked as a tour guide, accompanying the hundreds of thousands of visitors who come to Nepal each year, largely to trek through the spectacular mountain range where an avalanche triggered this week’s tragedy.

The young man was last in contact with his family on Wednesday morning just minutes before the flood hit. He was walking up the Trishuli River with a group of foreign tourists.

‘How can anyone survive that flood? It came crashing down like a giant monster that ate up everything,’ said Prem. ‘The whole of Nepal is heartbroken by what happened. In our hearts we fear that Sangyam is gone.’

Similar emotions are being shared everywhere on the Nuwakot road, one of the principal routes from Kathmandu to the Tibet border, which winds its way north of the city through lush mountains before heading past the aforementioned Trishuli, which bore the brunt of the flash flood as water came cascading down from the Chinese border.

The two-lane highway, which in normal times is heavily potholed, is now covered with a thick layer of sticky mud, which gets almost everywhere: into your clothes, your hair, and even your eyes.

The further one gets from Nepal’s capital city, the worse the destruction becomes. In some parts the road becomes virtually impassable due to fallen trees and rubble.

As I approached the Trishuli valley, the crowds looked increasingly shell-shocked. People stood around talking about their missing loved ones or their missing homes.

Those who are among the tens of thousands who have lost homes took refuge wherever they could, as they attempted to come to terms with the natural disaster that has had such a devastating impact on their lives.

Trucks carrying goods could be seen turning back as the road entered the valley, which is effectively ground zero of this terrible natural disaster – the true scope of which has yet to be fully realised.

At the edge of a mountain road I met three young girls who were staying in a tin hut while their parents sheltered from the monsoon season rains in another makeshift shelter nearby.

Some of their clothes were hanging over the side of the squalid hut. Despite losing their home, the youngsters giggled and smiled as they playfully attempted to pass the time away.

Shanti, their mother, said: ‘We have lost everything, but we are lucky that we didn’t lose our lives. We have moved higher up because we are too scared to be by the river. Who knows, there might be another flood? We have relatives in this area, and they have been helping us.

‘There is not much we can do. At least we are all together and nobody in the family is missing.’

Many whose houses remain intact have moved to higher ground amid fears of a second wave, which has restricted rescue operations in the area.

Thanks to the generosity of strangers, many are taking shelter in shabby concrete houses which border the Nuwakot road, which has no pavement and is lined with shacks selling an assortment of goods, along with tea stalls.

The area is made up of a mixture of Hindu and Buddhist temples, reflecting the two religions that are most practised in Nepal. Women dressed in traditional Nepali robes, known as bakhus, and colourful salwar kameezes walked along the roadside, carefully negotiating flood debris as the monsoon rain continues.

The ravaged state of the road is for now frustrating rescue efforts, with only helicopters able to access some of the more remote towns towards the northern end of the valley, which bore the brunt of the storm.

Choppers from the Nepali army whirled overhead through an overcast sky as they made their way towards the Tibet border, only 30 miles away, to help with the search for the missing. But it is proving to be increasingly difficult with the weather worsening and fears of a second flood.

The Red Cross has also managed to get some relief workers to affected towns and villages. But it will clearly be some time until aid agencies are able to mount a serious relief effort.

In the meantime, ordinary Nepalis have come together in this time of crisis.

On the Nuwakot road, tea shops are offering free drinks and snacks; one elderly man was walking around lending his umbrella to those who have lost their homes and now find themselves exposed to the elements; while Kanchi and Milli, two women who sell vegetables at a roadside stall were giving them away for free to flood victims.

Kanchi said: ‘These are our people, and we have to do all that we can to help them.

‘I know that the government is doing its best, but we also have a duty to look after our brothers and sisters.’

She revealed they are lucky to make £2 per day at the stall, but given what has happened, ‘money is not important’.

She added: ‘We are not rich but none of that matters because we all have to come together. It’s hard for us to make sense of this. Nepalis are very devout people, our temples are full every day. We don’t understand why God would do this to us?’

In the distance, a temple bell could be heard to mark the Hindu festival of Raksha Bandhan – one of the most important in Nepal. It was a national holiday to mark the religious occasion so people could catch up with their extended families. But for many of those in Nuwakot and other flood-hit areas, there is little to celebrate.

Raja Ram explained the significance of the ancient festival. Fighting back the tears he said: ‘It celebrates the bond between a brother and sister and is very important in our culture. I’m lucky that I live high up on a hill in Nuwakot but so many people down by the river have lost a brother or sister that I’ve decided not to celebrate. It just doesn’t seem right.’

