Home Blog Page 80

Jim Acosta Says Trump’s Press Ban Is “Not the American Way”

0

During Thursday’s broadcast of MS NOW’s “The Briefing,” reporter Jim Acosta said President Donald Trump’s restrictions on the media are “not the American way.”

Acosta argued that the issue extends beyond Trump’s removal of hard passes and press credentials. He characterized it as a broader effort by the far right and the Trump administration to reshape the nation’s news media into something resembling a state-controlled system. In his view, deciding which outlets can cover the White House is only a small part of a larger push that includes MAGA families taking control of news networks. Acosta also said oligarchs should not own the country’s news media and that the public should have a greater role in controlling it.

“It’s just not the American way,” Acosta said, framing the dispute as a question about the country’s way of life. He questioned whether news organizations should be allowed access to federal buildings where government employees conduct the nation’s business. Acosta called Trump’s decision to ban and criticize the press in this manner “completely un-American.”

Follow Pam Key on X @pamkeyNEN

Man Who Slashed Ex-Girlfriend’s Throat Has Court Meltdown

0

A New York City man accused of stabbing his former girlfriend more than 20 times appeared visibly distressed in court before confronting a photographer who was taking his picture.

Candido Rodriguez appeared handcuffed in a Manhattan courtroom on Tuesday afternoon, wearing dark glasses and a beanie as he faced charges connected to the death of 33-year-old Melanie Woods.

Rodriguez, who had previously wept during his arraignment, interrupted the proceedings to object to being photographed.

After looking directly into the camera, he turned toward the three court officers standing behind him and complained about the photographer.

Although he was repeatedly told to face the judge, Rodriguez continued arguing until Judge Ann Scherzer intervened and asked what was causing the disruption.

‘Well, this is an open court,’ she said, before instructing the photographer to stop taking pictures of the defendant.

Rodriguez appeared from a psychiatric ward while awaiting an evaluation before trial. During the hearing, his legal team also discussed the possibility of negotiating a plea deal.

He has been charged with first-degree murder and criminal possession of a weapon in connection with Woods’s death.

Candido Rodriguez entered a Manhattan courtroom handcuffed on Tuesday afternoon in darkened glasses and a beanie as he faces charges over the death of Melanie Woods, 33

Candido Rodriguez appeared handcuffed in a Manhattan courtroom on Tuesday afternoon wearing dark glasses and a beanie as he faced charges in the death of 33-year-old Melanie Woods

Woods was found dead in April 2024 with over 20 stab wounds across her torso and legs and her neck slashed. Prosecutors alleged Woods returned from walking her dog in the early hours of April 23 after Rodriguez had sent a series of one-sided angry and hostile messages

Woods was discovered dead in April 2024 with more than 20 stab wounds to her torso and legs, as well as a slashed neck. Prosecutors alleged she returned from walking her dog in the early hours of April 23 after Rodriguez sent a series of angry, hostile messages

Rodriguez, who previously broke down in tears as he was arraigned in court, interrupted the courtroom as he turned to court officers stood behind him to protest the photographer

Rodriguez, who previously broke down in tears during his arraignment, interrupted the hearing and turned toward court officers to protest the photographer

Woods was found dead in April 2024 after suffering more than 20 stab wounds across her torso and legs. Her neck had also been slashed.

Prosecutors alleged that Woods had returned from walking her dog during the early hours of April 23, after Rodriguez sent a series of angry and hostile messages that appeared to go unanswered.

According to prosecutors, Rodriguez was waiting inside her Harlem apartment when she arrived home at about 7 a.m. Neighbors reportedly heard shouting, crashing sounds and screams.

The couple had been in an on-again, off-again relationship, and Woods had previously asked Rodriguez to stop contacting her, prosecutors said.

‘Around 8am, the noise stopped,’ Assistant Manhattan District Attorney Marcella Lupski said during Rodriguez’s arraignment.

‘A neighbor heard the door shut and footsteps going down the stairs,’ the prosecutor continued.

‘The defendant brutally murdered his ex-girlfriend and left her in the bathtub of her apartment.’

