The former police officer accused of killing a young jogger who was training for the New York City Marathon has claimed that Allah instructed him to carry out the attack.
Speaking from Rikers Island, Sayed Mohassib, 27, offered a chilling account of the October 30 killing of 28-year-old Katie Suarez. His comments, reported by The New York Post, appeared to show no remorse as he described the fatal stabbing.
‘Allah told me to kill a person, so I killed her, the jogger Katie Suarez,’ he said. ‘Two days before it happened, Allah told me I had to kill a person.’
Mohassib said he had never met Suarez and claimed he had no personal reason to target her. ‘I didn’t know her, she was just there,’ he said.
Wearing a khaki jail uniform open at the chest, revealing tattoos of a tiger, a shark and Allah, Mohassib appeared composed while recounting the killing and repeatedly invoked God.
‘Allah told me to do it, so I did it,’ he said, offering no indication that he questioned the alleged instruction.
Asked whether he had a message for Suarez’s grieving family, he gave the same response: ‘No. Allah told me to do it.’
Suarez, a 28-year-old bank teller who had attended Brooklyn College, was jogging along a waterfront promenade in Bath Beach when prosecutors say she was attacked in a seemingly random assault.
Sayed Mohassib showed no apparent remorse while describing what he claimed were divine orders, telling The Post from jail: ‘Allah told me to kill a person, so I killed her, the jogger Katie Suarez’
Katie Suarez, 28, was jogging along a Bath Beach waterfront promenade on October 30 when Mohassib allegedly targeted her. The bank teller and former Brooklyn College student was stabbed twice in the neck in what investigators described as a seemingly unprovoked attack
Mohassib, a former Marine, elementary school educator and police officer, allegedly abandoned his duty of care under the guise of religious instruction. He initially denied responsibility when questioned by detectives
She suffered two stab wounds to the neck and was left critically injured. Her father discovered her unconscious and bleeding on the path.
Although she was placed on life support, Suarez died three days later.
In the jailhouse interview, Mohassib described the killing as a series of deliberate acts, appearing to contradict what he initially told investigators.
Detectives at the 62nd Precinct were reportedly told that he had blacked out and later awakened covered in blood with the knife still in his possession.
His account to The Post was markedly different. ‘I got home from work, I got the knife, and I killed her,’ he said. ‘I went home, I cleaned up.’
He also acknowledged that he first denied involvement before changing his story. ‘At first I said that I didn’t do it, but now I’m saying that I did it because Allah told me to.’
Mohassib has not yet entered a formal plea to the second-degree murder charge.
Investigators say Mohassib told them he discarded the knife in the garbage. The weapon has not been found, and detectives believe it may have reached a landfill in New Jersey.
The allegations have drawn renewed attention to Mohassib’s background. He previously served as a Marine and police officer before returning to work at a New York City elementary school despite reported concerns about his behavior.
Mohassib and Suarez attended Brooklyn College at the same time, although he told The Post that he did not know the woman he is accused of killing
When asked whether he had anything to say to Suarez’s grieving relatives, Mohassib replied: ‘No. Allah told me to do it’
Mohassib spent only six weeks with the NYPD in 2022 before leaving to join the US Marine Corps. Reports say his military service ended when he was deemed psychologically unfit and discharged.
Three months later, he reportedly attempted to return to the NYPD. His application was rejected after he allegedly arrived at a police station looking disheveled and behaving erratically. Sources told The Post that he was taken to Bellevue Hospital that day.
After the police department declined to rehire him, Mohassib returned to the Department of Education, where he had previously worked as a paraprofessional.
He worked at PS 200 elementary school in Bath Beach and, according to reports, returned to the classroom after Suarez was killed.
Colleagues later reportedly observed him speaking to himself, making incoherent statements and acting erratically.
Reports of concerning behavior also extended beyond his workplace. Sources said relatives had previously called 911 after Mohassib threatened to ‘chop them up.’
Neighbors described a marked change in his conduct. One told The Post that Mohassib seemed different after returning from a trip to his native Egypt.
‘He came back different. I don’t know what happened,’ the neighbor said.
Mohassib was arrested at his Bensonhurst home on November 7, eight days after the fatal attack. He faces a second-degree murder charge and is scheduled to appear in court on December 4
In another reported incident, he was seen leaving his Brooklyn home wearing only underwear.
Police arrested Mohassib at his Bensonhurst residence on November 7, eight days after the attack. He was wearing a bright red Von Dutch jacket and appeared largely emotionless as officers took him into custody. A bystander shouted an expletive at him from across the street.
He faces a second-degree murder charge and is due back in court on December 4.