As locals sipped tea and discussed Wednesday’s events, some looked up with a solemn, almost hopeless, look in their eyes.

Badal, a teacher whose name means cloud in Nepali, said: ‘The Nepal-Tibet border is not very far from here but it’s one of the remotest regions in the world. I don’t understand how they’ll find anyone.

‘Since Wednesday, the wifi keeps cutting out and at times communication is almost impossible. The phone signal is also very bad. Even if somebody is alive, how will anyone find out?’

As the rain showed no sign of relenting, Prem Bahdur Tamang continued along the principal road that winds through Nuwakot, pausing at shops that are little more than shacks to show people the picture of his beloved nephew.

Calling out his name and details of where he was last seen, he said: ‘One part of me has given up hope and another part doesn’t want to do that. I suppose it’s not different to what the rest of the country is going through.’

Big Bend Border Construction Halt Increases Hope for Wildlife and Conservation Efforts

0

WASHINGTON — Amid the ongoing legal challenge concerning contentious border infrastructure, the federal government announced in court on Friday its decision to extend the suspension of construction activities within Big Bend National Park until mid-September. This development has been warmly received by opponents of the project, who have been vocal since the plans were unveiled.

Recently, Customs and Border Protection had temporarily halted these activities following a visit to the park by CBP Commissioner Rodney Scott. During his visit, he engaged in discussions with local officials, following eruptions of public protest when bulldozers began making their mark on the park’s southern Texas terrain.

At the time, the Department of Homeland Security clarified that the machinery was not initiating full-scale construction but instead conducting preliminary design and survey tasks. This interruption, initially instated by Scott, was expected to lapse this coming Monday.

The proposed plans within Big Bend National Park include the creation of a new road, implementation of advanced detection technology, and the erection of vehicle-stopping barriers at the border. However, government representatives stress that definitive blueprints for the park project remain undecided.

On Friday, U.S. District Judge Orlando L. Garcia expressed his intention for both parties to leverage the additional time to collaboratively address their respective issues. The pause encompasses efforts across both the national park and an adjacent area located upriver and westward of the park, as confirmed by a Justice Department attorney during the hearing.

The work in Big Bend National Park is part of a $46 billion plan by the Trump administration to cover the length of the 2,000-mile border from the Pacific Ocean to the Gulf of Mexico in a combination of 30-foot-tall steel bollard walls, vehicle barriers and detection technology to stop illegal immigration and smugglers.

As construction has ramped into high gear, the administration has

Michelle Obama Reveals Relief as Daughters Move Out: Here’s Why She’s Embracing the Empty Nest

0

Former First Lady Michelle Obama sparked controversy on Friday after commenting on Jon Stewart’s “IMO” podcast. She mentioned she does not miss the presence of her adult daughters at home, a statement that has drawn both attention and criticism.

California Republican Party Delegate and mother Elizabeth Barcohana shared her perspective with Fox News Digital, suggesting Obama’s comments carried undertones of resentment amid the ongoing national conversation about motherhood.

During the podcast, Obama responded in a straightforward manner when Stewart reflected on the role parenting plays in adding purpose and structure to life. He then queried if she missed that aspect of parenting.

“I’m good,” was Obama’s succinct reply.

Barcohana interpreted Obama’s words as a sign of relief now that the demanding phase of raising her daughters, Malia and Sasha, has concluded.

“There is a difference between a mother expressing exhaustion from the demands of motherhood — which is real and relatable — and expressing resentment,” Barcohana said. “Resentment is what appears to come through in Michelle Obama’s remarks, and it is especially painful to hear amid the national conversation surrounding the Lindsay Clancy trial.

“She seems happy that her daughters’ childhoods are over. That is not a relatable feeling for most mothers at all.”

Obama said she did not miss having her daughters at home but immediately stressed that she loved them and planned to see them for dinner that night.

“I don’t miss them. I don’t. I love them. I’m going to see them tonight for dinner. I love them,” she said. “But Barack cried when they went to college. I was like, ‘Bye, little — goodbye.’ Now I … now Friday nights aren’t wrecked with terror and fear about, ‘Where are you? Where are you?’”

Conservative commentator Matt Walsh accused Obama of appearing eager for her children to leave despite the assistance he claimed the family’s wealth afforded her.

“And yet she still couldn’t wait for the kids to leave because the minor demands they made on her time and energy were still too much for her. Just a total raging narcissist,” Walsh said.

Political commentator Link Lauren criticized Obama for what he characterized as repeated complaints about her family and lifestyle.