Lupski added that surveillance video allegedly showed Rodriguez leaving the building and hailing a cab at approximately 8:05 a.m.

As he was repeatedly directed to turn back around and face the judge, he continued to argue before Judge Ann Scherzer said it was an 'open court' before asking no more photos be taken

After being repeatedly told to turn around and face the judge, Rodriguez continued to argue. Judge Ann Scherzer then said the hearing was an ‘open court’ and asked that no further photographs be taken

The pair were in an on-off relationship and Woods had previously asked him not to contact her anymore

The pair were in an on-off relationship and Woods had previously asked him not to contact her anymore

Rodriguez's defense attorney asked for him to receive immediate medical treatment at his arraignment. The judge agreed to put him on suicide watch as he was seen 'incredibly distraught'

Rodriguez’s defense attorney asked for him to receive immediate medical treatment at his arraignment. The judge agreed to put him on suicide watch as he was seen ‘incredibly distraught’

Woods was later discovered when her friends grew concerned and asked for a wellness check from the New York City Police Department.

Rodriguez’s defense attorney asked for him to receive immediate medical treatment at his arraignment. The judge agreed to put him on suicide watch as he was seen ‘incredibly distraught.’

He wailed as he was brought into the courtroom and was inconsolable while his case was heard.

Woods was scheduled to go to California but did not make the flight, which concerned her mother and her friend who tracked her phone’s location to her apartment.

She was described as a loving dog owner who traveled, enjoyed adventure and was ‘always rooted for the underdog’.

‘To know Melanie was to love her,’ her family wrote on a GoFundMe. ‘She was a vibrant soul who brought out the best in anyone around her, this we will never forget.’

They sought funds to be able to bring her home to California.

‘It’s hard to say goodbye to someone who had a big impact on our lives,’ her family added.

Woods was scheduled to go to California but did not make the flight, which concerned her mother and her friend who tracked her phone¿s location to her apartment

Woods was scheduled to go to California but did not make the flight, which concerned her mother and her friend who tracked her phone’s location to her apartment

‘It’s always hard to lose someone you know, to let go of Melanie, and move on. But if we keep those good memories in our hearts and minds, we can find comfort and Melanie will always be with us.

‘Rest in peace, beautiful girl. We love you so much.’

Rodriguez is expected to return to court on December 1.  

Jay Jacobs Easily Reelected as New York State Democratic Party Chairman Despite Leadership Challenge

0

The New York State Democratic Party re-elected Jay Jacobs as its chairman Thursday, despite his decision not to endorse Zohran Mamdani in last year’s mayoral race.

Jacobs won 82% of the vote from party committee members. Caitlin Ogden, chair of the Otsego County Democratic Party, received 14%, while 4% of members abstained.

Gov. Kathy Hochul supported Jacobs’ bid for another term, even as some party insiders sought to remove him over his refusal to back Mamdani.

Jay Jacobs secured 82% of the vote to win re-election as New York State Democratic Party chairman, defeating challenger Caitlin Ogden. CQ-Roll Call, Inc via Getty Images

Jacobs is a strong supporter of Israel, while Hizzoner has sharply criticized the Jewish state and called for the arrest of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

During the mayoral campaign, Jacobs said he and Mamdani agreed that America’s most pressing challenge was the continued growth of income inequality, but differed fundamentally over how to address it.

“Furthermore, as I expressed to him directly, I strongly disagree with his views on the State of Israel, along with certain key policy positions,” Jacobs said.

Jacobs, who also leads the Nassau County Democratic Party, is viewed as a moderate voice in a party that has moved further left. That shift has been reflected in the victories of democratic socialists, including Mamdani in the mayoral race and congressional candidates Darializa Avila Chevalier and Claire Valdez.

NYC Mayor Zohran Mamdani speaks during a news conference at City Hall in New York, on Sept. 14, 2026.

NYC Mayor Zohran Mamdani speaks during a news conference at City Hall in New York, on Sept. 14, 2026. Bloomberg via Getty Images

He has led the state party during two separate stints spanning 10 years under former Gov. David Paterson, former Gov. Andrew Cuomo and Hochul. His latest victory gives him another two-year term.

“I am honored to be re-elected as New York State Democratic Party Chairman and ready to build on the success we have made to help elect Democrats up and down the ballot,” Jacobs said after Thursday’s party committee meeting in Tarrytown.

“We are a diverse and united party, and we have candidates all across the state who are standing up to Donald Trump’s attacks on our state and fighting for New York families. I am excited to continue working with the phenomenal leaders who are going to lead us to victory in November.”

Gainesville Man Arrested After Rape Allegation, Nude-Photo Threat

0

GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Javier Yadiel Copra Santiago, 22, was arrested and charged in connection with two separate cases involving allegations of forcible rape or sexual battery and extortion, according to law enforcement reports.

First incident

A Gainesville Police Department officer reported that Copra Santiago went to the first victim’s apartment on September 15 to pick her up for work. The woman told police that she and Copra Santiago considered themselves friends and had previously engaged in sexual relations.

According to the report, Copra Santiago wanted to spend time with the woman before taking her to work, but she refused, leading to an argument. She said he put her in a chokehold until she lost consciousness. After she woke up, she told officers, he bound her wrists with two black zip ties and threatened her with pliers. The woman said she feared he intended to torture or kill her.

The victim said Copra Santiago eventually removed the restraints, forced her to perform oral sex, ordered her to stand and photographed her. She said he then told her to get on the bed and raped her. Afterward, he drove her to work, where she went to a secluded location and contacted police.

She told investigators that none of the sexual acts were consensual. The woman also said Copra Santiago referred to himself as a “rapist” after the alleged assault and told her he did not expect to see her again because he had raped her.

Investigators reportedly found two cleanly cut black zip ties in the woman’s bedroom, along with a used condom.

The report states that Copra Santiago later texted the woman several times, asking to speak with her. She did not reply until officers were present and monitoring the exchange. When she told him she did not want to meet because he had raped her, he allegedly responded, “I have no clue what you’re talking about I gave you a ride to work that’s it” and called the allegation “a big accusation.” He continued asking to speak with her “face to face.”

After being read his Miranda rights, Copra Santiago reportedly denied having sexual contact with the woman other than kissing her once while his wife was present. He said he had only been inside her apartment when helping her move in roughly a year earlier, denied seeing her at any point in September 2026 and said he had not driven her to work. He told investigators he did not know why she would accuse him of rape, then declined to answer additional questions.

Second incident

In a separate case, an Alachua County Sheriff’s deputy reported that the second victim contacted authorities on September 23 after receiving threatening messages from an unfamiliar phone number. The sender allegedly threatened to post nude photographs of her on Facebook and share them with her family. She told investigators that she believed the images had been taken from her own phone.

The messages proposed a deal: If the woman sent additional photographs, the sender would “disappear like poof [dust cloud emoji].” Other messages allegedly read, “No exposing no embarrassment when u try to go to the police for a fake number,” and, “Aight it’s all up online by tomorrow they’ll be on Facebook too and instagram and Snapchat [shrug emoji].”

The woman told deputies she suspected Copra Santiago because he lived nearby and had previously borrowed her phone. She said that during the call, he returned to his apartment and was away for at least 40 minutes.

Copra Santiago initially said he had remained near the woman while making the call, but later acknowledged returning to his apartment and being gone for about 20 minutes. He denied sending her the threatening messages. When shown screenshots, he reportedly claimed they had been fabricated. He also said investigators would not find photographs of the woman on his phone. The device was seized during his arrest, although the report does not indicate whether it had been examined beforehand.

Charges and bail

Copra Santiago faces charges of forcible rape and extortion, according to the arrest information. The Gainesville Police Department report says he was born in Puerto Rico and is a U.S. citizen with no prior criminal history. Judge Meshon Rawls ordered him held without bail pending a hearing on the State Attorney’s Office request to keep him jailed without bail through trial. If that request is denied, the judge will set bail at the hearing.

Flydubai Pilot Reveals Difficult Battle to Open Cockpit Door

0

A heroic pilot who was stabbed by his co-pilot during a FlyDubai flight has said he could not stand by and let others die after managing to save 174 passengers from disaster on Wednesday.