“This podcast is just her sitting around her mansion in Martha’s Vineyard complaining about how hard her life of luxury is and how much she despises her husband and children,” Lauren said.

Obama further explained her empty nest reaction by saying she welcomed her daughters’ independence and had already spent substantial time actively raising them.

“I love my schedule. I have a great schedule, and it’s all mine,” Obama said. “I mean, I’ve had so much quality time with my children. So much. Yeah, yeah. I know them inside and out.”

Obama also praised Barack Obama’s parenting last year, explaining that both parents deliberately prioritized their daughters throughout his presidency.

“It was important for both of us, for me and Barack, to carve out that time in those eight years when our girls were in their formative years, you know,” Obama said.

Brooke Hogan Addresses Comments on Her Relationship with Brother Nick Hogan

When it comes to family ties, Brooke Hogan and her brother Nick Hogan seem to be on different pages about how they perceive their relationship after the passing of their iconic father, Hulk Hogan, last year.

Nick, who is 36, shared his perspective in a recent chat with TV Insider that was released on Friday, August 28. Shortly after, Brooke, who is 38, felt compelled to offer her own viewpoint.

“I’ve deliberately chosen to keep the particulars of my relationship with Nick out of the public eye,” Brooke revealed exclusively to Us on the same Friday. “I would appreciate it if he could extend the same respect. We aren’t talking, and how he describes our relationship doesn’t align with how I see it.”

Brooke further noted, “My wish for privacy shouldn’t be seen as agreement with his statements.”

GettyImages-71762579 Nick Hogan Reveals Where He Stands With Sister Brooke After Her Estrangement from Late Dad Hulk Hogan

Meanwhile, Nick has been opening up about the status of his bond with Brooke since Hulk Hogan’s death. He expressed his admiration for her, saying, “I’m immensely proud of Brooke. I’m excited about everything she’s achieving,” during his recent interview with TV Insider.

In the interview, Nick heaped praise on his sibling, telling the outlet, “I’m so proud of Brooke. I’m so excited for everything she has got going on.”

He continued, “She’s just a phenomenal interior decorator. She has got this business that she started and she just did a new TV show, Rock the Block, and she was fantastic on that.”

Nick claimed that he is “excited” for Brooke and the positive things she has going on in her life.

“This is just a really exciting time for her. She had twins. She got married,” Nick said. “We’re just really excited for everything that’s going on for her. I’m so proud of her and, you know, everybody’s doing really well. My mom [Linda Hogan] is doing great right now. My entire family has been so supportive of everything that we’re doing. So, we’re in a really good place.”

GettyImages-72705062Brooke-Hogan-Reacts-to-Brother-Nicks-Comments-on-Their-Relationship-Status.jpg


Linda, Nick, Brooke and Hulk Hogan.
(Photo by Frank Micelotta/Getty Images)

The siblings’ father Hulk died in July 2025 of acute myocardial infarction, commonly known as a heart attack, with leukemia CLL, a type of cancer that affects white blood cells, as an underlying contributor. He was 71.

Prior to his death, Brooke was estranged from her father for several years. She told Us in April that the severed connection with her dad had also impacted her relationship with her brother.

Brooke Hogan Emotionally Reveals Where She Stands With Mom Linda Brother Nick

Brooke Hogan reflected on the difficult, fraught end of her father Hulk Hogan’s life — and emotionally discussed where things stand now with her mother, Linda, and brother, Nick. In an exclusive interview with Us Weekly, Brooke, 37 — who acknowledged she “didn’t speak” to her father for “two years” before he died in July […]

“The saddest thing about broken families is the siblings,” Brooke told Us at the time. “The siblings suffer the most because you’re always forced to take a side. Nick and I, even though we had the same parents, we had two very different upbringings and two very different experiences. That is one thing my parents always said: ‘You guys are siblings, you always have to have each other’s back.’ No matter what trouble my brother gets into, no matter what he does or who he is, that’s my brother.”

She added, “Even if we don’t talk — because I haven’t felt supported by him in times where I really needed to feel that, sometimes I feel like he saw the same things I did and wouldn’t be a united front, that’s the thing that hurts me the most — but my brother is a very kind person. He’s very smart. He loves animals. There’s just so many great things about him and so many things that I love.”

Exclusive: Discover the New Owner of Lindsay Clancy’s Former Home

0

A year after the tragic deaths of Lindsay Clancy’s three children, strangled with exercise bands in their basement, a former Massachusetts prosecutor has moved into the family’s former home.