Smit ​Machchhar, pictured with a tube in his nose and bandages covering his head and hands, spoke with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi from his hospital bed in Abu Dhabi. The nearly 10-minute conversation was shared on the prime minister’s social media channels.

Machchhar explained how he forced open the cockpit door while under attack, allowing passengers to reach the attacker.

“I fell to the floor and felt that the plane was sinking. I knew that if I could give one last push and open the door, I could save everyone,” he said.

“At that moment, I was fighting for my life. I realised that if I did not act, everyone could die. I was already wounded and had many injuries, but I knew I had to do something.”

“I said to myself, ‘If I don’t get up…’ As I lay on the floor, I could feel the plane sinking. The door was right there. Even though I had been beaten, I managed to open it.”

“Everyone played an equal part in this. What I did was to save my own life, but at the same time I knew I could not let everyone else die.”

Modi praised Machchhar’s courage and quick thinking, saying the pilot’s actions had saved lives and upheld the reputation of Indian aviators.

Smit ​Machchhar, seen with a tube in his nose and bandages on his head and hands, spoke to Indian PM Narendra Modi from a hospital bed

Smit ​Machchhar, pictured with a tube in his nose and bandages on his head and hands, spoke to Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi from a hospital bed

Graphic footage filmed by passengers on the flight shows the wounded pilot Smit Machchhar lying on the floor as others tend to him

Graphic footage filmed by passengers shows the wounded pilot Smit Machchhar lying on the floor while others care for him

Machchhar, who comes from Mumbai, India’s financial capital, suffered serious injuries in Wednesday’s attack. Despite being wounded, he opened the cockpit door, enabling passengers to enter and restrain the attacker as the Boeing 737 began a steep descent.

His actions have earned him widespread praise, with world leaders saying he helped avert a potentially catastrophic disaster.

The FlyDubai flight was carrying 182 people from Dubai to Tel Aviv when it was diverted to Tabuk in northwestern Saudi Arabia, where it made an emergency landing.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said the attacker, an Omani national, had been arrested in Saudi Arabia and was being interrogated there. His motive remained unclear.

Machchhar told Modi that he recited the Hanuman Chalisa during the ordeal. The Hindu devotional hymn, dedicated to Lord Hanuman, is traditionally recited as a prayer for strength and courage.

“Lord Hanuman gave me courage,” he said before becoming emotional. “I feel so proud of myself. I’m sorry for crying in front of you.”

Modi replied: “If you don’t get emotional in front of me, in front of whom will you?”

Machchhar is married and has two children. According to his LinkedIn profile, he has worked for FlyDubai for around four years.

Before joining the airline, he spent 11 years at SpiceJet, the Indian low-cost carrier, where he worked as a senior commander and line training captain. He recorded more than 9,750 flying hours with SpiceJet.

“I am not looking at this wound as a wound, because that would make my recovery even more difficult,” Machchhar said.

‘I am looking at it as a journey which is slowly going on and will take time but I am confident that the recovery will be there and I will become fit and healthy again.’

The Omani co-pilot who stabbed Machchhar had undergone radical Islamist indoctrination and was clearly suicidal, Israel’s prime minister said Thursday.

‘We know that he underwent Islamist radical indoctrination. That appears to be something we are gathering from his personal information,’ Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said in an interview with Fox News.

Musaev recounted how he rushed to the aid of the dying Machchhar – as the attacker pleaded with him to end his life

Musaev recounted how he rushed to the aid of the dying Machchhar – as the attacker pleaded with him to end his life

Two Israeli security officials said their initial assessment is that the co-pilot, identified by as an Omani national, was likely acting alone, though the investigation was still ongoing.

The flight plunged more than 14,000ft in less than 30 seconds during the incident as it flew over Saudi Arabia on the journey from the United Arab Emirates to Israel, according to the flight-tracking website Flightradar24.

Netanyahu said it was clear that the co-pilot who carried out the stabbing was suicidal.

‘It looks very likely that he was going to down the plane,’ Netanyahu said. Coupled with ‘the Islamist tendencies, that radicalisation that are found in his background, I think that’s… a pretty good clue,’ he said, without elaborating.

‘But again, I don’t make final conclusions yet. But that’s the indications we have now,’ he added.

The United Arab Emirates has started investigations seeking to establish the circumstances and motives and determine ‘whether the incident was linked to any terrorist activity or purpose, or involved prior planning or direction’, the UAE state news agency reported on Thursday.

New footage has since emerged of the bloodied knifeman sat on the floor of the plane as his head is bowed and hands are tied – while Machchhar is stretchered out. 

One of the heroic passengers on board was Georgian Jewish dentist, Dr Musaev. 

Speaking exclusively to the Daily Mail after returning to Israel, the 47-year-old recounted how he rushed to the aid of the dying Machchhar – as the attacker pleaded with him to end his life. 

‘Everything was going smoothly when, suddenly, we felt the aircraft drop sharply. 

‘We thought it was just turbulence. I took out my camera and started filming. Exactly half a minute later, we heard noises from the front: shouting, and a woman screaming, “Knife! Knife!”,’ Musaev said. 

‘That was when I got up. I realised it was a terrorist attack and joined the people ahead of us, who were the first to rush into the cockpit and pull the terrorist out.’

The group of four men, he recounted, then ‘grabbed the attacker by the neck’ as they dragged him out of the cockpit. 

‘We tied the terrorist up, binding his hands and feet,’ he added. ‘[The attacker said] nothing apart from begging us: “Kill me”.’ 

In the same moment, Musaev was pleaded with by the dying captain as he helped administer first aid, who said: ‘Save me. I don’t want to die here.’

‘The pilot was losing a lot of blood,’ he said. ‘His arm was badly slashed, as was his neck, and he had a very deep wound at the back of his head. 

‘Everything in the cockpit was covered in blood, but he was conscious. We were effectively left without first-aid supplies. Somehow, we managed to stop the bleeding with pieces of cloth.’ 

Energy Department Employee Ashton Ellaboudy Arrested in Houthi Case

0

A Department of Energy electrical engineer has been arrested on allegations that he provided support to the Iranian-backed Houthi rebels, including purchasing materials for homemade explosives and drones and traveling to Yemen, the Justice Department said Thursday.

Ashton Hamed Ellaboudy, 51, of Richland, Washington, was taken into custody Thursday and is scheduled to make his first court appearance Friday. Court records do not identify an attorney who could comment on his behalf.

According to the FBI, Ellaboudy aimed to help the Houthis strengthen their communications capabilities. Investigators say he traveled to Yemen last September, as renewed fighting between the Houthis and Saudi-backed government forces has killed hundreds of people and displaced tens of thousands.

The conflict dates back to 2014, when the Iran-backed rebels seized control of the capital, Sanaa, forcing Yemen’s government to operate from exile in Saudi Arabia.

After returning to the United States, authorities say, Ellaboudy told Customs and Border Protection officers that he had come back from Oman after a work trip. He allegedly claimed he had been part of a U.S. government mission inspecting missile defense systems.

However, investigators interviewed Ellaboudy’s supervisor, who said he knew of no international travel involving Ellaboudy and was unaware of any Energy Department missile inspection program to which the engineer would have been assigned, according to an FBI affidavit.

The affidavit also says Ellaboudy was recorded speaking with FBI informants brought into the investigation. He allegedly told them that he had been smuggled into and out of Yemen and had hoped to reach the capital to establish government-level contacts.

The FBI said Ellaboudy ultimately did not reach Sanaa.

Investigators began examining Ellaboudy’s activities after learning that he had purchased precursor chemicals often used to make homemade explosives, including acetone and sodium bisulfate. They also discovered that he had bought components used in drones, the FBI said.

During the investigation, Ellaboudy communicated with several informants, including one who presented himself as a Houthi colonel. The FBI says Ellaboudy offered guidance and assistance involving communications equipment.

Ellaboudy faces charges under a federal law that prohibits providing material support to an organization designated by the United States as a foreign terrorist organization. The Houthis are included on that list.

“These allegations are so deeply disturbing that they almost defy imagination,” John Eisenberg, the assistant attorney general overseeing the Justice Department’s National Security Division, said in a statement.