Michael Phippen, who previously worked as an assistant district attorney in Plymouth County between 2016 and 2018, is now the owner of the property located at 47 Summer Street, Duxbury, according to recent property records.

Phippen acquired the house for $675,000 in January 2024, a year after Patrick Clancy faced the devastating scene of finding his spouse severely injured and their children dead.

Lindsay Clancy, aged 36, faces charges for the deliberate killing of her children—Cora, five, Dawson, three, and Callan, a mere eight months old—in January 2023.

Following the heartbreaking incident, she attempted suicide by cutting her wrists and neck and jumping from the second story, resulting in paralysis from the waist down.

In an October 2024 interview with The New Yorker, Patrick Clancy said the home he had shared with Lindsay was sold earlier that year but did not name the buyer. 

‘There’s no house anymore,’ he said. ‘There are no kids. All that’s left is me and Lindsay.’

Grisly evidence photos of the blue-painted, two-story home and the scene inside featured heavily in Lindsay Clancy’s grueling five-week trial, which is now nearing its end with 12 jurors deliberating her fate.

A former Massachusetts prosecutor moved into Lindsay Clancy's family home after her three children were strangled to death with exercise bands in the basement

A former Massachusetts prosecutor moved into Lindsay Clancy’s family home after her three children were strangled to death with exercise bands in the basement

Michael Phippen, who served as a Plymouth County assistant district attorney from 2016 to 2018, now owns the former Clancy home at 47 Summer Street in Duxbury

Michael Phippen, who served as a Plymouth County assistant district attorney from 2016 to 2018, now owns the former Clancy home at 47 Summer Street in Duxbury

Phippen bought the home for $675,000 in January 2024, one year after Patrick Clancy returned to find his wife injured and their three children dead

Phippen bought the home for $675,000 in January 2024, one year after Patrick Clancy returned to find his wife injured and their three children dead

In an October 2024 interview with The New Yorker, Patrick Clancy said the home he had shared with Lindsay was sold earlier that year but did not name the buyer

In an October 2024 interview with The New Yorker, Patrick Clancy said the home he had shared with Lindsay was sold earlier that year but did not name the buyer

The nationally watched case has sparked social media attention around Phippen, with followers and true-crime fanatics pointing to his former position as a DA in the same county where Clancy’s children were killed.

Speculation immediately swirled that he purchased the home while the district attorney’s office was involved in the case, though he had left the office years earlier, in 2018. 

He now heads the criminal defense department at Stark and Lattuca, a New York and Massachusetts law firm, while also running his own criminal defense practice. 

The three-bedroom, two-bathroom home, built in 1972 with a basement and garage, quietly changed hands without ever being publicly listed, according to real estate records. 

Phippen snapped up the property off-market for less than its estimated $778,400 value, according to Zillow. 

It was a bargain for the former prosecutor, who bought the home at an unusually low price in Duxbury’s tight housing market, where the average home value is $1,131,969 and the median list price $1,278,333, Newsweek reports.

The Clancys purchased the home for $500,000 in 2018, nearly two years into their marriage, before they had any children. 

Jurors were shown troves of heartbreaking images, including the children’s drawings and family photos that once filled the home. 

Lindsay Clancy, 36, is accused of intentionally killing her three children, Cora, five, Dawson, three, and eight-month-old Callan, in January 2023

Lindsay Clancy, 36, is accused of intentionally killing her three children, Cora, five, Dawson, three, and eight-month-old Callan, in January 2023

After selling the home, Patrick Clancy said: 'There¿s no house anymore. There are no kids. All that¿s left is me and Lindsay'

After selling the home, Patrick Clancy said: ‘There’s no house anymore. There are no kids. All that’s left is me and Lindsay’

Phippen pushed back against plans for jurors to view the property in person. Judge William Sullivan (pictured) overruled the objection

Phippen pushed back against plans for jurors to view the property in person. Judge William Sullivan (pictured) overruled the objection

Jurors were allowed to inspect the home's exterior, upper floors and basement where the killings took place

Jurors were allowed to inspect the home’s exterior, upper floors and basement where the killings took place

Crime scene photos show the inside of the basement where the children were found strangled

Crime scene photos show the inside of the basement where the children were found strangled

At a June pretrial hearing, Phippen pushed back against plans for jurors to view the property in person, with his attorney, Peter Maguire, arguing it would be ‘massively disruptive’ for his client’s partner, pets and neighbors. 

Judge William Sullivan ultimately overruled the objection, allowing only jurors, attorneys, the judge and necessary court staff to take part.