West Suburban Residents Demand Answers on Proposed O’Hare Flyer Train

0

FOREST PARK, Ill. (WLS) — Just weeks after River Forest officials formally rejected the proposal, residents from communities across the western suburbs gathered in Forest Park Thursday night for a closer look at the planned O’Hare Flyer.

The community meeting featured representatives of the O’Hare Flyer, a privately financed express rail line proposed to connect downtown Chicago with O’Hare International Airport.

The discussion highlighted sharply different views about how the project could affect neighborhoods and municipalities along its proposed route.

Forest Park resident Cary McLean said the rail line could bring significant disruption to nearby homes and neighborhoods.

“If the O’Hare Flyer get this corridor, they win, we lose. No mitigation fixes a train every 7.5 minutes behind our homes,” McLean said.

O’Hare Flyer CEO and co-founder Dave Lundy countered that the project could deliver substantial economic gains throughout the region.

“You’re talking about thousands of jobs. You’re talking about the ability to bring conventions and corporate headquarters to Chicago,” Lundy said.

Forest Park Commissioner Maria Maxham said residents still need answers about the project’s potential effects on traffic, the economy and property values.

“I don’t think aspirational stories or anecdotes are enough to prove that this is a project that we should pursue,” Maxham said.

Lundy called the O’Hare Flyer a potential economic game changer and noted that details about the plan have been public for weeks. He added that misinformation has fueled much of the opposition.

“We are trying to be as transparent, as accessible as possible. It’s the reason we’re here,” Lundy said. “The more we can do to talk to the community and give them direct information, the more people are gonna understand what the benefits of the project are.”

Supporters also emphasized the potential for new jobs, infrastructure improvements and broader economic development.

“We want to see local jobs for local workers, and we want to see more infrastructure happening in Chicago,” said Nick Medina of Laborers’ Local One.

Opponents, meanwhile, said the concerns are not limited to one neighborhood. They pointed to potential impacts on residents in several municipalities along the proposed rail corridor.

With the debate over the O’Hare Flyer continuing, supporters and critics alike made clear that more discussion lies ahead.

Copyright © 2026 WLS-TV. All Rights Reserved.

Suella Braverman Told She Is Being ‘Racist Against Herself’

0

Suella Braverman was challenged on BBC Question Time after a Black audience member accused her of “being racist against herself” for saying she does not identify as English, despite being born in Britain.

The Reform UK education spokesperson told the programme that she considers herself “British of Asian ethnicity”, rather than English, because of her family background.

The former Conservative home secretary was speaking during a debate in Tottenham, north London, when an audience member said her position risked reinforcing a racist argument.

The 54-year-old man told Mrs Braverman he would be “very rich” if he had received a penny every time someone had told him he was not English, despite being born in the country.

He agreed when the London-born politician suggested that she was “being racist against myself”, prompting her to reply: “Right, well that makes a lot of sense.”

The exchange came as Mrs Braverman discussed the meaning of English identity while promoting her new book, Patriot: Empire, Betrayal and Hope, which explores her family history.

Her father, Chris, was born in Kenya, while her mother, Uma, was born in Mauritius. Both have Indian ancestry, and Mrs Braverman also has French Creole and Portuguese heritage.

Another audience member referred to former prime minister Rishi Sunak’s recent explanation of “why he’s English”, saying it should never have been necessary for his identity to be questioned.

Reform UK's education spokesperson Suella Braverman appears on Question Time last night

Reform UK education spokesperson Suella Braverman appeared on Question Time last night

A 54-year-old man in the audience in Tottenham suggested Mrs Braverman was being racist

A 54-year-old audience member in Tottenham accused Mrs Braverman of being racist

Presenter Fiona Bruce said the discussion followed comments from Mr Sunak, who had spoken about being portrayed as “a brown Hindu who was British but couldn’t be English”.

She then asked Mrs Braverman to expand on her own view after noting that the politician had described herself as British but not English.

Mrs Braverman replied: “Doesn’t sound very controversial to me, but suddenly it has become debatable. I was born in London, North London actually, in 1980.