Clancy’s attorney Kevin Reddington warned jurors during his opening statement on July 27 that the home ‘doesn’t look at all’ like it did when the Clancys lived there with their three children. 

On the morning of July 31, the 18 jurors, 12 women and six men, filed onto a large coach outside the courthouse before setting off for the home. 

During the walkthrough, jurors retraced Patrick’s steps from three years earlier, when he returned home to the horrific scene, inspecting the home’s exterior, upper floors and basement where the killings took place. 

On the night of the killings, Clancy placed a takeout order at ThreeV Restaurant in Plymouth for a Mediterranean power bowl for herself and scallop and pork belly risotto for Patrick. 

Sometime after 5pm, Patrick left to pick up the food order and stop at a local CVS for medication for Cora, errands Clancy had asked him to run. 

Just after 6pm, Patrick returned to a house that was ‘really quiet’ before racing upstairs to search for his family. 

The stairs leading down to the basement of the Clancy home where the children were found

The stairs leading down to the basement of the Clancy home where the children were found

The snow on the ground in the backyard of the Clancy home. The mom-of-three was paralyzed after landing on the ground

The snow on the ground in the backyard of the Clancy home. The mom-of-three was paralyzed after landing on the ground

The bedroom window from which Clancy jumped. Jurors were able to view the height for themselves during the tour

The bedroom window from which Clancy jumped. Jurors were able to view the height for themselves during the tour

Twelve jurors are now deliberating the mother's fate after the court heard closing arguments from the prosecution and defense yesterday

Twelve jurors are now deliberating the mother’s fate after the court heard closing arguments from the prosecution and defense yesterday

He found Clancy injured in the backyard and called 911. When emergency responders arrived, he went inside and discovered his three children dead in the basement, strangled with colored exercise bands. 

The jurors toured the property in groups of six, spending about 10 minutes each inspecting the home and backyard where Clancy was found that night. 

From the backyard, jurors had a clear view of the second-floor bedroom window she jumped from, giving them a better sense of the height and distance she fell.

Inside, they inspected rooms on both the first and second floors, including the bedroom and the window she jumped from. They also entered the basement where the three children were killed.

Although jurors were allowed to view the space, they were prohibited from opening closet doors or touching any items inside the home. 

Twelve jurors are now deliberating the mother’s fate after the court heard closing arguments from the prosecution and defense Thursday.

A total of nine women and three men, selected from the 18-member jury, will ultimately decide whether Clancy is guilty of first-degree murder, second-degree murder, manslaughter or not guilty by reason of insanity.

Lindsay Clancy’s Mindset During Critical Jury Deliberations

0

As jurors embarked on their second day of deliberations in Lindsay Clancy’s murder trial, her attorney shed light on her emotional state.  

Lindsay Clancy’s defense lawyer, Kevin Reddington, told reporters that she was feeling “sad,” “nervous,” and “scared,” as reported by NBC Boston and the Associated Press.

Reddington further expressed confidence that the jury, comprising nine women and three men, must evaluate all the evidence critically. He argued, “I believe that the government ultimately has not proven their case.”  

On January 24, 2023, Clancy tragically strangled her children, Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months, before leaping from a second-story window at her Duxbury home. Her actions left her paralyzed, now requiring the use of a wheelchair. She has entered a plea of not guilty, citing a lack of criminal responsibility. 

Throughout the trial, Reddington contended that Clancy was improperly medicated and suffering from postpartum psychosis when the incident occurred. The prosecution refuted these claims, asserting that while Clancy experienced depression, she was not psychotic and failed to adhere to her medication regimen or clearly convey her symptoms to healthcare providers. 

As both sides made their final cases to the jury Aug. 27, Clancy’s grief was on display.  

She dabbed her tears with a tissue as Reddington named each of her children and called them victims of a “horrible, horrific act.”  

She was overcome with emotion once again when Reddington presented a “wish jar” that she and her ex-husband Patrick Clancy bought on their honeymoon in Hawaii. Reddington explained how the jar contained written wishes from the couple to have healthy children, causing Clancy to close her eyes and wipe her tears.  

Later, Clancy took deep breaths and bowed her head as Second Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague outlined why the order of the killings—including first moving Dawson to a separate room where Cora couldn’t intervene—showed deliberation and “ordered thinking.”  

The jury must now decide Lindsay’s fate. 

She will either be found guilty of first-degree murder, second-degree murder or manslaughter or found not guilty due to lack of criminal responsibility. She will either face prison time or be committed to a psychiatric facility.  

Jury deliberations are set to resume Aug. 31.