“My parents came to this country as immigrants with nothing. I am very grateful to Britain for the hand of friendship it extended to them.

“I have always considered myself British of Asian ethnicity, and that is something I have never questioned. Of course I’m not English. I’m not an English person.

“I am of Asian origin. In my book, I trace some of my ancestry, with relatives originating in India and moving through Mauritius and Kenya before spreading across the world. They are not English, so it would misrepresent me to claim Englishness as an ethnicity.”

She added that if someone with her background had been born in Japan, she would not describe herself as Japanese, and would similarly not call herself Chinese if she had been born in China.

Mrs Braverman continued: “Why are the English the only people on earth who cannot have a distinct identity? It baffles me that this has suddenly become a debate, and I do not want to deny my Asian heritage.

“I am British Asian, as millions of people in this country consider themselves to be. I do not see why that is controversial. I can be born in England, support the England football team and love England.”

Suella with her parents Chris, who was born in Kenya, and Uma, who was born in Mauritius

Suella Braverman pictured with her parents, Chris, who was born in Kenya, and Uma, who was born in Mauritius

Bruce then questioned her on her stance, asking ‘how far back’ you should go to be considered ‘fully English’, adding: ‘Are we talking 1066, are we talking three generations?’

Mrs Braverman accused her of asking the question ‘a bit facetiously’ and insisted there was ‘no fixed date’, but Bruce pressed her to explain further.

Mrs Braverman told her: ‘Obviously you take a reasonable approach, but my parents were not born in England, my grandparents were not born in England so in my particular instance, no, I am not of English origin.’

She added: ‘I’m not the one saying that it has to be five generations or four generations. 

‘I think it becomes pretty obvious when people have got a lineage, an ancestry, a connection to the heritage of this country which dates back a few generations. And I think that that is not unreasonable to expect of people who come to this country.’

Bruce concluded: ‘So, okay, a few generations. I’m not sure how many.’

Later in the show, the 54-year-old audience member told Mrs Braverman: ‘I think what you’ve done is just basically reinforce the racist argument.

‘I’ve been on this planet for 54 years and the amount of times I’ve been told I’m not English even though I was born here. If I’d had a penny for every time I’ve been given that.’

Bruce asked him: ‘And do you consider yourself English, can I ask you?’

Suella Braverman with Rishi Sunak in May 2023 when she was home secretary and he was PM. Mr Sunak recently said he was described as a 'brown Hindu' who was British but not English

Suella Braverman with Rishi Sunak in May 2023 when she was home secretary and he was PM. Mr Sunak recently said he was described as a ‘brown Hindu’ who was British but not English

And the man replied: ‘Absolutely, absolutely. So what you’ve done is reinforce the argument.’

Mrs Braverman then asked: ‘I’m being racist against myself?’

The man agreed, saying ‘basically you are’, and she replied: ‘Right. Well, that makes a lot of sense.’

Mrs Braverman continued: ‘I’m not going to be racist… I believe we can have a cohesive society that unites around British identity. But I also want to pay respect to the English people and I don’t think that is something controversial.’

The man asked her: ‘No one’s disrespecting English people. Do you understand what the word indigenous means? If you were born here, you’re indigenous. Yeah? Simple.’

Energy secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh, who was also on the panel, then came in and told Mrs Braverman: ‘I don’t know, Suella. It makes me really sad. I think the reason our politics has been so coarse around immigration are arguments that have been sort of put on display here.

‘I come at this issue as a first generation migrant who came to this country to seek refuge and I know that this country is a welcoming tolerant country and I’m a product of it.

‘It’s tragic that we cannot have a sensible debate around immigration that there are these undercurrents of racism that are put into it so that we can’t look at the problem. The system is broken and the two people sitting here who are part of a government that broke it.’

The other panel members on the BBC One programme were the Conservative shadow business secretary Julia Lopez and the journalist and podcaster Oli Dugmore.

  • Question Time is available to stream on BBC iPlayer here 

READ MORE: Britain’s real racists? The Lefties who called me a ‘coconut’ for daring to say we must curb mass immigration: SUELLA BRAVERMAN